1 / 19

FIGARO WP7 Assessment

FIGARO WP7 Assessment. WP status & planning June 4 2013. Stated goals WP. Objectives to develop and adapt assessment tools to appropriately evaluate the FIGARO platform to assess FIGARO Platform performance on a number of levels. Assessing DSS. Slide 3.

stokely
Download Presentation

FIGARO WP7 Assessment

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. FIGARO WP7 Assessment WP status & planning June 4 2013

  2. Stated goals WP Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Objectives • to develop and adapt assessment tools to appropriately evaluate the FIGARO platform • to assess FIGARO Platform performance on a number of levels.

  3. Assessing DSS Slide3 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Assessing decision supporttool • Internal consistency verification • Empirical quality validation • User satisfaction in operating tool

  4. So, what to assess • Issues • - Verification • Attractiveness / relevance information GUI • Operability GUI (ease of use / qualifications) • Flexibility for plugging in DSSs / models / data • Reference • - uManage, Aquasafe, … Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity

  5. So, what to assess • Additional issues • validity models / sensor data / forecasts • trust of users in models / data / forecasts • - projected benefits recommended actions for users • power to convince to adopt recommendation • Reference • growers experience / insight • current operation Slide5 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity

  6. Assessment inside / outside platform? Slide6 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity

  7. Assessment inside / outside platform? Slide7 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity object to be assessed instrument to assess • Independent assessments are stronger (empirical evidence + expert-models + literature validate adopted model) • Validation ‘just’ using empirical data can do (validation strategy required modest claims should be acceptable)

  8. Assessment indicators Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Relevant indicator themes • Economic performance of farm • Environmental performance of farm / catchment • Platform use Different users, stakeholders will require / request different assessment indicators, or use other definitions Sources: FAO, IWMI, ICID, Safir, Figaro partners

  9. Economic performance Under uncertainty: link to uncertainty management strategy user ‘risk avoidance’: forecast benefit vs marginal or small but relevant potential damage (user self-characterization) underlying primary / secondary data ? • Today, no irrigation is necessary, because • sensor says soil is still wet • model says it will rain Slide9 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Net Present Value Gross return on investment investment intensity / O&M cost intensity payback time Economic water / land productivity Irrigation efficiency, energy efficiency Water / energy /nutrient / labour saving Energy dependency Yield increase will be delivered by UniBo / data Aquacrop + UPVLC

  10. Environmental performance Slide10 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Water saving Reduction in water scarcity, other externalities Water productivity / water footprint (blue, green) Land productivity Reductions in nutrient leaching, salinization Energy saving will be delivered by UT, UPVLC, C-Tech scale: farm + potential larger scales

  11. Platform use Slide11 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Appropriateness of functionality Required skills for usage / ease of use Flexibility to plug in models / data / forecasts Flexibility to put in user preferred operations / strategies Robustness / durability of platform (/ system?) Accuracy of actual operation and impacts compared to controls and projections will have to be defined, with WP 8,9, UT, UniBo, … involved scale: farm

  12. Tasks / deliverables Slide12 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Task 7.1 Define key performance indicators (KPI) and benchmarks for performance assessment and indication of success. (M1-M6) • (UT, C-Tech, UNIBO, UPVLC, Netafim, IIT, CER, FAO,IST, Eden) • Status: Draft report accomplished; closure as anticipated still requiring finalizing steps.

  13. Tasks / deliverables Slide13 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Task 7.1 Define key performance indicators (KPI) and benchmarks for performance assessment and indication of success. (M1-M6) • Upcoming activities complete detailed definition indicators required data matching sources (+ defaults) benchmarks stakeholder priorities questionnaire iteration + collecting responses (WP8)

  14. Tasks / deliverables Slide14 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Task 7.2 Development of assessment methods and tools (M5-M30) • (UT, UNIBO, UPVLC, IIT) • Status: Starting; upgrade output 7.1 in coming 3 months; expected to be compatible with original plans proposal. • Model work partly in WP 2 / 3 (UPVLC, UniBo) • Further development water footprint analysis (UT) • LCA-oriented will be planned with C-Tech

  15. Tasks / deliverables Slide15 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Task 7.3 Quantification of fresh water and energy savings at farm level. (M19-M42) • (UT, UPVLC) • Starting next year; 7.2 results provide sufficient tools. Extending WP 8,9 work in scenario’s (climate, potential)

  16. Tasks / deliverables Slide16 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Task 7.4 Techno-economic assessment.(M25-M45) • (UT) Coming year: - Specify; get in partners to contribute Netafim, UniBo, …

  17. Tasks / deliverables Slide17 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Task 7.5 Environmental impact assessment.(M31-M48) • (Netafim, UT, UNIBO, AU, HR, UPVLC, C-Tech, Eden, Hidromod, IST, CER, IIT, AgroSens, FAO) • With field-site & assessment partners interpret scenario’s (climate, potential application) to reduced externalities / basin scale Coming year: questionnaire results of regional / water management authorities will be used to set the scene Define further repeditive monitoring with questionnaire

  18. Tasks / deliverables Slide18 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Task 7.6 Lessons learned and policy guidelines (M4-M5, M15-M18, M35-M38, M41-M48 • (UT, UNIBO, AU, PED-AMT). • Status: project-internal learning

  19. Tasks / deliverables Slide19 Flexible and precIse irriGation plAtform to improve faRm scale water prOductivity Wrap up: focus coming year • Finalize assessment indicator specification / priorities • Start required tool development / adaptation • Planning/preparing forthcoming activities

More Related