390 likes | 849 Views
PERCUTANEOUS CT-GUIDED BIOPSY OF THE MUSCULO-SKELETAL SYSTEM: RESULTS OF 1722 CASES. E. Rimondi , P. Ruggieri, G. Bosco , G. Ussia , T. Calabr ò, A. Angelini, G. Rossi, U. Albisinni. Istituto Ortopedico Rizzoli- University of Bologna, Italy. Management of bone tumors.
E N D
PERCUTANEOUS CT-GUIDED BIOPSY OF THE MUSCULO-SKELETAL SYSTEM: RESULTS OF 1722 CASES E. Rimondi, P. Ruggieri, G. Bosco, G. Ussia, T. Calabrò, A. Angelini, G. Rossi, U. Albisinni Istituto Ortopedico Rizzoli- Universityof Bologna, Italy
Management ofbonetumors Plain films Benign appearance Aggressive appearance Stop (for many) CT (if flat bone) MR Imaging benign malignant biopsy (if necessary) Stop (for many) biopsy (if necessary) CT/bone scan/ chest xray or CT biopsy
Biopsyis the last stepof the staging biopsyis a compromise need to have significant tissue needtoavoid contamination (*local / bloodcircul.**) * Schwartz, AnnSurgOncol 1997 **Zoubek, Eur J Pediatry 1996
Typesofbiopsy • Fine needle • Trocar • Incisional • Frozen • Excisional
Roleof CT withcontrast • Size • Site • Morphology • Intra/extra compartmental • Neurovascular bundles
Operative criteria • Choose the approach • Select the trocar • Where to get the sample
Operative criteria:Choose the approach On the line of ideal surgical incision
Operative criteria:Select the trocar Big trocar, big sample
CT-guided trocar biopsy in 1722 ptsRizzoli 1990-2008 Mean age 46 ( SD ± 20)
Site of procedure: Spine 648 (38%) 19 ( 3 %) 192 ( 30 %) 267 ( 41 %) 170 ( 26 %)
Site of procedure: other skeletal sites 125 (7%) 67 (4%) 449 (26%) 433 (25%)
Rizzoli results: 1990 – 2008 Diagnostic Accuracy D.A. 76.5 % 1317 358 47
Common mistakes in biopsies • Surgical approach • Site of the biopsy • Quality of the sample • Tissue preservation
Rizzoli results: 1990 – 2008 Within 30 days 405 pts had another biopsy - Incisional biopsy 45 - Percutaneous biopsy 360 Diagnostic in 316 patients Final accuracy: 95 %
Incisional biopsy only in - previous non diagnostic biopsies in “difficult” cases
Mankin HJ, et al.The hazardsofbiopsy in patientswithmalignantprimarybone and soft tissuetumors. • JBJS Am, 1982 • Mankin HJ, et al. • The hazardsofbiopsy, revisited: membersof the musculoskeletaltumor society. • JBJS Am, 1996 • Wrong diagnoses 17.8 % • Non representativebiopsies 8.4 % • Relatedcomplications 9.0 % • Consequentchanges in treatment and prognosis 10.0 % Differenciesbetweenbiopsiesperformed in specializedreferralCentersand non specializedhospitals. Sameresultsthan in 1982 study!
Harvard medicalschoolseries: • 359 patients with a MS tumor • Treated between 1999 and 2000 • CT-guided core needle biopsy has an overall accuracy of 71% Hauetal, Skeletalradiol2002
Harvard medical school series: • CT-guided core needle biopsy is better than fine needle aspiration biopsy for diagnosis • It is the logical and safe choice for diagnostic studies of patients with MS lesions. Hauetal, Skeletalradiol2002
St Vincent’s series: • 127 patients with a MS tumor • Treated between 1998 and 2001 • CT-guided core needle biopsy has an accuracy of 80.3% Altuntasetal, ANZ J Surg2005
St Vincent’s series: • CT-guided core needle biopsy is safe and effective for the diagnosis of MS lesions. • biopsy should be conducted in the institution performing the definitive treatment Altuntasetal, ANZ J Surg2005
Rizzoli seriesof the spine: • 430 pts with spine lesions • Treated from 1990 to 2005 • 401 diagnostic biopsy • Total accurancy of 93.3 % Rimondi etal, Eur Spine J 2008
Rizzoli seriesof the spine: • Percutaneous CT-guided biopsy is considered the procedure of choice in spine lesions • If biopsy was not diagnostic, another trocar biopsy should be repeated Rimondi etal, Eur Spine J 2008
75-97 % histologic congruity between diagnosis at biopsy and definitive surgery SurgicalPathologist Quantity – Quality of the tissue Knowledge of the case
SurgicalPathologistmust: • Know the case • Talk to surgeon and radiologist • Examine imaging studies
ConclusionWhyCT-guidedbiopsy? • Percutaneous CT-guided biopsy is: - safe - speed - cheap
Conclusions • Percutaneous CT-guided biopsy is a useful technique that should be recommended for most of the bony lesions • Ultrasound-guided biopsy with tru-cut is usually preferable for soft tissues • Careful selection of patients with previous accurate imaging
Gold standard PATHOLOGIST ORTHOPEDIC A TEAM APPROACH RADIOLOGIST ONCOLOGIST