1 / 30

Hazardous Air Pollutants: A Policy Comparison

Hazardous Air Pollutants: A Policy Comparison. IU at Oxford V550, Comparative Environmental Policy Morgan Conway, Kristen Davee , Julie Elmore, Andrew Rector. Air Pollutants—The Basics. What are they? “Substances which alter the composition of the natural atmosphere”

patty
Download Presentation

Hazardous Air Pollutants: A Policy Comparison

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Hazardous Air Pollutants: A Policy Comparison IU at Oxford V550, Comparative Environmental Policy Morgan Conway, Kristen Davee, Julie Elmore, Andrew Rector

  2. Air Pollutants—The Basics • What are they? • “Substances which alter the composition of the natural atmosphere” • Physical classification • Gas molecules or particulate matter • Where do they come from? • Natural sources vs. Anthropogenic sources • Mobile sources vs. Stationary sources • What happens after emission? • Primary pollutants vs. Secondary pollutants • Issues of scale

  3. Classification of Hazardous Air Pollutants (HAPs) • Differs across countries • Generally substances such as: • Heavy metals • Acid gases • Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) • Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) • Other organic air toxics • Why should we care?

  4. Heavy Metals • Cadmium, Lead, Mercury, Arsenic, Nickel • Low atmospheric concentrations, BUT they can: • Persist in the environment • Bioaccumulate in food chains • Undergo long-range atmospheric transport

  5. Other Categories • Organic Air Toxics • Benzene • PAHs • PCBs • Acid Gases • Will form an acidic solution when mixed with water • Carbon dioxide, sulfur oxides, hydrofluoric acid, and hydrochloric acid

  6. Technology • Clean air regulation for acid rain and smog has spurred innovation • Optimal combination of control technologies varies • Co-benefits • Plasma control systems

  7. Automobile Emissions • Exhaust contents: carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides, heavy metals, and hydrocarbons (benzene, PAHs) • Methods to control emissions from gasoline-powered vehicles • Improve the combustion system • Target pollutants in the exhaust line • Seal off areas open to the atmosphere and return evaporative emissions to the intake line

  8. Market Failures • Incomplete property rights • Public good nature of the environment/atmosphere • Externalities • Information • Lack of understanding • Asymmetries • How can we correct these?!

  9. Name That Policy Tool! • Command and Control • Technology Standards • Performance Standards • Ambient Standards • Market-Based Instruments • Marketable Allowances • Mutant Combination instruments • C&C with input coordination • Information programs

  10. United States Approach to HAPs • One-size-fits-all approach to most substances • Lead an important exception • PCB use eliminated in 1979 http://www.londonair.org.uk/london/asp/news.asp?newsid=Cleanair

  11. U.S. HAP Regulation • 1990 amendments to Clean Air Act • 189 substances listed as “hazardous air pollutants” • No scientific reason for including these on the list • Mechanisms established under amendments • Distinction between “major” and “area” sources • “Maximum available control technologies” • Additional measure: information sharing

  12. Scientific Uncertainty

  13. Six Criteria Pollutants • 1990 amendments also created list of “criteria pollutants” • Common, dangerous pollutants regulated via set exposure standards • National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) • Policy mechanisms • State Implementation Plans (SIPs) • Permits

  14. Lead: A Unique Case • Lead phased out of gasoline from 1973-1996 • Tradable permit system in place from 1982-1987 • Government set standard for how much lead could be in a gallon of gas (and kept lowering the limit) • Companies not able to meet the standard could buy permits from those that could

  15. PCBs: Another Unique Case • Toxic Substances Control Act of 1976 (TSCA) • PCB use and manufacture banned under TSCA in 1979 • Some very old appliances could still have PCBs • EPA runs disposal programs for these

  16. Policy Evolution • Why choose these tools? • Uncertainty over science • Dramatic health/environmental effects of some substances • Political expediency http://www.edupics.com/coloring-page-factories-pollution-i7640.html

  17. Canada and HAPS • What is a “HAP” in Canada? • Canadian Environmental Protection Act of 1999 (CEPA) • Administered in parts by both the Minister of the Environment and the Minister of Health • Allows for regulation of Toxic 1 substances • Does not prescribe regulations • National Pollutant Release Inventory (NPRI)

  18. CEPA 1999 • Goals • Prevent pollution • Protect the environment and human health • Guiding Principles • Pollution prevention • Virtual elimination • Precautionary Principle • Intergovernmental Cooperation

  19. Benzene Control in Canada • Regulations • Benzene in Gas Regulations • Best Management Practices • For natural gas dehydrators • Environmental Code of Practice • For non-integrated steel mills • For integrated steel mills

  20. Heavy Metals in Canada • First addressed with the formation of the Department of the Environment • Differing regulations for each metal • 8 national regulations or standards for airborne Mercury • 8 national regulations and Environmental Performance Agreements for airborne lead • 4 guidelines or codes of practice for inorganic cadmium

  21. Major Policy Tools ¡Name that policy tool! • Regulations • Environmental Performance Agreements • Coordination between Environment Canada, Industry and NGO’s • Increased flexibility and better public image • Code of Practice • Integrated document outlining environmental concerns, minimum performance standards and environmental goals • Best Management Practices • Guidelines

  22. United Kingdom Air Pollutants

  23. The Great Smog 1952

  24. Environmental Act of 1995 • Created: • Environmental Agency • National Air Quality Standards • Local Air Quality Management

  25. European Union • EU Air Quality 1996 • NOx, SOx, O3, CO, PM • First Daughter (1999) • Second Daughter (2000) • Third Daughter (2002) • Fourth Daughter (2004)

  26. Mother of all Air Quality in EU • EU Air Quality of 2008 (Directive 2008/50/EC ) • Merges existing regulation into one • Incorporates latest health and scientific data • Aim: • Ease administrative burden • Better clarity

  27. UK Air Quality (NAQS) • UK Air Quality Strategy of 97 • Under Environmental Act 1995 • Set targets for 8 pollutants • Benzene, 1,3-butadiene, CO, lead, NO2, Ozone PM and SO2 • Air Quality Strategy of 2010 • EU Air Quality directive made law • Incorporates 4th daughter directive

  28. UK Air Quality - LAQM • Local authorities must assess air quality • Review and assess • Monitor and mathematical models • Air Quality Management Area (AQMA) • Action plans • In 2007, there were 208 AQMAs • Most missed standards due to auto emissions

  29. General Themes • The role of government • Supranational, national, state/provincial, local • Use of the Precautionary Principle • Relevant/supporting science (or lack thereof) • Use of “command and control” measures • The role of uncertainty in policy instrument choice

  30. Thank You For Your Attention • This is time for • Questions • Comments • Comparisons • Critiques Check new tools off your lifetime policy list!

More Related