1 / 17

Procedure in the criminal courts and the doctrine of precedent

14th December , 2011. Procedure in the criminal courts and the doctrine of precedent. Find the words in the text that mean the following: accusation , attack , entrust , postpone , proof , punishment Three cases are mentioned in the text. Find the following information:

chipo
Download Presentation

Procedure in the criminal courts and the doctrine of precedent

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. 14th December, 2011 Procedure inthecriminalcourtsandthedoctrineofprecedent

  2. Find the words in the text that mean the following: accusation, attack, entrust, postpone, proof, punishment Three cases are mentioned in the text. Find the following information: a) who are the accused b) what are the facts of the case c) what is the final decision of the court

  3. the procedure ofthecriminalcourts is governedbytheCriminal Procedure Ruleswhich: • laydowntheoverridingobjectivewhicheveryone must follow to dealwithcasesjustly • givecourtsexplicitpowers to activelymanagethepreparationofcasestopreventunfairdelaysandpromotecertainty Criminal procedure

  4. consistof 10 principal subjectdivisions: • overridingobjectiveandcase management • preliminaryproceedings • custodyandbail • disclosureofevidence • thetrial • thesentencing • contemptof court • appeals • costs Criminal procedure rules

  5. Prosecutionmaybebroughtby: • theCrownPorsecution Service (the state) • establishedin 1985 • theyreviewthecasespassed to thembythe police to seeifthere is enoughevidence for a realisticchance for convictionandifthere is public interest • privateindividuals or businesses • anindividualhas to present a writenaccountoftheallegedoffence to a magistrate • the magistrate issues a summons on thedefendant • thecase is heard at theMagistrates’ Court

  6. indictable offences • can be tried only after an indictment after a preliminary hearing to determine if there is a prima facie case to answer or by a grand jury • the first hearing is held at the Magistrates’ Court • the trial is held at the Crown Court • in the USA it is called a felony Categoriesofoffences

  7. triableeitherwayoffences • canbetriedeither on indictment or summarily • thetrialtakes place either at theMagistrates’ Court or theCrown Court after a Mode ofTrialhearing at which a magistrate decidesifthecase is suitable to beheard at theMagistrates’ Court • ifyesthedefendantcanagree or ask for a trialbyjury (iftheplea is notguilty) • ifno (thecase is tooserious or complex) thecase is sent to theCrown Court

  8. summary offences • can be tried without an indictment or a jury • always tried at the Magistrates’ Court • may be sent to the Crown Court for sentencing • involve a maximum penalty of six months in prison or a fine of up to £5000 • in the USA: amisdemeanor

  9. indictableoffences (298) • murder, manslaughter, rape, incest, robbery, burglary (alsoattemptedoffencesandconspiracy) • treason, assassination, espionage • blackmail, extortion, arsonwithintent to endanger life • causingdeathbydangerousdriving • possessionof a firearm or imitationfirearm • wilfulmisconductinjudicial/public office • pervertingthecauseofjustice • escapefromprison, aidingandabbettingescapefromprison, prisonmutiny Examples

  10. summaryoffences • commonassault • motoringoffences (drinkdriving, unlicenseddriving) • shoplifting, propertydamage • drunkanddisorderly • bigamy • bribery

  11. triableeitherwayoffences • assaultcausingbodilyharm, assaulting a prisonofficer • theft, taking a vehiclewithoutconsent • drivingwhiledisqualified • obtainingpropertybydeception • drugsoffences • embezzlement

  12. also called stare decisis (stand by the decision) • policy of courts to abide by the principles established in earlier cases • judicial precedent • a judicial decision that serves as a rule for future decisions in similar cases • can be made only by superior courts Thedoctrineofprecedent

  13. A judgementconsistof: 1. ratiodecidendi • thecoreoftheessential legal principle • legal reasonsofpreviousdecisions must beknown • binding 2. obiterdicta • observationsmadebythejudge • non-binding Judicialprecedent

  14. original precedent - when there are no similar past cases, the judge will look at those closest in principle binding precedent - precedent form an earlier case which must be followed persuasive precedent - non-binding on the court but the judge may consider it and apply it Typesofprecedent

  15. rigidity • circumstances are changing faster than the law • complexity • difficult to find a relevant case and distinguish between ratio decidendi and obiter dicta • distinction • very difficult to find differences or similarities between the cases disadvantages

  16. Point of law - decided by a judge as it involves the interpretation and application of legal principles or statutes Point of fact - decided by a jury as it involves the interpretation of circumstances surrounding the facts of the case What is to bedecided on?

  17. Thankyou!

More Related