1 / 44

Indonesia AND AUSTRALIA

Indonesia AND AUSTRALIA. Assoc Prof Greg Fealy Asialink Leaders Program, March 2013. outline. Key Indonesian historical events and Australia’s role Current trends in Indonesia Political Economic Socio-cultural and demographic Contemporary Australia-Indonesia relations.

odin
Download Presentation

Indonesia AND AUSTRALIA

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Indonesia AND AUSTRALIA Assoc Prof Greg Fealy Asialink Leaders Program, March 2013

  2. outline • Key Indonesian historical events and Australia’s role • Current trends in Indonesia • Political • Economic • Socio-cultural and demographic • Contemporary Australia-Indonesia relations

  3. Is indonesia important? • In what ways is Indonesia important to Australia? • What are key elements of discourse in Australia about Indonesia? • Does Australia over-emphasise Indonesia’s importance? • Is Indonesia more important to Australia than Australia is to it?

  4. Indonesia’s importance • Military and Strategic • Threat of military attack from Indonesia • Invaders attacking through Indonesian archipelago • Impact of cooperation or antagonism in facing regional crises (eg China) • Diplomatic: Indonesian role in securing or denying Australian diplomatic ambitions • Economic: 12th most important trading partner • Cultural and Educational

  5. Difference and self-definition • Much of discourse is about stark differences between Australia and Indonesia • Size and geography • Ethnicity • Religion • Wealth • Cultural heritage • Difference as threat or opportunity; defining Australia’s attitude to region through Indonesia • Compare Pauline Hanson and Paul Keating

  6. Indonesian political History • Dutch colonial state • Japanese Occupation, 1942-45 • Indonesian Revolution, 1945-49 • Parliamentary Democracy, 1950-59 • Sukarno’s Guided Democracy, 1959-66 • Soeharto’s New Order Period, 1966-98 • Post-SoehartoReformasi, 1998-Present • 24 years of democracy; 39 years of authoritarianism

  7. Sukarno Period (1945-1967) • Period of great political and regional instability as well as economic decline • Sukarno was a great champion of anti-colonialism and ‘Third World’ diplomatic activism • Staged Asia-Africa conference in 1955 • Leading role in formation of Non-Aligned Movement in 1961 • Vehemently opposed to Dutch retention of Papua (1945-1962) and British-sponsored creation of Malaysia in 1963 • Increasingly leftwards drift in Indonesian diplomacy during early to mid-1960s

  8. ‘Crush Malaysia’ billboard from 1964

  9. Mao and Sukarno, 1964

  10. Suharto Period (1966-1998) • Period of political repression but rapid economic growth • Suharto implacably anti-communist and re-oriented Indonesian foreign policy towards West • Courted US and Japan, as well as World Bank and IMF • Rejoined the UN in late 1960s • Continued NAM role; reluctant OIC participant • Played key role in establishing ASEAN in 1967 • Believed region should be united against external threat and manipulation • Insisted on principle of non-intervention by ASEAN nations in each others’ affairs (‘The ASEAN Way’) and decisions through consensus • Strong APEC supporter

  11. John Gorton and Soeharto

  12. Soeharto chairing the 1994 NAM Conference in Jakarta

  13. Post-Suharto Period (1998-Present) • Four Presidents (Habibie, Abdurrahman Wahid, Megawati and SBY) but considerable consistency in foreign policy outlook • Habibie travelled little; domestically preoccupied • Abdurrahman constantly abroad but little system to his foreign policy • Megawati was conservative and uneasy on diplomatic stage • All maintained priority on ASEAN but harmonious relations with West • Indonesian dominance of ASEAN greatly diminished during this period; greater Malaysian and Singaporean influence

  14. ASEAN Members – Dark Blue ASEAN Observers – Light Blue ASEAN +3 Members – Red EAST ASIA SUMMIT – Red and Green ASEAN Regional Forum – Red, Green and Orange

  15. SBY(2004-Present) • SusiloBambangYudhoyono has arguably been Indonesia’s most effective president abroad • Eloquent speeches, dignified bearing, quick to grasp policy details • Popular in West, among both governments and media • Lauded as model Muslim leader because a ‘moderate democrat’ • Pretensions of being world statesman but tendency to over-reach • Offered to broker peace in Middle East and Korean Peninsular • Failed attempts to mediate between Sunni and Shia

  16. Indonesia’s Strategic Concerns • Paramount concern for unity and territorial integrity of the nation • Powerful sense of vulnerability due to colonial experience, geography and internal diversity • Indonesia’s bitter experience of Dutch colonialism • Dutch seen as exploitative, harsh and paternalistic • Left enduring perception that large foreign powers are inherently predatory and manipulative • This has fuelled Indonesia’s long non-aligned orientation

  17. Indonesia’s Strategic Concerns • Indonesia is world’s largest archipelagic nation; 5000 kms from Aceh to Papua; some 18,000 islands • Attendant problems for archipelagos: porous borders, difficulties in transport and communications, obstacles in administering and defending far-flung territories • Fear of loss of islands: Malaysia’s successful case to sovereignty over Sidapan and Ligitan islands • Sheer complexity of ethnic, religious and cultural make-up raises risk of disintegration • History of separatism based on ethnic, religious or regional economic sentiment

  18. Indonesia’s Strategic Concerns • All these combine to give many Indonesians a spectre of insecurity • At times, can have almost paranoiac overtones • Discourses about other countries seeking to break Indonesia up for their own purposes • To extract its wealth, to pursue religious or strategic agendas • Australia, US, Britain, the Netherlands, Malaysia, Singapore, Israel, China and Japan all placed, at different times, in this discourse of threats

  19. Broader Indonesia Strategic Concerns • Malaysian border disputes, especially re Ambalat • Increase in naval capability partly directed at Malaysians • SBY specifically referred in cabinet to stopping Malaysia pushing Indonesia around • China’s South China Sea policies and impact upon ASEAN and regional stability • Phnom Penh impasse on ASEAN communique • People smuggling (rather than boat people) • Terrorism and insurgency issues

  20. Indonesian Suspicions of Australia • Australia’s role in supporting Indonesian independence in 1945-49 • Irritation over Australia’s support for Dutch retention of West Irian/Papua in late 1950s and early 1960s • East Timor destabilised relations from mid-1970s till early 2000s • Papua now most sensitive issue in bilateral relationship

  21. Sukarno and Critchley

  22. Papua • Widespread view in Indonesian political and military elite after 1999 that Australian govt actively supporting Papuan independence • BIN report on secret Cosgrove-led committee • TNI plans for ‘re-taking’ Papua from Australia • From 1999-c.2005 constant Indonesian demands for Australia to affirm territorial integrity • Papuan issue has eased in recent years but strong possibility of re-emergence due to rising separatist sentiment

  23. Lombok Treaty • Partly intended to allay Indonesian fears that Australia might support Papuan separatism (following granting of refugee status to Papuan independence activists) • Key clause: [two sides promise] ‘not to … support or participate in activities … which constitute a threat to sovereignty and territorial integrity’ • Underlying tone of mistrust and suspicion rather than shared interests and concerns • Unlikely to have significant impact on relations

  24. Who is more important in bi-lateral relationship?

  25. ‘Thank heavens for SBY!’ • SBY has been forgiving president regarding Australian missteps. Repeatedly responded helpfully and calmed domestic irritation. • Ban on live cattle exports • Boat people • Clemency for Schappelle Corby • US marines in northern Australia • Cocos Islands as US naval base • ‘SBY is as good as it gets for Australia’

  26. Bright prospects • Indonesia predicted to be major economic force in next few decades • Numerous international agencies have Indonesia as one of top ten economies by 2020-2025 (currently 18th) • Favourable demographics fuelling strong domestic demand • Now a trillion-dollar economy, a G20 member and IMF donor • Hal Hill: good times in Indonesia lead to bad policies • Some evidence of this already: growing sense that growth is irreversible leading to less discipline • Premature sense of global importance and risk of over-reaching

  27. Contemporary politics • Indonesia consistently lauded as only ‘fully’ democratic nation in Southeast Asia and also one of few Muslim majority democracies in the world. • Praised as model of tolerance and pluralism • Praise not entirely deserved • Indonesia experiencing some democratic regression: elite forces driving process but staunch resistance from civil society and media (eg of Anti-Corruption Commission and changing election laws) • Worsening record of religious intolerance (greater restrictions on religious expression and growing sectarianism)

  28. Presidential elections • Significance of 2014 parliamentary and presidential elections: victory to an autocratic or oligarchic leaders could accelerate anti-democratic trend; progressive leader could revive reform process • Leading candidates are PrabowoSubianto and JokoWidodo – stark choice between them • Prabowo is former 3-star general who was dismissed for human rights abuses • Highly articulate and intellectual but also ruthless • Led polls until late 2012

  29. Jokowi • Elected governor of Jakarta in Sept 2012 after successful stint as Surakarta mayor • Very unconventional but charismatic politician with strong grassroots appeal • Changed dynamics of politics during 2012 • Now leading most polls and seemingly has momentum to win nomination

  30. Post-SBY Australian-Indonesian Relations • Possibility of much less congenial Indonesian president from 2014 • Worst case scenario would be PrabowoSubianto • Risks for bilateral relations in Australian assertiveness on boat people • Indonesia punching below weight in international fora • ‘One million friends and zero enemies’ approach leads to risk avoidance and minimal gains

More Related