1 / 32

THE USE OF THE MILITARY IN LAW ENFORCEMENT

THE USE OF THE MILITARY IN LAW ENFORCEMENT. The Hernandez Tragedy Case Study. Background: Use of Military Units in U.S. Law Enforcement. U.S. law generally prohibits military from enforcing domestic law Unless specific type of enforcement action authorized in law.

arch
Download Presentation

THE USE OF THE MILITARY IN LAW ENFORCEMENT

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. THE USE OF THE MILITARY IN LAW ENFORCEMENT The Hernandez Tragedy Case Study

  2. Background: Use of Military Unitsin U.S. Law Enforcement • U.S. law generally prohibits military from enforcing domestic law • Unless specific type of enforcement action authorized in law

  3. Background: Use of Military Unitsin U.S. Law Enforcement • Prohibited activities include: • stopping vehicles, vessels, aircraft • searches or seizures, arrests • investigation & interrogation

  4. Military Counter-Drug Assistance Specifically Authorized by Law 1981 share equipment & facilities, train on equipment, surveillance & communications 1989 lead agency for surveillance of illegal drugs entering U.S.

  5. Military Counter-Drug Assistance Specifically Authorized by Law 1991: • maintain, repair, upgrade equipment • transport personnel • provide operations bases • train U.S. & international personnel • construct roads & fencing • command & control networks • intelligence & reconnaissance

  6. Civilian Law Enforcement Agencies Operation Alliance • National • 4 States • Local

  7. Military UnitsSupporting Operation Alliance • Operational • Joint Task Force - SIX (JTF-6) • coordinates & plans military support to drug law enforcement agencies • Tactical • U.S. Marines, 1st Marine Division, 11th Regiment, 5th Battalion

  8. U.S.- Mexico Border: Big Bend Texas Region • cross cultural make-up • vast territory • smugglers & illegal aliens • law abiding citizens

  9. Redford, Texas • Small town; 130 residents • Located on Rio Grande River which marks border with Mexico • River is shallow and can be crossed on foot • Residents usually carry weapons due to potential dangers Redford

  10. Operations Order • Teams watch for and make real time reports on all persons, vehicles, aircraft • Reports will be passed to Border Patrol • Border Patrol agents to respond within 15 minutes

  11. Listening & ObservationPost Teams • Remain concealed during daylight hours • Move to post at night • Wear “gillie suits” & camouflage paint • Armed with M-16A2 rifles

  12. Hole 3 Team Members • Corporal Banuelos, Team Leader, age 22 • Corporal Torrez, age 19 • Lance Corporal Wieler, age 21 • Lance Corporal Blood, age 22

  13. Rules of Engagement (ROE) Card Mistakenly Issued • Force may be used to defend yourself & others • Do not use force if other defensive measures could be effective • Use only minimum force necessary • You may detain any person who poses an imminent threat of serious bodily harm to you or others present. Release to civilian law enforcement soonest. • You may pursue hostile forces only to defend or retrieve military personnel.

  14. ROE Card Which ShouldHave Been Issued • You MAY use only the amount of force necessary and proportional to the threat. • You MAY use deadly force to defend yourself and others from death or serious bodily injury. • You MAY detain any person who poses an imminent threat of death or serious bodily harm; release to civilian law enforcement soonest. • You MAY NOT use deadly force if other measures would be reasonably effective. • You WILL make every effort to avoid confrontation and armed conflict with civilians.

  15. Events of May 20, 1997 1800: Team moves out of hide site to observation post 1805: Marines see man on horseback on Mexican side of border 1805: Team reports another man (Hernandez) on U.S. side carrying a rifle and herding goats Ezequiel Hernandez, age 18

  16. Events of May 20, 1997 1807: Team reports they are taking fire; Border Patrol notified 1811-1814: Team Leader- “As soon as he readies that rifle down range, we are taking him.” Operations Center- “Roger, fire back” Marine Team- “He’s ducking down…he’s looking for us.” Operations Center- “You are to follow the ROE.” Marine Team- does not acknowledge order.

  17. Events of May 20, 1997 1819: Border Patrol radios team that they are on the way 1827: Team reports “…Man down….[He] pointed his weapon down range and we took him out.” Team Leader fired single fatal shot. 1836: Border Patrol arrives at scene.

  18. Marine Mistakes • Mission viewed as training opportunity not potentially dangerous operation • leadership failed to learn from previous shooting incidents • poor support of Marine tactical units by higher Marine headquarters • Marines selected for mission on the basis of availability not skills or training • Marines selected had never worked together & received insufficient training

  19. Marine Lessons Learned Counter-drug support mission: • Analysis • Personnel selection • Training must take into account risk of violent confrontation with civilians & non-combat nature of mission.

  20. Interagency Mistakes • JTF-6 did not communicate operational and tactical requirements • No contingency plans or rehearsals between Marines and Border Patrol • Border Patrol failed to respond to some Marine requests for support • Lack of understanding between Marines and Border Patrol regarding response time

  21. Interagency Mistakes • Border Patrol and JTF-6 provided inaccurate & incomplete tactical information to Marines • may have overstated general criminal involvement of Redford residents • were not informed that Border Patrol agents had previous incident with Hernandez shooting gun • were not informed they were on private land & or houses were nearby • Marine team failed to clearly communicate situation during incident

  22. Interagency Lessons Learned Interagency leadership must: • ensure adequate tactical information is provided • identify training needs • develop contingency plans • provide sufficient support during mission

  23. Rules of EngagementMistakes/Lesson Learned • ROE instruction limited & insufficient • Marines were used to Standing ROE for combat • “scenario fulfillment” phenomena • Cards necessarily lacked likely scenarios Lesson Learned: ROE instruction for non-combat missions must be extensive and specific.

  24. Analysis of Banuelos’ Actions ROE Issued to Banuelos: • Force may be used to defend yourself & others • Do not use force if other defensive measures could be effective • Use only minimum force necessary • You may detain any person who poses an imminent threat of serious bodily harm to you or others present. Release to civilian law enforcement soonest. • You may pursue hostile forces only to defend or retrieve military personnel.

  25. Analysis of Banuelos’ Actions Actual ROE for Mission: • You MAY use only the amount of force necessary and proportional to the threat. • You MAY use deadly force to defend yourself and others from death or serious bodily injury. • You MAY detain any person who poses an imminent threat of death or serious bodily harm; release to civilian law enforcement soonest. • You MAY NOT use deadly force if other measures would be reasonably effective. • You WILL make every effort to avoid confrontation and armed conflict with civilians.

  26. Outcomes After the Incident • Texas State Criminal Investigation • Defense Department Investigations • Federal Criminal Investigation • Civil Action • Congress Investigation

  27. Operation JUMP START:Lessons Learned? • 2006 - 2008 deployment of 6000 National Guardsmen to Border with Mexico • Mission: support Border Patrol in controlling illegal immigration & drug smuggling • Functions: entry identification teams; build roads & fences; provide medical, communication, administration, intelligence, and repair support, assist at checkpoints

  28. Operation JUMP START:Rules for the Use of Force • Force may be used in self-defense and defense of others. • Consider employing an escalating level of force. • Use only the minimum level of force necessary. Force must be proportionate to the threat. • Non-Deadly force levels: show of force; verbal persuasion; defensive techniques

  29. Operation JUMP START:Rules for the Use of Force • Deadly Force may be used only when all 3 conditions are met: • You reasonably believe person poses an imminent danger of death or serious bodily injury to you or another; • All other means are exhausted, not readily available, or situation does not permit their use. • Use of deadly force does not unreasonably increase the risk of death or serious bodily injury to innocent persons. • Arming Order Level determined by commanding general or designee

  30. 2007 Armed Border Confrontation • 4 armed soldiers observe 6 – 8 armed intruders wearing bullet proof vests • soldiers follow standard operating procedure: withdraw and report • No shots fired, rifles kept “ready low”

  31. Conclusion • Traditional military units fundamentally different from civilian law enforcement agencies • Careful planning & training needed for law enforcement missions • Interagency cooperation critical to success • Carefully drafted rules for use of force vital for success

More Related