1 / 42

Andrea Saltelli, European Commission, Joint Research Centre andrea.saltellijrc.it ECOINFORMATICS meeting US Environme

2. On uncertainty

blake
Download Presentation

Andrea Saltelli, European Commission, Joint Research Centre andrea.saltellijrc.it ECOINFORMATICS meeting US Environme

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


    1. 1

    2. 2 A few words about science , uncertainty and quality – a kernel A few words about science , uncertainty and quality – a kernel

    3. 3 The 1997 ozone fight, even more clearly than the 2008 rerun, was a case of a policy debate masquerading as a science debate. In such instances, scientists ought to be busy ripping off the policymakers’ masks, not donning them. The 1997 ozone fight, even more clearly than the 2008 rerun, was a case of a policy debate masquerading as a science debate. In such instances, scientists ought to be busy ripping off the policymakers’ masks, not donning them.

    4. 4 Briefly back to uncertainty at the science – law-policy interface, we now move from controversy in society (on the books we all keep on our bedside table such as Diamond & Crichton) to the policy arena, where regulators, stakeholders and industry fight an all out battle. Briefly back to uncertainty at the science – law-policy interface, we now move from controversy in society (on the books we all keep on our bedside table such as Diamond & Crichton) to the policy arena, where regulators, stakeholders and industry fight an all out battle.

    5. 5 … while increasing the opportunities for peer review by researchers independent from the regulators seemed designed … … while increasing the opportunities for peer review by researchers independent from the regulators seemed designed …

    6. 6 … while increasing the opportunities for peer review by researchers independent from the regulators seemed designed … … while increasing the opportunities for peer review by researchers independent from the regulators seemed designed …

    7. 7

    8. 8

    9. 9 … much of the Netherlands, Bangladesh, and the seaboard of eastern U.S., many low lying Pacific islands, the deltas of Nile and Mekong rivers, and the coastal and riverbank… much of the Netherlands, Bangladesh, and the seaboard of eastern U.S., many low lying Pacific islands, the deltas of Nile and Mekong rivers, and the coastal and riverbank

    10. 10 Michael Crichton’s position is that of the skeptics of the anthropogenic nature of global change and its impact. Bjorn Lomborg school, Skeptical Environmentalist, Copenhagen Consensus project. How can one form an opinion about whether sea levels are rising or not. Michael Crichton’s position is that of the skeptics of the anthropogenic nature of global change and its impact. Bjorn Lomborg school, Skeptical Environmentalist, Copenhagen Consensus project. How can one form an opinion about whether sea levels are rising or not.

    11. 11 Global change is typified as a typical ‘wrong idea’ driven by the politico-legal-media complex (PMC). Global change is typified as a typical ‘wrong idea’ driven by the politico-legal-media complex (PMC).

    12. 12

    13. 13

    14. 14

    15. 15

    16. 16 Note: Pilkey’s book has a good state of the art on the sea level rise story. Note: Pilkey’s book has a good state of the art on the sea level rise story.

    17. 17

    18. 18

    19. 19

    20. 20

    21. 21 The book is Life Itself, a Comprehensive Inquiry into the Nature, Origin, and Fabrication of Life The book is Life Itself, a Comprehensive Inquiry into the Nature, Origin, and Fabrication of Life

    22. 22 The book is The revenge of the crystal 1999 - studies mostly effects of the image machine on our imaginations and systems of meaning. Maybe Crichton has read it?The book is The revenge of the crystal 1999 - studies mostly effects of the image machine on our imaginations and systems of meaning. Maybe Crichton has read it?

    23. 23 Jeroen van der Sluijs (UU Copernicus Institute) has written extensively on science’s crisis of credibility of model use, following the the Netherlands media scandal of 1999 (RIVM). On present day uncertainty assessment practice: “the uncertainties which are more carefully scrutinised are usually those which are the least relevant” (lampposting). Nassim Nicholas Taleb calls this ‘The delusion of uncertainty’ (The Black Swan, 2007 Penguin). Jeroen van der Sluijs (UU Copernicus Institute) has written extensively on science’s crisis of credibility of model use, following the the Netherlands media scandal of 1999 (RIVM). On present day uncertainty assessment practice: “the uncertainties which are more carefully scrutinised are usually those which are the least relevant” (lampposting). Nassim Nicholas Taleb calls this ‘The delusion of uncertainty’ (The Black Swan, 2007 Penguin).

    24. 24 When the photographer caught Silvio in this plastic pose he was telling us about the rupture of the relation between the God and the Truth…When the photographer caught Silvio in this plastic pose he was telling us about the rupture of the relation between the God and the Truth…

    25. 25 Tackles quality issue in the management of uncertainty, including value-ladenness Internal extension of peer community (involvement of other disciplines)* External extension of peer community (involvement of stakeholders in environmental assessment & quality control) *PNS in the UK “in a situation where different disciplines and paradigms are brought together with a view to co-operation, such as in policy development, bridging boundaries is of key importance to stave off impasse.” Lorenzoni et al., Futures Tackles quality issue in the management of uncertainty, including value-ladenness Internal extension of peer community (involvement of other disciplines)* External extension of peer community (involvement of stakeholders in environmental assessment & quality control) *PNS in the UK “in a situation where different disciplines and paradigms are brought together with a view to co-operation, such as in policy development, bridging boundaries is of key importance to stave off impasse.” Lorenzoni et al., Futures

    26. 26 Tackles quality issue in the management of uncertainty, including value-ladenness Internal extension of peer community (involvement of other disciplines)* External extension of peer community (involvement of stakeholders in environmental assessment & quality control) *PNS in the UK “in a situation where different disciplines and paradigms are brought together with a view to co-operation, such as in policy development, bridging boundaries is of key importance to stave off impasse.” Lorenzoni et al., Futures Tackles quality issue in the management of uncertainty, including value-ladenness Internal extension of peer community (involvement of other disciplines)* External extension of peer community (involvement of stakeholders in environmental assessment & quality control) *PNS in the UK “in a situation where different disciplines and paradigms are brought together with a view to co-operation, such as in policy development, bridging boundaries is of key importance to stave off impasse.” Lorenzoni et al., Futures

    27. 27

    28. 28 I must add here a short commercial advising you to buy Jerry’s bookI must add here a short commercial advising you to buy Jerry’s book

    29. 29 Let us go back to workbench to make sense of model based inferenceLet us go back to workbench to make sense of model based inference

    30. 30 Let us go back to workbench to make sense of model based inferenceLet us go back to workbench to make sense of model based inference

    31. 31 Global change is typified as a typical ‘wrong idea’ driven by the politico-legal-media complex (PMC). ? Bruce has something to say <<Scientist tend to ‘find’ depending on ‘fund’>> Global change is typified as a typical ‘wrong idea’ driven by the politico-legal-media complex (PMC). ? Bruce has something to say <<Scientist tend to ‘find’ depending on ‘fund’>>

    32. 32

    33. 33

    34. 34 Thanks for any additional material from US and CanadaThanks for any additional material from US and Canada

    35. 35 Thanks for any additional material from US and CanadaThanks for any additional material from US and Canada

    36. 36 Thanks for any additional material from US and CanadaThanks for any additional material from US and Canada

    37. 37

    38. 38 Thanks for any additional material from US and CanadaThanks for any additional material from US and Canada

    39. 39

    40. 40

    41. 41 Balance of power tilted Balance of power tilted

    42. 42

    43. 43

More Related