1 / 48

WW 2 History Club

WW 2 History Club. “Keep the British Isles Afloat”. “Arsenal of Democracy”. 833 Days. 26 - Dec - 2012. “All Aid Short of War”. “Keep out of foreign wars”. Today’s Goal.

munin
Download Presentation

WW 2 History Club

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. WW 2 History Club “Keep the British Isles Afloat” “Arsenal of Democracy” 833 Days 26 - Dec - 2012 “All Aid Short of War” “Keep out of foreign wars”

  2. Today’s Goal • Introduce you to some of the less famous individuals who were not military but had as much influence on what eventually happened as any general • Interest in similar sessions in the future? • Focus Group? • WWII Book Club?

  3. The Big Three For most people, “the big three” of WWII refer to • Churchill • Roosevelt • Stalin • But who made it happen?

  4. The Few In one of his most famous speeches, Churchill stated: “Never in the field of human conflict has so much been owed by so many to so few” Who are “the few”? Are you sure?

  5. 833 Days 1-Sep-1939: WWII starts 8-Dec-1941: US declares war on Japan 12-Dec-1941: Germany declares war on US 8-May-1945: VE Day European War lasted 2076 days US was not a true belligerent for first 833 days

  6. Britain Stands Alone • Seeds of WWII go back decades • European War started in Sep 1939 • Fall of Poland • Phony War • Fall of Norway and Denmark • May 1940 breakout • “The Battle of France is Over …”

  7. Britain Stands Alone • “ … the Battle of Britain is about to begin …” • Britain is the size of Colorado • British army was trampled by Germans • Britain is low of food, men, arms, … • How could Britain stand up to Hitler?

  8. Britain Stands Alone • Germany is 80 million + • Britain Empire is 500 million • British Empire: 50 divisions • Germany: 250 divisions (half were crack combat divisions) “Never before in history have so few brought so much suffering to so many”

  9. US Isolationism • Memories of WWI • Stay out of European conflicts • Vast majority of Americans against any involvement (various reasons) • FDR had to be careful • What was his strategy? • Why was it so important to stay out of the war?

  10. Video • Perspective on Greatness: The Price of Peace • 1952 Documentary Series • Approx 30 minutes

  11. What Happened? • Why did Americans change their mind about “the European War” • How did the US figure out what the UK really needed? • How did Lend-Lease go from an idea to action? • How were the many differences between the US and the UK mitigated?

  12. What Happened? • Why did FDR and Churchill wait so long to meet? • How could these monstrous egos get along? • Churchill was known for decisiveness and quick action; FDR for vacillation and endless delays • How could they work cooperatively?

  13. What Happened? • 4 Americans changed history • 4 Americans backed Britain and supported aide to Britain against huge opposition • 4 Americans convinced FDR (and the US public) that Britain would not surrender • 4 Americans mitigated the problems of culture and alliance

  14. 4 Americans • Edward R. Murrow • Harry Hopkins • John Winant • W. Averell Harriman Who were these men and how did they change history?

  15. Edward R. Murrow • Minimal training as a newspaperman • Pioneer in radio broadcast • Director of CBS Talks & Education in 1935 • Went to London in 1937 • Covered “the events” live: revolutionary approach • Anschluss • Sudetenland, Munich, … • Built huge following for “radio news”

  16. Edward R. Murrow • World News Roundup (CBS radio) • “This is London” • Trusted source of news • Close relationship with Churchill • Offered director-general of BBC • Closer relationship with Pamela Churchill For many Americans, Murrow’s broadcasts were a trusted source of “unbiased”, up-to-the minute, news

  17. Edward R. Murrow • Murrow Boys .. “The finest news staff ever assembled”: • Eric Sevareid • Charles Collingwood • Howard K. Smith • William Shirer • Mary Marvin Breckinridge • Cecil Brown • Richard C. Hottelet • Bill Downs • Winston Burdett • Charles Shaw • Ned Calmer

  18. Edward R Murrow & the Power of Radio • We tend to forget that radio was “the media” of the 1930s and 1940s • Everyone listened to radio • Radio was often more powerful than images because with radio you could imagine … “the theater of the mind”

  19. Edward R Murrow & the Power of Radio • Let’s listen to some radio from the 1930s • “I can hear it now” (1933 – 1945) • Trafalgar Square 24Aug’40 • “Good Luck” Dec 1940 • “This is London” 1942

  20. Harry Hopkins • FDR’s chief advisor on many topics (2nd most powerful man in Washington) • Directed WPA, largest employer in the country • Managed the distribution of $ billions • Friend and confidant of FDR • Lived at the White House for 3+ years • One of FDR’s “confidential agents” – “eyes & ears” • More influential than the State Department • “Now Harry, get that goddamn thing done. And Harry would have it done in two hours”

  21. Harry Hopkins • Secy of Commerce • Special mission to UK in early 1941 to “get the facts” • Developed exceptionally good relationship with Churchill; impressed by his decisiveness and quick action • “Lord of Root of the Matter” • Returned with a good understanding of Churchill, UK • Convinced that UK would weather the storm • Overall director of Lend Lease; wanted Harriman in UK • Arranged for Placentia Bay meeting • Visited Stalin (Jul’41); convinced FDR to include USSR in LL

  22. US Position on Aid • Neutrality Act of 1935 • general embargo for 6 months • Neutrality Act of 1936 • extended 14 months, no loans • Neutrality Act of 1937 • no time limit; civil wars too; • modest “cash & carry” provision • Neutrality Act of 1939 • Initially restored embargo • Later repealed Acts of 1936 and 1937: • “Cash & Carry”

  23. US Position on Aid • Cash & Carry … Sep/Nov -1939 • All belligerent nations; UK preference • War zones declared • National Munitions Control Board • Federal crime: Arms trading w/o license (still in effect)

  24. US Position on Aid • 1940: • Britain stands alone • Britain running out of $ • US public in favor of “some help” • Destroyers for Bases (US acted faster) • 17 Dec: The Garden Hose speech • 29 Dec: Arsenal of Democracy Speech

  25. US Aid to Allies • 1941: • Britain truly desperate • Battle of the Atlantic • 75% of US public in favor of Lend-Lease • March  Britain • April  China • October  Soviet Union

  26. Joseph Kennedy • Interesting past • US Ambassador to UK 27Jan’38 – 22Oct’40 (critical time?) • Aligned with Chamberlain / appeasement • Vocal about Britain falling • Thought Germany was too strong • Encouraged FDR to write off Britain • Encouraged Americans to get out of UK

  27. The Mess • For 175 years … • Churchill and UK tired of US “talk” • UK Belief: US was taking advantage of UK • Halifax had to tone down Churchill’s correspondence • Churchill: “Give us the tools …” • FDR: not much use for JPK or State Dept

  28. John Winant • Hero was Abe Lincoln • Reserved and “awkward”; not a great speaker • Idealist to the point of political suicide • Worked 24/7 but not a good administrator • Progressive Republican; 2 term governor of NH • More progressive than FDR? • US rep to International Labor Organization – 1935 (FDR ploy?) • Social Security Administration Commissioner – 1935 - 1936 • Back to ILO in 1937; director of ILO by 1939

  29. John Winant • Travelled extensively in Europe during run up to war • Well known in UK • Appointed Ambassador to UK in Jan, 1941 • FDR need someone to clean up the mess exacerbated by Kennedy • UK reaction was jubilant • “I'm very glad to be here. There is no place I'd rather be at this time than in England.” • “Here You Shall Not Pass” • Close relationship with Churchill and British government, particularly Foreign Office and Anthony Eden. Part of Churchill’s extended family

  30. John Winant • Often explained “the basics” to support Churchill • Embassy staff operated as a team • “… complete confidence and respect that your Ambassador has won from all classes of people in England. He will become, I believe, before he leaves, the most beloved American who has ever been in England” • Frustrated (as were others) with FDR’s waffling • Did FDR not want the responsibility of an overt act? • “What America requires is not propaganda but the facts” • “We have all slept … we have all tried … we are now beginning … • Every day we delay …

  31. W. Averell Harriman • Son of railroad (robber) baron • The right schools: Groton, Yale (Skull & Bones) • Social links with FDR but completely different personalities • Intensely pragmatic • Banking, Union Pacific and other RR interests, Shipping, horse racing interests; polo player • Travelled extensively in Europe brokering deals • Enjoyed meeting and befriending powerful people • Switched from Republican to Democratic parties in 1928 • Recognized shift of power from Wall Street to Washington

  32. W. Averell Harriman • On the fringes of the New Deal • Wanted more important position on FDR’s team • Revive American business • Positions in NRA, Natl Industrial Recovery, Natl Advisory Council, Office of Production Mgmt • Not involved in early mobilization planning • Internationalist and interventionist • When Hopkins returned from UK (early ’41), he specifically requested Harriman as the UK side of Lend-Lease • FDR: “I want you to go over to London and recommend everything that we can do, short of war, to keep the British Isles afloat.”

  33. W. Averell Harriman • “Defense Expeditor” • “The great thing about Averell was that everything he did, he did bloody well.” • FDR provided few specifics; OK by Harriman • Custodian of “the relationship” Hopkins had initiated • US military: not much value in sending scarce equipment unless UK had bases, men, … • US military: are we to be a warehouse for the British or a fighting partner? • Key Goal: get more information to convince US military

  34. W. Averell Harriman • Felt optimistic with Hopkins in charge • Developed relationship with Churchill on a par with Hopkin’s … the American member • Even closer relationship with Churchill’s daughter-in-law, Pamela • Quickly settled in to the job • Excellent liaison with Winant’s office • Coordinated the mess of special missions • Experience with railroads and shipping • Battle of the Atlantic Two impatient men, an ocean apart, linking up and working with each other to save Britain

  35. W. Averell Harriman • Placentia Bay participant • Mission to USSR (follow up to Hopkins) to negotiate details of Lend-Lease to USSR • Churchill’s “efficiency expert”; trip to Egypt • Quite critical of FDR’s waffling … “I have made my decision …” • Better understanding of British capability (pre Barbarossa) • Would fight to the finish • But not capable of finishing it • Direct American intervention would be required.

  36. FDR Signs Lend Lease

  37. Lend Lease • Lend-Lease was a critical factor in the eventual success of the Allies in World War II. • In 1943–1944, about a quarter of all British munitions came through Lend-Lease. • Aircraft (in particular transport aircraft) comprised about a quarter of the shipments to Britain, followed by food, land vehicles and ships.

  38. Lend Lease • Even after the United States forces in Europe and the Pacific began to reach full strength in 1943–1944, Lend-Lease continued. • Most remaining allies were largely self-sufficient in front line equipment (such as tanks and fighter aircraft) by this stage, Lend-Lease logistical supplies (including motor vehicles and railroad equipment) were of enormous assistance.

  39. Lend Lease • Much of the aid can be better understood when considering the economic distortions caused by the war. • Most belligerent powers cut back severely on production of non-essentials, concentrating on producing weapons. • This inevitably produced shortages of related products needed by the military or as part of the military-industrial complex or essential non-military goods.

  40. Lend Lease • The USSR was highly dependent on rail transportation, but the war practically shut down rail equipment production: only about 92 locomotives were produced. 2,000 locomotives and 11,000 railcars were supplied under Lend-Lease. • Likewise, the Soviet air force received 18,700 aircraft, which amounted to about 14% of Soviet aircraft production (19% for military aircraft).

  41. Lend Lease • Although most Red Army tank units were equipped with Soviet-built tanks, their logistical support was provided by hundreds of thousands of U.S.-made trucks. • By 1945 nearly two-thirds of the truck strength of the Red Army was U.S.-built. Trucks such as the Dodge 3/4 ton and Studebaker 2½ ton, were easily the best trucks available in their class on either side on the Eastern Front. • American shipments of telephone cable, aluminum, canned rations, and clothing were also critical.

  42. Lend Lease • Hopkins on one end and Harriman on the other • Two focused and impatient men • Understood that ultimately it is the total system that must work: war material, support material, transportation, spare parts, people, training,… , LOGISTICS!

  43. Economics

  44. Harriman’s Businesses • Harriman was a true “tycoon” and had extensive business interests (full and partial ownership) • Banking (Brown Bros Harriman, Guaranty Trust, Union Banking, …) • Railroads (Union Pacific, Southern Pacific, Illinois Central, • Shipping (Holland American, Pacific Mail, US Lines, …), • Racing stables • Other transportation (Wells Fargo,

  45. Harriman’s Businesses • Harriman’s bank was main Wall Street connection for German companies • Not illegal until Hitler declared war on US and “Trading With The Enemy” Act was passed • In Oct ’42 several of Harriman’s companies were seized: • Union Banking Corporation (UBC) (from Thyssen and Brown Brothers Harriman). • Holland-American Trading Corporation (from Harriman) • the Seamless Steel Equipment Corporation (from Harriman) • Silesian-American Corporation

  46. Pamela Churchill • Originally married to Randolph (WSC’s son) • Affair with Harriman • Affair with Murrow • Affairs with … • Post WWII: affairs with major players on the continent • Widow in 1971 when she met Harriman at a party • Married Harriman two months later • Washington hostess • US ambassador to France under Clinton

  47. Further Reading • “To Keep The British Isles Afloat” • Thomas Parrish • Focus is Hopkins and Harriman • “Citizens of London” • Lynn Olson • Focus is Harriman, Murrow, Winant • “The Murrow Boys” • Lynn Olson

  48. Questions • Was Britain as bad off as they claimed in late 1940 and early 1941? • What was the threat of invasion then? • Would tools and such be enough? • What else did Churchill really want? • What was FDR’s real strategy? • What impact did Murrow and his boys have? • Did these men make history or did history make these men?

More Related