120 likes | 428 Views
Credentialing of Internationally Educated Health Professionals and the Nursing Exodus from sub-Saharan Africa. University of Alberta: Linda Ogilvie, RN, PhD Judy Mill, RN, PhD Barbara Astle, RN, PhD Candidate Anne Fanning, MD, FRCPS. University of Ghana: Mary Opare, RN, MN.
E N D
Credentialing of Internationally Educated Health Professionalsand the Nursing Exodus from sub-Saharan Africa University of Alberta: Linda Ogilvie, RN, PhD Judy Mill, RN, PhD Barbara Astle, RN, PhD Candidate Anne Fanning, MD, FRCPS University of Ghana: Mary Opare, RN, MN
Africa is estimated to have 1.3% of the global health workforce and 25% of the disease burden (WHO, 2004)
Competing Rights • Right to: • health • leave one’s country to seek a better life • work and to just and favourable conditions of work • an adequate standard of living • education • nondiscrimination and equality
Table 1: Comparison of Life Expectancy, Under Five Mortality (<5MR), and Maternal Mortality Ratio (MMR) for Canada, Ghana, Malawi, South Africa, and Zimbabwe (WHO, 2005) Note: MMR from 2000; other statistics from 2003
Table 2: Physician, Nurse and Midwife Availability in Malawi, Zimbabwe, Ghana, and South Africa per Population around 1998 (WHO, 2002)
Brain Drain? • Brain Gain? • Brain Circulation?
Migration of Health Professionals from sub-Saharan Africa • Pattern • Poor data • Extent (physicians) • Extent (nurses)
Table 3: UK Licensure of Nurses from South Africa, Zimbabwe, Ghana, and Malawi from 1998-99 to 2002-03 Adapted from Bach (2003) from UK Nursing and Midwifery Council data
Push-Pull Factors in International Health Professional Migration • Common in general migration literature • HIV/AIDS • Worldwide shortage, particularly of nurses
Policy Response to International Health Professional Migration • Attention to stick and stay factors within countries • High-income countries meet own needs through education and retention • Ethical recruitment practices • Financial restitution • Skill recirculation
Skill Recirculation or Brain Circulation? • Initiatives from the diaspora • International partnerships • Reorientation of international aid priorities • Integration of health systems
Coming Full Circle • Barriers to credentialing of internationally educated health professionals are not useful as a strategy to reduce health inequities worldwide and need to be addressed only within the context of protection of the public within the receiving country