1 / 16

Dominant vs. Resistant Readings

Dominant vs. Resistant Readings. ‘Reading’. a way of thinking about the world series of prejudices/assumptions of the way the world is. affected by our family, schooling, and society various texts support or rely on these assumptions. Different Readings. Dominant Reading:

drake
Download Presentation

Dominant vs. Resistant Readings

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Dominant vs. Resistant Readings

  2. ‘Reading’ • a way of thinking about the world • series of prejudices/assumptions of the way the world is. • affected by our family, schooling, and society • various texts support or rely on these assumptions

  3. Different Readings Dominant Reading: follows, supports or does not question the way of thinking shared by the writer and the society in which he/she writes Resistant Reading: one that challenges the biases, prejudices or set of assumptions shared by the writer and the society in which she/he writes.

  4. Dominant Reading of LRRH • Children should obey their parents because disobedience is dangerous. • It is dangerous to talk to strangers. • Females are vulnerable but can rely on men to protect them. • Males are rescuers. Males are stronger than females and better able to protect themselves and others

  5. What’s the point?! • texts are a model for life • affect our way of thinking about the world (and what the world should be like) • if our texts are sexist, classist, racist then sexism, classism, racism will seep into our world.

  6. Gender Readings • ‘sex’ • biological term referring to concrete differences • ‘gender’ • prejudices and assumptions concerning stereotypical characteristics • roles that are created by society • both sexes are forced (through expectations) to fulfill these roles

  7. LOOK FOR: Stereotypes Women: • emotional, caring, irrational, afraid of spiders Men: • strong, silent, rational, equipped with innate instincts for spider combat

  8. Goal of Gender Readings • Women often portrayed as weak, helpless, illogical and in need of rescue by men • explains gender inequality, creating an imbalance of power • men are almost always in the more powerful positions • women are reduced to objects • revealing these assumptions means they can be combated

  9. LOOK FOR: four character types • Caring mother figure • Obedient daughter • Acceptable romantic partner (the wife) • The temptress (the mistress) **Any of these can be depicted as a victim

  10. Marxist/Economic Readings Assumptions: • humans are not truly free to be anything they want • socio-economic conditions affect every aspect of the world that we live in – including our minds and the way that we look at the world

  11. LOOK FOR: power relations • Who has control of others because of societal structures (family, religion, government, school)? • Who are the ‘bosses’? Who are the workers? How are they characterized?

  12. LOOK FOR: ownership • Who owns property? Who doesn’t? • Who lives a comfortable life without needing to work (or work hard)? Who must work hard just to survive? • Which lifestyles are valued or emphasized? How is money (and the pursuit of money) portrayed?

  13. Postcolonial Readings • Social Imperialism from 16th to 20th century • Literature used as propaganda to reinforce European view of world (and ‘need’ for imperialistic forces to tame, civilize, and bring order to ‘heathens’) • Recent authors have emphasized the voice and perspective of the colonized

  14. LOOK FOR: in Euro-centric Lit. • stereotypical portrayals of colonizer and colonized • racism (cannibalism, irrationalism, fear of mixed race couples) • power struggles between difference races • ‘mimicry’: attempt of colonized to adopt European culture

  15. LOOK FOR: in postcolonial Lit. • attempts to capture the rhythm and sound of oral stories (particularly in African Lit.) • native culture defined in opposition to organized, scientific rationalism of Europe • ‘mixed’ characters and their resolutions of identity

  16. Goal of Resistant Readings • Highlight when women, the poor, and non-European races and cultures portrayed as: weak, helpless, lazy, immoral, stupid, naïve, violent, savage, technologically and socially backwards • Highlight moments of inequality or situations with imbalances of power due to these factors • Revealing these assumptions (when hidden) means they can be combated. When overt, can help us understand an author’s purpose

More Related