1 / 43

Hennessy & Roach, P.C.

Hennessy & Roach, P.C. The Workers’ Compensation Toolbox 10 th Annual Illinois State Council Society of Human Resource Management Conference July 23-24, 2009. Hennessy & Roach, P.C. Overview of Presentation. Brief discussion of IL Workers’ Comp System Employer Rights Spotting Fraud

mizell
Download Presentation

Hennessy & Roach, P.C.

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Hennessy & Roach, P.C. The Workers’ Compensation Toolbox 10th Annual Illinois State Council Society of Human Resource Management Conference July 23-24, 2009

  2. Hennessy & Roach, P.C.

  3. Overview of Presentation • Brief discussion of IL Workers’ Comp System • Employer Rights • Spotting Fraud • What to do in First 48-Hours • Lowering Your Workers’ Comp Costs

  4. The Illinois Workers’ Comp System • Is the accident compensable? • “In the course and scope of employment” • Employee reasonably is where he is supposed to be and doing what he is reasonably supposed to be doing • Liberally construed by Commission

  5. The Illinois Workers’ Comp System • Is the accident compensable? • “Arising from employment” • Injury arises from an increased risk of injury peculiar to employment • Liberally construed by Commission

  6. The Illinois Workers’ Comp System • Causal Relation • Is the Work accident a “causative factor” in the medical condition? • Aggravation only required to trigger causation • No apportionment exists

  7. The Illinois Workers’ Comp System • 45-day Notice Requirement • Employee must advise employer of work injury w/in 45 days of accident • Jurisdictional requirement for claim to be valid • Liberally construed in favor of employee – almost any notice works!

  8. The Illinois Workers’ Comp System • Average Weekly Wage • Statutory methods exist to determine AWW • AWW determines TTD and PPD rate

  9. The Illinois Workers’ Comp System • Temporary & Total Disability & Benefits • Employee off work pursuant to physician slip • Paid at 66 2/3rds of AWW • Not payable if light duty or max medical improvement • TTD rate subject to min & max rates

  10. The Illinois Workers’ Comp System • Permanency • Paid at PPD rate – 60% of AWW • PPD rate subject to min & max rates • Payable after MMI

  11. The Illinois Workers’ Comp System • Different types of Permanency • Section 8(e)-Specific body parts – e.g., Hand=205 wx; Leg=215 wx • Section 8(d)(2) – Person-as-a-whole =500 wx or 20% MAW • Wage differential awards-Earnings capacity impairment

  12. The Illinois Workers’ Comp System • Permanent & Total Disability • Statutory permanent total • Medical permanent total • “Odd-lot” permanent total

  13. Employers’ Rights • Notice • Employee MUST advise employer of work injury w/in 45 days of accident • Documentation • Employer has right to docs in support of claim for benefits including Temporary Total Disability & Medical Benefits

  14. Employers’ Rights • Representation • Experience in workers’ comp matters • Experience in venue • Experience w/the Arbitrator • Willingness to communicate • Tri-parte relationship

  15. Employers’ Rights • Independent Medical Examination • Employer has right to have employee examined by doctor of YOUR choosing • Exam can address causal relation, work status and treatment plan

  16. Employers’ Rights • Utilization Review • Allows evaluation of proposed health care services • Appropriateness of level of health care (medically necessary) & quality of services • Includes prospective review, 2nd opinions, concurrent review, discharge planning, peer review, IMEs and retrospective review

  17. Employers’ Rights • Liens & Credits • Employer Lien (820 ILCS 305/5(b)) • Employer is entitled to reimbursement for amounts paid or to be paid to employee if recovery from 3rd party claim • Most common in work related car crashes • Subject to attorney’s fees, costs & expenses • Employer can pursue 3rd party even if employee chooses not to

  18. Employers’ Rights • Liens & Credits • Credit for Prior Settlements & Awards • Credit only against like body parts • Settlement or award must occur prior to accident • No provision for credit for person-as-a-whole Source: 820 ILCS 8(e)(17)

  19. Employers’ Rights • Liens & Credits • Credit for Group Benefits • Employer contribution required • Credit for non-occupational medical & disability benefits • Credit applied against TTD & medical benefits Source: 820 ILCS 305/8(j)

  20. Employers’ Rights • Liens & Credits • Life Insurance Offset • Employer may elect to obtain life insurance on employees • Employer may apply such benefits to satisfy all or portion of death benefit payable under the Act Source: 820 ILCS 305/4(h)(i)

  21. Fraudulent Claims • Red Flags indicating possible fraud • Injury occurred on a Monday morning • Injury occurred on a Friday but not reported until following Monday • Accident just prior to strike, termination, layoff, end of project or seasonal work • Unwitnessed by fellow employees • History of previous claims

  22. Fraudulent Claims • Red Flags • Lack of notice beyond 30 days • Time between accident & medical care • Different descriptions between medical history & first claim report • Difficulty contacting employee at home when allegedly disabled • Refuses diagnostic procedure

  23. Fraudulent Claims • Red Flags • Disability policies recently obtained • Lawyer and/or Dr. known for involvement in suspect claims • Employee frequently changes doctors • Employee changes his/her attorney

  24. Fraudulent Claims • What to do about Fraud • Follow all leads of potential fraud • Document fraudulent activities • Notify insurance carrier of suspicions

  25. Fraudulent Claims • What can be done about Fraud? • Section 25.5 of IL Workers’ Comp Act • Class 4 Felony • Order to pay complete restitution to defrauded person or entity • Civil liability in an amount three times the value of the benefits or twice the value of benefits attempted to be obtained

  26. Fraudulent Claims • Requirements to prove Fraud • The employee must have filed an Application for Adjustment of Claim & must have rcv’d or attempted to receive benefits • Employee must have made written demand for the payment of benefits related to the reported fraud

  27. Fraudulent Claims • Who investigates Fraud? • Div. of Insurance of the Dept of Financial & Professional Regulation • Findings of fraud are reported to the AG or the State’s Attorney • All reports of fraud shall be resolved w/in 120 days

  28. Fraudulent Claims • Enumerated acts of Fraud • Employer • Intentional false statements or material representation to deny benefits • Intentional false statements to prevent a person from making legitimate claim • Intentionally prepare or present false or invalid certificate of coverage

  29. Fraudulent Claims • Enumerated acts of Fraud • Employer • False statements to obtain self-insurance status or reduce amt of security required • False statements to investigators of Div. of Insurance • Intentionally assist, solicit or conspire to do any of the above

  30. Fraudulent Claims • Enumerated acts of Fraud • Employee • Intentionally present false claim for benefits • Intentionally make false statements to obtain benefits • Intentionally make false statements to Div. of Insurance • Intentionally assist, solicit or conspire to do any of the above

  31. First 48-Hours • Obtain Medical Care • Company doctor is advisable • Interview Employee • What happened, who was present, when did it happen, how, where • Employee should prepare written accident report to be signed & dated

  32. First 48-Hours • Eyewitnesses • Complete written accident reports • Interviewed to clarify reports • Supervisor • Report should be completed regarding injury & should crystallize the investigation

  33. First 48-Hours • “Evidence” • Photograph objects or areas involved • Beware of spoliation of evidence • Preserve defective products or objects if they caused the injury • Bear in mind potential subrogation claims

  34. First 48-Hours • Company Reports & Files • Report accident to agent or carrier • Communicate any grounds for suspicion – YOU are in the best position to know the untold story • Create “workers’ comp claim file” • Keep & maintain all documents during the life of the claim

  35. Lower Your Workers’ Comp Costs • Accident Prevention • Safety! Safety! Safety • Ergonomic work stations; weekly safety meetings; safety manual; industrial/environmental audits; safety officer; employee discipline program; etc. • Insurer provided risk assessment audits

  36. Lower Your Workers’ Comp Costs • Reporting • Use of precautionary reports even if accident is minor • Employee training on company policies for reporting work accidents • Proper investigation & documentation of all work accidents

  37. Lower Your Workers’ Comp Costs • Light & Restricted Duty Programs • Light duty saves on TTD benefits • Lowers claim history & premiums • Light duty keeps employee at work • Light duty is proven to lower overall costs of claims • Accommodation of permanent restrictions

  38. Lower Your Workers’ Comp Costs • Nurse Case Manager Involvement • Nurse monitors & helps coordinate medical care • Nurse evaluates potential for early return to work

  39. Lower Your Workers’ Comp Costs • Company Physician • Becomes familiar with work environment • Can provide light duty work assignments • Can facilitate MMI declaration & declare permanent restrictions • Can provide drug screening, post-offer physicals & ergonomic assessments

  40. Lower Your Workers’ Comp Costs • Independent Medical Examinations • Employer has right to have employee examined by doctor of its choice • Exam can address causal relation; return to work; MMI; and permanent restrictions

  41. Lower Your Workers’ Comp Costs • Physician review of medical records • Address medical necessity of suggested treatment • Submitted as evidence at trial

  42. Lower Your Workers’ Comp Costs • Reputable Workers’ Comp Carrier • Aggressive & knowledgeable defense attorneys • Tri-parte relationship • YOU have a right to participate in the defense of the case

  43. Hennessy & Roach, P.C. Thank You 217 – 726 – 0037 mholt@hennessyroach.com www.iwcc.il.gov www.HennessyRoach.com

More Related