1 / 53

Union Organizing Campaigns and Collective Bargaining

Union Organizing Campaigns and Collective Bargaining. Chapter 19. Chapter Overview. Union Membership Decision Union Organizing Campaign Good-Faith Bargaining Participants in Negotiations Collective Bargaining Agreements Specific Issues in Collective Bargaining Agreements

lea
Download Presentation

Union Organizing Campaigns and Collective Bargaining

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. UnionOrganizingCampaignsandCollectiveBargaining Chapter 19

  2. Chapter Overview • Union Membership Decision • Union Organizing Campaign • Good-Faith Bargaining • Participants in Negotiations • Collective Bargaining Agreements • Specific Issues in Collective Bargaining Agreements • Impasses in Collective Bargaining • Trends in Collective Bargaining • Summary of Learning Objectives 19-3

  3. Collective Bargaining • Process that involves negotiation, drafting, administration, and interpretation of a written agreement between an employer and a union for a specific period of time • Contract that sets forth the joint understandings of the parties as to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment • Contracts have varying time periods, most common being three years • Basic components of the process are the following: • Negotiation of relevant issues in good faith by both management and union • Incorporation of parties’ understandings into a written contract • Administration of daily working relationships according to terms and conditions of employment specified in contract • Resolution of disputes in interpretation of terms of contract through established procedures 19-4

  4. Union Membership Decision • Before collective bargaining process begins • Employees of an organization must decide whether they want to be represented by a union • Important prerequisite to understanding collective bargaining process is knowledge of what attracts employees to unions 19-5

  5. Reasons for Joining • Many factors influence an employee’s desire to join a union • One important factor is employees’ perception of ability of union to change the situation • While wages, benefits, working conditions, and job security are main issues contributing to decision to join a union, other factors include employees’ desires for • Better communication with management • Higher quality of management and supervision • Increased democracy in the workplace • Opportunity to belong to a group where they can share experiences and comradeship 19-6

  6. The Opposition View • Major reasons for not joining a union are satisfactory • Wages • Benefits • Working conditions • Job security • Negative image of labor unions include believing unions • Have too much political influence • Require members to go along with decisions made by union • Have leaders promoting their own self-interests • Abuse their power by calling strikes • Cause high prices • Misuse union dues and pension funds • Are adversaries • Dissatisfaction with wages, benefits, and working conditions can quickly change negative attitude toward unions 19-7

  7. The Opposition View • Organizations have avoided unionization by • Providing satisfactory wages, benefits, working conditions, and job security • Creating a procedure for handling employee complaints • Eliminating arbitrary and heavy-handed management and supervisory practices • Establishing a meaningful system of two-way communication between management and employees • Eliminating threats to employees’ job security • Making employees feel like they are part of organization 19-8

  8. Union Organizing Campaign • Union organizing campaigns begin when one or more employees request that the union begin an organizing campaign • National and international unions contact employees in organizations that have been targeted for organizing campaigns • Generally, unions will not attempt to organize a facility unless there is a strong body of support among employees • Typically, union begins a campaign to interest employees in joining it • Employees sign authorization cards indicating they would like to have an election to vote for or against representation by a union • National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) requested to supervise an election – If 30 percent of employees sign authorization cards • In practice, NLRB is petitioned only if over 50 percent sign authorization cards 19-9

  9. Union Organizing Campaign • Restrictions placed on where and when support for unions can be solicited • Employees in favor of union can orally solicit support from other employees in work and nonwork areas only on nonwork time • If allowed to engage in casual conversation while working, employees can discuss union matters if production is not hindered • Union literature can be distributed only on nonworking time, and management can limit the distribution of literature to nonwork areas • NLRB rarely approves exceptions to general rules for oral solicitation and distribution of union literature • Some exceptions have been granted • Department stores 19-10

  10. Union Organizing Campaign • Rights to orally solicit union support and distribute union literature on company property apply only to employees • Management can prohibit union organizers from entering company property for these purposes • One exception is that if management allows other solicitors to enter company property, they cannot exclude union organizers • Captive-audience doctrine • Management rights • Can speak against union on company time to employees and require employees to attend meeting • Prohibit from giving a speech on company time to mass employee audience in 24 hours immediately before election • 24-hour rule applies only to a speech before a large group • Union rights • Do not have right to reply on company time 19-11

  11. Determining the Bargaining Unit • If union obtains signed authorization cards from at least 30 percent of employees • Either union or employer can petition National Labor Relations Board to conduct a representation election • If union has signed authorization cards from more than 50 percent of employees • Union can make a direct request to employer to become bargaining agent of employees • Employer normally refuses, and union then petitions NLRB for an election • After a petition is filed • Representative of NLRB (examiner) verifies that authorization requirement has been fulfilled • Makes a determination as to appropriate bargaining unit 19-12

  12. Determining the Bargaining Unit • Bargaining unit (election unit) • Group of employees in a plant, firm, or industry that is recognized by employer, agreed on by parties to a case, or designated by NLRB as appropriate for purposes of collective bargaining • Consent elections • Union elections in which parties have agreed on appropriate bargaining unit • Community of interest • Concept by which NLRB makes a bargaining unit decision based on areas of employee commonality • Factors include elements such as • Similar wages, hours, and working conditions • Employees’ physical proximity to one another • Common supervision • Amount of interchange of personnel within proposed unit • Degree of integration of employer’s production process of operation 19-13

  13. Election Campaigns • Illegal unfair labor practices include • Physical interference, threats, or violent behavior by employer toward union organizers • Employer interference with employees involved in organizing drive • Discipline or discharge of employees for prounion activities • Threatening or coercing of employees by union organizers • Union can picket an employer only • If employer is not presently unionized • Petition has been filed with NLRB within the past 30 days • Representation election has not been conducted during preceding 12 months • Informational picketing • Individuals patrol at or near place of employment carrying signs to publicize fact that union is requesting an election to become bargaining agent for employees 19-14

  14. Election Campaigns • During election campaign, management usually initiates a campaign against a union • Emphasizing costs of unionization • Loss of individual freedom that can result from collective representation • Management • Can legally state opinions about possible ramifications of unionization if its statements are based on fact and are not threatening • Can explain to employees positive aspects of their current situation • Can conduct polls to verify union strength prior to an election, but in general it may not question employees individually about their preferences or otherwise threaten or intimidate them • Cannot promise to provide or withhold benefits in future in case of unionization or nonunionization 19-15

  15. Election Campaigns • During the election campaign, unions emphasize their ability to • Help employees satisfy their needs • Improve their working conditions • Ability of union to sell these concepts to employees is a critical factor in union’s success • Employees must believe union • Cares about their problems • Can help resolve them • Can assist in improving their wages, benefits, and working conditions • Unions are legally prohibited from coercing or threatening individual employees if they do not join union 19-16

  16. Election Campaigns • Actual impact of an election campaign is unclear • Campaign tactics of both management and union are monitored by NLRB • If found to be unfair, election results may be invalidated and a new election conducted • Charges of unfair labor practices against management, if serious enough, can result in NLRB ordering management to bargain with union • Gissel bargaining orders – Named after a landmark Supreme Court decision, NLRB v. Gissel Packing Company, which held that bargaining orders by NLRB are an appropriate remedy for certain types of employer misconduct • Gissel bargaining orders are rarely issued by NLRB 19-17

  17. Election, Certification, and Decertification • If management and the union agree to conduct election as a consent election • Balloting often occurs within a short period of time • If management does not agree to a consent election, a long delay may occur • Delays in balloting often increase likelihood that management will win election • Management frequently refuses to agree to a consent election • 12-month rule • Provides that no election can be held in any bargaining unit within which a valid election has been held within preceding 12-month period 19-18

  18. Election, Certification, and Decertification • Certification bar • Condition occurring when NLRB will not permit another election in bargaining unit within 12 months of a union’s certification • Recognition bar • Condition occurring when NLRB prohibits an election for up to 12 months after an employer voluntarily recognizes a union • Contract bar doctrine • Doctrine under which NLRB will not permit an election in bargaining unit covered by a contract until contract expires, up to a maximum of three years • Secret ballot – Exclusive bargaining representative • Union represents all employees (both union members and nonmembers) in bargaining unit in negotiating their wages, hours, and terms and conditions of employment • Union has to receive only a majority of votes cast 19-19

  19. Election, Certification, and Decertification • Once union has been certified • Remains by law the exclusive bargaining representative for all employees until employees within unit desire otherwise • If employees want to oust union • File a petition with NLRB for a decertification election • If 30 percent of employees support petition to decertify and a valid election to oust union has not been held within preceding year, a decertification election is conducted • If a majority of voting employees vote to decertify union, it no longer legally represents them 19-20

  20. Steps Involved in a UnionOrganizing Campaign 19-21

  21. Good-Faith Bargaining • Sincere intention of both parties to negotiate differences and reach a mutually acceptable agreement • National Labor Relations Act – Stipulates legal requirement for private enterprise organizations • Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 – Stipulates legal requirement for federal agencies • Does not require parties to agree • Obligates them to make a good-faith attempt to reach an agreement • Essential requirement is that a bona fide attempt be made to reach an agreement • Not explicitly defined in either law • Boulwarism – Named after a General Electric vice president • Occurs when management makes its best offer at outset of bargaining and firmly adheres to the offer throughout bargaining sessions • NLRB has ruled this illegal 19-22

  22. Participants in Negotiations – Employer’s Role • Single-company agreement • Representatives of a single company meet with representatives of union and negotiate a contract • Possible for one company to have several unions representing different groups of employees • Possible for one company and one union to negotiate different contracts for each facility or plant location of company • Multiemployer agreements • Individual employers in these industries are small and are in a weak position relative to union • Employers then often pool together in an employer association, which negotiates a single agreement for all involved employers • May be on a local level, a regional level, or at a national level • Industrywide bargaining – Multiemployer bargaining occurring on a regional or national basis 19-23

  23. Participants in Negotiations – Employer’s Role • In large organizations such as General Motors, master agreements on wage and benefit issue are negotiated between • Corporate officials • Officials of national or international union • In addition to master agreement, local supplements are negotiated at the plant level • Deal with issues that are unique to each plant 19-24

  24. Participants in Negotiations – Union’s Role • Single-company agreements – Size of company determines nature of union participation • Smaller companies – Local union works closely with a field representative of international or national union in negotiations • Gives advice and counsel to local union • Frequently serves as principal negotiator for union • Large companies with multiple plants – Top officials of national or international union conduct negotiations • Local union officials and a field representative of national or international union negotiate local supplements to master agreement for large companies 19-25

  25. Participants in Negotiations – Union’s Role • Multiemployer agreements • Union participation is usually directed by president of national or international union • Representatives of local unions to be covered by multiemployer agreement normally serve on union’s negotiating committee • Coordinated bargaining – Form of bargaining in which several unions bargain jointly with a single employer 19-26

  26. Role of Third Parties – National Labor Relations Act • Requires both unions and management to bargain in good faith • Refusal to bargain can be overridden by an order of NLRB • If board’s order has been properly issued, U.S. Court of Appeals is required to order enforcement under threat of contempt-of-court penalties • NLRB has authority to determine whether a particular behavior is unfair • If either party believes that an unfair practice has occurred, a charge can be filed with NLRB • Either party can appeal decisions of NLRB to U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and even the U.S. Supreme Court 19-27

  27. Role of Third Parties – Federal Labor Relations Authority (FLRA) • Given its authority by Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 • Serves as counterpart to NLRB for federal sector • Employees • Unions • Agencies • Under procedures similar to those of NLRB, FLRA • Investigates unfair labor practice charges • Conducts hearings on unfair labor practices • Issues orders to cease from any such practices 19-28

  28. Role of Third Parties – Federal Services Impasses Panel (FSIP) • If parties in federal sector reach an impasse in negotiations, either party may request Federal Services Impasses Panel (FSIP) to consider the matter • FSIP, an entity within FLRA, has authority to • Recommend solutions to resolve an impasse • Take whatever action is necessary to resolve dispute, as long as actions are not inconsistent with the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 • Parties may agree to adopt a procedure for binding arbitration of a negotiation impasse • Only if procedure is approved by the FSIP • FSIP is considered to be legal alternative to a strike in federal sector 19-29

  29. Role of Third Parties – Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service (FMCS) • Independent agency within federal government that provides mediators to assist in resolving contract negotiation impasses • Jurisdiction of FMCS encompasses • Employees of private enterprise organizations engaged in interstate commerce • Federal government employees • Employees in private, nonprofit hospitals and other allied medical facilities • Mediation (Conciliation) • Process whereby both parties invite a neutral third party (called a mediator) to help resolve contract impasses • Unlike an arbitrator, has no authority to impose a solution on parties 19-30

  30. Role of Third Parties – Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service (FMCS) • Roles of mediators include • Helping parties find common ground for continuing negotiations • Developing factual data on issues over which parties disagree • Setting up joint study committees involving members of both parties to examine more difficult issues • Separating and serving as a buffer between antagonistic parties • Carrying proposals and counterproposals between parties • Various state agencies and private individuals, such as lawyers, professors, and arbitrators, also provide mediation services 19-31

  31. Role of Third Parties – Arbitrators • Arbitration • Process whereby parties agree to settle a dispute through use of an independent third party (called an arbitrator) • Arbitration is binding on both parties • Interest arbitration or contract arbitration – Arbitration of contract terms • Rarely used in private sector but is common in public sector • Can take one of two forms: • Conventional interest arbitration • Final-offer interest arbitration 19-32

  32. Role of Third Parties – Arbitrators • Conventional interest arbitration • Form of arbitration in which arbitrator listens to arguments from both parties and makes a binding decision • Decision can be identical to position of either party or different from the positions of both parties • Final-offer interest arbitration • Form of arbitration in which arbitrator is restricted to selecting final offer of one of the parties • Interest arbitration can be either voluntary or mandatory • Lists of certified arbitrators can be obtained from • Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service • American Arbitration Association (AAA) 19-33

  33. Collective Bargaining Agreements • Contract specifies in writing mutual agreements reached by parties during negotiations • Mandatory subjects of negotiation • National Labor Relations Act obligates employers and unions to bargain in good faith on wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment • Unions attempt to expand the mandatory area by giving a broad interpretation to the phrase • Employers naturally resist this expansion • Nonmandatory, or permissive, issue • Parties are not required to bargain on them • It is an illegal labor practice for one party to insist on bargaining about a permissive issue • Many difficulties exist on establishing a group of mandatory and permissive issues for all organizations 19-34

  34. Collective Bargaining Agreements • A small group of prohibited issues that cannot be included in a collective bargaining agreement exist • They include • Closed shop – Requires employers to hire only people who are union members • Hot-cargo clause – Results when an employer agrees with a union not to handle or use the goods or services of another employer • For federal sector, Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 makes it mandatory to bargain over “conditions of employment” • Act defines conditions of employment as • Personnel policies • Personnel practices • Matters affecting working conditions 19-35

  35. Prohibited and Permitted Collective Bargaining Issues in the Federal Sector 19-36

  36. Specific Issues in Collective Bargaining Agreements • While each contract is different, most contracts include five issues: • Management rights • Union security • Wages and benefits • Individual security (seniority) rights • Dispute resolution 19-37

  37. Management Rights • Primary purpose of management rights clause • Retain for management the right to direct all business activities • Items that are normally regarded as an integral part of management rights include the rights to • Direct the workforce • Determine size of workforce (including number and class of employees to be hired or laid off) • Set working hours • Assign work • The union insists on a sentence specifying that management will not discriminate against the union 19-38

  38. Union Security • Deal with status of employee membership in union and attempt to ensure that union has continuous strength • Union shop • Provision in a contract that requires all employees in a bargaining unit to join union and retain membership as a condition of employment • “Grandfather” clause – Modified union shop requires all employees hired after effective date of agreement to acquire and retain union membership as a condition of employment • Most right-to-work laws outlaw union shop • Agency shop • Contract provision that does not require employees to join union but requires them to pay equivalent of union dues as a condition of employment 19-39

  39. Union Security • Maintenance of membership • Contract provision that does not require an employee to join union but does require employees who do join to remain members for a stipulated time period • Taft–Hartley Act has made possible • Right-to-work – Permits states to pass legislation that guarantees right to work regardless of union membership • Prohibits closed shop – Only union members can be hired • Prohibit preferential shop – Requires that union members be given preference in filling job vacancies • Checkoff • Arrangement between an employer and a union under which employer agrees to withhold union dues, initiation fees, and assessments from employees’ paychecks and submit this money to union 19-40

  40. Wages and Employee Benefits • Cost-of-living adjustments (COLA) • Contract provision that ties wage increases to rises in Bureau of Labor Statistics consumer price index • Most call for hourly increases in wages for each specified rise in CPI • Adjustments can be made on a quarterly, semiannual, or annual basis • Other wage issues specified in contracts include • Overtime pay and rates of pay for work on Saturdays, Sundays, holidays, and sixth or seventh consecutive day of work • Benefits normally covered in union contracts include • Holidays • Vacations • Insurance • Pensions 19-41

  41. Wages and Employee Benefits • Eligibility for holiday pay is of one or two types • Length-of-service requirement • Employee must have worked a minimum of four weeks with employer before being eligible for holiday pay • Work requirement • Employee generally must work day before and day after a holiday to receive holiday pay • Most union contracts provide vacation provisions • Usually tied directly to employee’s length of service • Most union contracts contain clauses providing • Health, accident, and life insurance benefits • Major medical insurance • Accidental death and dismemberment benefits • Dental insurance • Coverage for miscellaneous medical expenses such as prescription drugs 19-42

  42. Definitions of Typical Supplementary Pay Items 19-43

  43. Individual Security (Seniority) Rights • Seniority – An employee’s relative length of service with an employer • May be measured on basis of employee’s • Length of service in a job classification or a department • Length of service with one plant or with company as a whole • Commonly used to achieve job security – Contract provisions specify that seniority is to be used within bargaining unit for • Transfers to higher-level jobs • Layoffs • Recalls from layoffs • Choice of work shifts • Vacation periods 19-44

  44. Individual Security (Seniority) Rights • Seniority systems are designed to benefit employees with greater length of service • Women and minorities, generally most recently hired employees, can be adversely affected by a seniority system • Section 703(a) of 1964 Civil Rights Act prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin • Section 703(h) exempts bona fide seniority systems from mandate of Section 703(a) • Suggests that bona fide seniority may have a disproportionate impact on a certain class of people and still be deemed valid • Such a system may not be result of intent to discriminate against a class of individuals 19-45

  45. Dispute Resolution • “No-strike” clause • Pledges union to cooperate in preventing work stoppages • Pledges can be • Unconditional – Ban any interference with production during life of contract • Conditional – Permit strikes under certain circumstances • No-strike ban most commonly lifted after • Exhaustion of grievance procedure • Arbitration award has been violated • In return for a no-strike pledge, union normally asks company • Not to engage in lockouts during term of contract • Lockout – Refusal of employer to let employees work • Grievance procedure provision is most common method for resolving disputes arising during term of contract • Final step in dispute resolution procedure is usually arbitration 19-46

  46. Impasses in Collective Bargaining • If new agreement has not been reached at end of contract period, employees can continue working under terms of old contract until • New agreement is reached • Strike is called • Strike – Occurs when employees collectively refuse to work • Not permitted for most public employees • To strike, union must first hold a vote among its members • In picketing, individual members patrol at or near place of employment to • Publicize existence of a strike • Discourage employees from working • Discourage public from dealing with employer • Frequently, members of other unions will refuse to cross picket line of a striking union 19-47

  47. Impasses in Collective Bargaining • Purpose of a strike is to bring economic hardship to employer, forcing employer to agree to union demands • Success of a strike determined by how severely union is able to interrupt organization’s operations • Employers often attempt to continue operations by using • Supervisory and management personnel • People not in a striking bargaining unit • People within bargaining unit who refuse to go on strike • People hired to replace striking employees • Attempts to continue operations through these methods can increase difficulty of reaching an agreement • Often result in violence 19-48

  48. Impasses in Collective Bargaining • Emergency dispute provisions of Taft–Hartley Act can be used • President is authorized to appoint a special board of inquiry, which makes • Preliminary investigation of impasse prior to issuing an injunction to halt strike • Cooling-off-period – President can issue injunction prohibiting strike action for 80 days • 60 days to resolve impasse, after which NLRB is required to poll employees on whether they will accept employer’s last offer • Injunction is dissolved • President can refer impasse to Congress and recommend a course of action 19-49

  49. Trends in Collective Bargaining • Variables influencing collective bargaining process include • Technological change • Increased use of automation • Changing government regulations • Rising foreign competition • Decline in percentage of blue-collar employees • High rates of unemployment • Joint labor–management committees • Form of collective bargaining that has evolved to cope with rapidly changing variables • Meets regularly over contract period to explore issues of common concern 19-50

More Related