1 / 15

Living wages in Africa: Experiences from the Cut Flower and Garment Industry in Kenya

Living wages in Africa: Experiences from the Cut Flower and Garment Industry in Kenya. BDS Workshop 16-18 September 2009. Kenya’s Cut Flower Industry. Globalization’s success story Oldest and most successful in Africa Largest cut flower exporter to EU

kanan
Download Presentation

Living wages in Africa: Experiences from the Cut Flower and Garment Industry in Kenya

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Living wages in Africa: Experiences from the Cut Flower and Garment Industry in Kenya BDS Workshop 16-18 September 2009

  2. Kenya’s Cut Flower Industry • Globalization’s success story • Oldest and most successful in Africa • Largest cut flower exporter to EU • 1st /2nd largest foreign exchange earner • Employment (40,000-50,000 / 100,000) • Feminized and flexible labor strategies

  3. Kenya’s Garment Industry • Not a significant contributor to GDP • Employment = 40,000 • Garments are manufactured products whose price elasticity is relatively less erratic than that of agricultural products (major sources of foreign exchange earnings for Kenya) • It is also believed that it will enable the hitherto largely elusive take-off to industrialization for the SSA economies

  4. Towards living wages? • Policies to set living wages are a popular but controversial instrument • Minimum wage legislation is supposed to empower workers whose wages are constrained by the excessive market power of employers • Kenya has had an active minimum wage setting policy since independence setting a large number of minimum wage floors that vary by occupation, sector of activity and location • Minimum wages are often updated annually and effected on Labour Day

  5. Towards living wages? • 2006-2008 minimum wage not revised • On 1st May 2009 the government announced an 11% Ksh. 735 (US$9.8) average increase of minimum wages: • Agricultural sector wages – Ksh. 3043 (US$40.6) • General wages for the 3 cities – Ksh. 6130 (US$81.7) • General wages for municipalities wages – Ksh. 5655 (US$75.4) • General wages for all other areas in the country – Ksh. 3270 (US$43.6) • Enforcement and coverage of minimum wage legislation is often wanting (urban vs. rural, formal vs. informal)

  6. Towards living wages? • The criteria used by government to set minimum wages does not reflect the real cost of living • Average annual inflation rates almost tripled from 9.8% in 2007 to 26.2% in 2008 • Bread basket for an average urban household of 3-4 person is estimated at Ksh. 23,670 (US$315.6) • In addition to minimum wages floors there are usually non-wage benefits (housing, healthcare, childcare, transport etc)

  7. Living wages and codes of practice • Most social codes have different living wage clauses • The basic premise of a living wage is that full-time workers should receive sufficient compensation from their work to be able to support a small family at least at a minimum acceptable living standard • However the issue of what constitutes a living wage is left open to interpretation

  8. Living wages and codes of practice • WRC clause on living wage appears to be more proactive unlike the other 3 codes – not pegged to minimum wage legislation • WRC has proposed a sample living wage estimate with illustrations from Indonesia and El Salvador. • It has also estimated the impact of labor cost increases on apparel retail prices • So what constitutes a living wage?

  9. Determining living wages • According to the WRC establishing a living wage involves: • Determining a basic, culturally appropriate market basket of the goods and services necessary to support a household in a given country, with primary emphasis on the most critical area, nutrition. • Determining the market price of each good and service that would be locally available to a garment worker and generating a monthly figure for living costs from this data. • The WRC proposes that living wage levels would be determined for the locality within a given country where a particular factory is located, at the specific time when a dispute arises as to whether that factory is meeting the living wage standard.

  10. WRC Living Wage Estimate: Jakarta, Indonesia

  11. Consequences of Wage Increases on Apparel Production Costs

  12. JO-IN Initiative • The Joint Initiative (JO-IN) (Clean Clothes Campaign, ETI, Fair Labour Association, Fair Wear Foundation,Social Accountability International & WRC) established in 2003 • It is attempting to move living wage discussions from “what is?” and “how” a living wage can be implemented • Project in Turkey: Wage ladder – a benchmaking system for mapping factory progress in improving wages

  13. What is a living wage? • The cut flower and garment industry pay over the legal minimum wage usually in accordance with a 2-year CBA • CBA negotiated by Kenya Plantation & Agricultural Workers Union signed in 2007: Min. wage for general worker KSh.5958 (US$79.4) with an increase of 8% every year • CBA negotiated by Tailors & Textile Workers Union signed in 2003: Min. wage for general & a skilled worker was KSh.5276 (US$70.3) & KSh.6634 (US$88.5) respectively with an increase of 8% every year • But the estimated food basket of Ksh. 23,670 (US$315.6) is nearly five-fold the wages paid in the two sectors • Workers also indicate that the wages that they receive are not sufficient for their basic needs

  14. Implementing of living wages • WHO should take responsibility particularly on global supply chains? • Are JO-IN projects a solution? Is this realistic? • ALL stakeholders (buyers, suppliers, TUs, NGOs and workers) should participate • But are there incentives for each stakeholder’s participation? • It must be clear what incentives are there for each stakeholder • What are the responsibilities of the different parties involved (buyers, suppliers, unions, government and others)

More Related