1 / 29

Human Cognition Reason without Rationality?

Human Cognition Reason without Rationality?. Hermit Crab. An arthropod in a mollusk shell. The shell evolved for a different organism than the crab carrying it down the beach.

landon
Download Presentation

Human Cognition Reason without Rationality?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Human CognitionReason without Rationality?

  2. Hermit Crab • An arthropod in a mollusk shell. • The shell evolved for a different organism than the crab carrying it down the beach. • Similarly, our brains have evolved to serve the needs of our ancestors over the last half billion years, not just the last six million.

  3. Satisfycing • Find solutions that are “good-enough”, not necessarily the best possible. • Sign of evolution – organisms often show poor design. • Panda’s thumb.

  4. Fast and frugal heuristics • ecologically rational (exploit information from the environment) • use evolved capacities such as memory and the perceptual system • fast, frugal, and simple • work when time & knowledge are limited • model both good and poor reasoning

  5. Which is larger? • München or Aachen? • 1,353,186 vs. 258,664 • Köln or Freiburg? • 1,007,119 vs. 224,191 • Nürnbergor Dortmund? • 505,664 vs. 588,735 • Dresden or Bremen? • 523,058 vs. 547,340

  6. Which is larger? • Houston or Philadelphia? • 2,160,821 vs. 1,547,607 • Phoenix or San Diego? • 1,488,750 vs. 1,338,348 • San Jose or San Francisco? • 982,765 vs. 825,863 • Saint Louis or Wichita? • 318,172 vs. 385,577

  7. Have you ever? • Shaken Barack Obama’s hand? • Passed Erin Anderson on campus?

  8. Aunt Martha & Alzheimer’s

  9. Heuristics and Biases. • Is the symptom associated with the disease?

  10. Heuristics and Biases. • Expected = (row_total * col_total)/overall total

  11. Heuristics and Biases. Someone drawn at random from a population of 30% lawyers and 70% engineers. Which is he?

  12. Heuristics and Biases. • A fair coin is tossed six times. • Which sequence is most likely? • H-T-H-T-T-H • H-H-H-T-T-T • H-H-H-H-T-H

  13. Heuristics and Biases. • Praise for an exceptionally smooth landing is usually followed by a poorer landing on the next try, while criticism for a rough landing is usually followed by improvement on the next try. • Therefore praise is detrimental to learning while criticism is beneficial.

  14. Empirical bias. • Rejection of problem information: • All people who live in Monrovia are married. • Kemu is not married. • Does she live in Monrovia? • Yes. Monrovia is not for any one kind of people, so Kemu came to live there.

  15. Empirical bias. • Importing new evidence: • All who own houses pay house tax. • Boimadoesn’t pay house tax. • Does he own a house? • Boima has a house but he’s exempted from paying house tax. The government appointed Boimatax collector so they exempted him from paying the tax.

  16. Empirical bias. • Evaluating own knowledge: • In the far north, all bears are white. • Bolshevik Island is in the far north. • What color are the bears there? • You should ask the people who have been there and seen them, we always speak of only what we see.

  17. Empirical bias. • The unschooled resist, the schooled acquiesce: • question premises, • add new ones, • test conclusions against knowledge, • qualify own judgment.

  18. Empirical bias. • Absurd premises invite resistance. • Here, being illogical is sensible. • Passively accepting premises may work at school, but not in the real world.

  19. Puzzler from Car Talk • There are three switches in one room that control three light bulbs in another room. • Each switch controls one bulb. • Can’t see from switch room to bulb room. • How do you figure out which switch controls which bulb in one trip from the switch room to the bulb room? 

  20. Insight into a Reasoning Task • Set of cards with letter on one side and number on the other. • Rule: If there is a vowel on one side, there is an even number on the other. • What cards do you turn over to test the rule?

  21. Insight into a Reasoning Task • You are from the liquor control board enforcing the ban on underage drinking. • You have to enforce the rule If someone is drinking a beer, s/he is over 21. • Who do you have to ask for an id or check to see what they are drinking?

More Related