1 / 16

Fuelling the Indian entrepreneur – Opportunities in SME

Fuelling the Indian entrepreneur – Opportunities in SME. Bancon 2010 Panel Discussion. Presentation by Ramnath Balasubramanian, McKinsey & Co. December 3 rd , 2010. CONFIDENTIAL AND PROPRIETARY Any use of this material without specific permission of McKinsey & Company is strictly prohibited.

riva
Download Presentation

Fuelling the Indian entrepreneur – Opportunities in SME

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Fuelling the Indian entrepreneur – Opportunities in SME Bancon 2010 Panel Discussion Presentation by Ramnath Balasubramanian, McKinsey & Co December 3rd, 2010 CONFIDENTIAL AND PROPRIETARY Any use of this material without specific permission of McKinsey & Company is strictly prohibited

  2. SME sector in India • Contributes to ~39% of country’s manufacturing output • Contributes to ~34% of exports and ~20% of imports • Provides employment to ~68 mn people in rural and urban areas of country India has more than 8 million SMEs contributing significantly to the country’s GDP, exports and employment • Number of • Companies • CAGR • (no. of co.’s) • Turnover cutoff • Rs. crore • % • 1,500 • 22 • Large corporates • >500 • Mid corporates • 4,000 • 19 • 125-500 • 18 • 200,000 • Medium SME 10-125 • SME • 22 • 1,500,000 • Small SME 2-10 • 6,500,000 • 25 • Micro SME <2 SOURCE: Prowess database; market interview; India Budget 2006-07; team analysis

  3. SME banking revenue pool will grow at a CAGR of 16% over the next five years with growth being uniform amongst various products • ESTIMATES Mix of SME revenue pool SME revenue pool INR '000s crore INR '000s crore, percent • 65-75 • Investment banking • 32 • 1 • 1 • 100% • 3 • 3 • CMS • FX and rates • Trade finance • 16% • Deposits • Lending • FY 2009 • 2015E • 2015E • FY 09 • FY 15 SOURCE: RBI data; Prowess data; market interviews; McKinsey analysis

  4. 6 • 10 • 15 • 1 • 14 • 2 • 13 • 3 • 12 • 11 • 5 • 2 • 4 • 9 • 3 • 1 • 5 • 6 • 9 • 4 • 8 • 8 • 7 • 7 Over 70% of SME advances revenue is concentrated in the top 15 cities and 9 industries • ESTIMATES • SME advances revenues • SME advances revenues Percent Percent • Mumbai • Whole Sale Traders • Delhi • Remaining cities • Textiles • 14 • Chennai • Remaining sectors • 30 • Kolkata • 25 Cluster cities • IT and professional services • 11 • Bangalore • Hyderabad • Retail traders • Ahmedabad • Metal works • Coimbatore • Pune • Food processing • Top 15 cities • Top 9 • sectors • 75 • Chandigarh • 70 • Real estate • Ludhiana • Jaipur • Transport and logistics • Vadodara • Ernakulam • Auto and Auto ancillary • Surat SOURCE: RBI; McKinsey analysis

  5. SME is a relatively profitable segment, but returns could vary based on operating model and ability to manage risks • ESTIMATES Percent of average advances Risk-adjusted ROA for high performing SME Bank • Three key drivers of profitability of SME segment • Ability to manage risk (loan losses) • Cross sell deposit and fee income-related products to SMEs • Manage operating costs of serving SME segment • Lending • NII • Risk cost • RiskadjustedNII • Deposit • NII • Fee • Income • Opex • Risk-adjusted ROA Risk-adjusted ROA for under-performing SME segment • Lending • NII • Risk cost • RiskadjustedNII • Deposit • NII • Fee • Income • Opex • Risk-adjusted ROA SOURCE: Central bank data; expert interview; 2008 Asia Pacific SME Banking Report

  6. SMEs’ financial needs can be broadly classified into three categories + • Complexity of cash management needs • “Enabling • day to day • business” Conducting daily transactions Managing and investing high cash flow • “Creating flexibility and acquiringassets” • Lifespan of assets and liabilities • Traditionally served • Core • financial • needs • 1 Managing and financing working capital Acquiring and maintaining assets • Complexity of risk protection • “Managing business-related risks” Single “isolated” risks Multiparty and complex risks • Stake-holders related • needs SME owner and shareholders • “Serving stakeholders’ financial needs” • 2 SME employees and management SME suppliers and/or customers • Rarely served • Lifecycle-based long-term financing needs • Life-cycle related • needs • “Supporting • strategic • growth” • 3 Starting the business Changing the business – SOURCE: McKinsey

  7. % SMEs are extremely loyal to their primary bank with ~70% of SMEs have banking relationships of more than 6 years • Tenure of relationship with lending bank (percent) • Top 15 cities • Cluster cities • 10 or more years • 6-9 years • 3-5 years • Upto 2 years • Similar trend observed for transacting bank as well SOURCE: McKinsey SME survey

  8. There are 7 key elements of a successful SME business • 1 • Appropriate customer segmentationand value proposition to ensure different types of SMEs are served according to their needs • 2 • Business modelchoice– in terms of traditional lending based vs. liability led vs. technology led (e.g., supply chain financing) • 3 • Servicing model to ensure rapid turn-around times at low cost to serve (e.g., internet, loan factories) • 4 • Relationship management and branch architecture to cover and provide specialised services to SME • 5 • SME-specific risk rating tools in a relatively data-scarce environment using qualitative credit assessment based techniques • 6 • Suitable operating architecture in terms of centralisations vs decentralisation of mid and back-office functions • 7 • Putting in place the appropriate organisation construct and business performance management system to ensure the right focus on the segment SOURCE: McKinsey

  9. Deposit and cash flow packages • Volume correlated products • Sector specific offers ¹ • 1. Segmentation and value proposition Value proposition: Bundled offers can help drive cross-selling • Description • Examples • Combination of business account and/or personal account in one single package (or two business or personal banking products tied-up) with a fee discount • Interests/loan size relationship benefits on business/individual account, e.g., • Business offset services reduce amount of interest on business loan based on balance in personal deposit account • Loan size determined based on deposit balances with bank • Combination of businessand individualoriented products that are tailored to a specific sector(e.g., doctors, lawyers) ¹ 1 Limited number of sector specific offers available including non-profit, agricultural and professional services SOURCE: McKinsey; mystery shopping; company websites

  10. 100 Traditional 800 Supply chain 100 ~65 ~75 ~55 ~300 • 2. Business model Business model choice : Supply chain based approach • CLIENT EXAMPLE • Example of channel financing strategy deployed by a successful bank • Impact achieved Profitability of supply chain lending vs. traditional lending • Needs-based segmentation,focus on SME within large corporate’s supply chain • Performance managementand incentive system driving cross-unit collaboration • Use of proprietary scoring model and client profitabilityin credit assessment and pricing • Streamlined, seamlessIT-platform across segments and products, leveraging full transaction information Basis points, indexed Risk adjusted revenues Cross-sell opportunities on supply chain finance Basis points, indexed Risk adjusted lending revenue Trade services cross-sales Cash management cross-sales FX cross-sales Total revenues SOURCE: “Serving Asian SMEs” KIP team, 2008; expert interviews

  11. 5 • Impact achieved • 2. Business model Business model choice : Integrating business and personal wealth needs of SMEs • ASIAN CLIENT EXAMPLE • Example of integrated business and personal relationship approach Additional profits from cross sale of SME banking products to wealth management SME customers Indexed • Identified overlap and cross-sales potential for both wealth mana-gement and SME banking • Developed of SME owner specific wealth management offering based on insights from SME interaction behavior • Refined organization model with aligned performance management and incentives to further cross-unit collaboration • Installed referral system and eventual collaboration model to facilitate cross-unit sales • ~100 Current profit from SME owner’s WM • ~245 Net interest income • ~75 Net fee income Operation cost • ~145 Risk cost • ~65 Profit • ~110 • ~210 Additional profits from increased WM penetration of SME and wallet share of SME owner’s WM Indexed • ~100 Current profit from SME owner’s WM • ~195 Increased wallet share of SME owner’s WM • ~180 Increased WM penetration of SME Operation cost • ~110 Profit • ~265 • ~365 SOURCE: “Serving Asian SMEs” KIP team, 2008; expert interviews

  12. Quantitative rating • (statistical score) • Qualitative credit • assessment • Combined rating • Statistical techniques • Logistic regression • CHAID • Neural networks • Focus on quantitative or quantifiable data • Financials • Credit bureau information • Demographics (e.g., age) • Account information (e.g., balance, monthly turnover) • One overall rating and Probability of Default • Method of combination chosen based on the relative performance of the two underlying ratings • Appraisal of the business • Operating environment • Cash flow forecasting • Asset valuation • Management, etc. • Presented as a series of questions with pre-defined answer options (check boxes) • 6. Risk management Effective mitigation of risk in SMEs will need a combined quantitative and qualitative credit assessment approach SOURCE: McKinsey Risk Management Practice

  13. 6. Risk management A combination of quantitative and qualitative modelshas consistently yielded better results across markets • Quantitative model only • Quantitative model + separate QCA Predictive power (GINI) in points, sample cases • The QCA (Qualitative Credit Assessment) adds unique insights to credit assessment • Quantification of inherently qualitative factors such as management quality • Validation of financials and other fraud indicators • Flexible approach to limited data availability (e.g., by quantifying also degree of uncertainty around a data point) • India • Taiwan • Hong Kong • China • North America SOURCE: McKinsey Risk Management Practice

  14. In summary • 1 • SME is a large, fast growing and attractive opportunity for banks and financial institutions and a significant contributor to the economy • 2 • Needs of SMEs are evolving rapidly - financial institutions will need to look beyond core financial needs for this segment • 3 • The segment is very local and can be very profitable for banks – but managing profitability will require a very sound business model • 4 • Financial institutions will need to create a differentiated model to serve this segment and build excellence in one or more of seven dimensions SOURCE: McKinsey

  15. Backup

  16. Proximity to branch and competitive prices appear as the top two buying factors • Key Buying Factors (KBFs) Percentage of respondents stating in top 5 factors • KBFs – lending bank • KBFs – transacting bank • Factors • Factor importance • Factors • Factor importance • Proximity to branch • Proximity to branch • Competitive prices • Competitive prices • Brand name/reputation • Brand name/reputation • Trustworthiness of • the bank • Trustworthiness of • the bank • Turnaround time • Turnaround time • Level of documentation • Level of documentation SOURCE: McKinsey SME survey

More Related