1 / 22

Developing Governance & Leadership Performance in the Public Sector

Developing Governance & Leadership Performance in the Public Sector. John Halligan Professor of Public Administration Deputy Head, Division of Business, Law & Information Sciences University of Canberra John.Halligan@canberra.edu.au. Public Sector Governance.

azriel
Download Presentation

Developing Governance & Leadership Performance in the Public Sector

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Developing Governance & Leadership Performance in the Public Sector John Halligan Professor of Public Administration Deputy Head, Division of Business, Law & Information Sciences University of Canberra John.Halligan@canberra.edu.au

  2. Public Sector Governance • Corporate governance to public sector governance • Public sector versus private sector • Governance: corporate & organisational • Developing governance • Advocacy of CG & PSG • Promotion of elements of governance • Demarcating the field • DoFA’s categorisation of 955 govt bodies • Basic models: corporation, dept of state and hybrids

  3. Values of Good Public Sector Governance • Accountability • Transparency • Integrity • Stewardship • Leadership • ANAO 2003

  4. CG Principles & Elements • Focus on foundations for management & oversight • Eg formalise management/board functions/roles • Structure board to add value • Eg Chair & majority of independent directors • Promoting ethical & responsible decision-making • Eg establish code of conduct • Safeguarding integrity in financial reporting • Eg establish audit committee, • Managing risk • Enhancing performance culture • Recognising stakeholder interests • Sources: ASX Corporate Governance Statement 2003; ANAO 2003

  5. Contingent on Type of Organisation • Legislative basis & type of board • Corporate governance roles • Chair, Board, Minister & relationships • Executive boards • Advisory (dependent on CEO) • Mixes of policy, governance etc

  6. Corporate Boards v PS Executive Boards • Secretary/CEO/MD has ultimate/shared responsibility? • Board members have consultative/decision-making roles? • Board members have statutory/directors’ duties for which they are personally liable? • Board members are wholly internal/external? • Board members are subject to formal/informal ministerial direction/influence in terms of appointment, decision-making, & dismissal? • Board members have other/ministerial roles? • Board members have little/much control over their Secretary/CEO/MD? • Board members are/aren’t answerable directly to Secretary/CEO/MD? • Horrigan 2004

  7. Key Governance Issues: Boards • Different board concepts in FMA agencies & CAC bodies • Board appointments • Conflicts of roles & representational interests for board members • Governance expertise of board appointees • Interaction between government policy & board autonomy • Need for protocols in Minister-Board-Agency comunication • Sources: NIG 2003, CGP 2004

  8. Key Governance Issues • Whole-of-government issues • Handling of portfolio agencies under emerging regime • Risk management • Cross-portfolio & cross-governmental policy coordination • Sources: NIG 2003, CGP 2004

  9. Two Phases of Howard Govt • 1: Private sectorising dominant • Privatisation, competitive tendering, outsourcing etc • APS arms length & dictates of market or private sector practice • Public-private differences minimised – rise of corporate governance • 2: Strengthen PS capacity & direction • Role of central agencies, oversight & integration • Public-private differences emphasised • Reassertion of public sector governance

  10. Post-Uhrig Environment • Implications • Principles for public sector agencies • Focus on binary approach to structure • Corporate board & Executive management • Departmentalisation • Strengths of Uhrig • Recognises limitation of purchaser/provider • Need to streamline range of different organisational types • Appropriate use of board concept

  11. Post-Uhrig Issues • Limitations of Uhrig • First principles approach • Emphasis on private sector expertise • Narrow approach to governance • Simplistic dichotomy • Governance questions for bodies eg ABA, ABC, ATSIC etc • Sources: Wettenhall2004

  12. Leadership Performance • Different approaches to leadership • Focusing on performance? • Several leaderships • Corporate governance • Organisational

  13. Leaders & Performance • Initial observations • Recent review of CG • No rigid adherence to prescriptions • Adapt to agency and its environment • Leadership styles • 1: Compliance • Legality, directives & probity • 2: Instrumentalist • Delivering government objectives • 3: Human relationships • Softer concepts

  14. Governance & Performance • Assumptions about relationship between private sector board attributes & organisational performance • Objective (Hard) measures • Separation of roles of chair/CEO? • Independent/non-executive directors? • Board size

  15. Governance & Performance2 • ‘Soft’ (qualitative) factors • Roles, responsibilities and relationships? • Board, committee, leadership dynamics • Board cultures, trust and oversight stance • Information & communication flows (Edwards 2004)

  16. Building Effective Boards – NDPB • Enhancing effectiveness of independent boards of executive non-departmental bodies • Model • 3 crucial elements of high performing boards • Structure & functions • Actions & behaviours • Performance evaluation • Framework • 8 essential components of high performing boards • Each has key elements of good practice & indicators of strong performance • Barker 2004 (HM Treasury)

  17. Elements of High Performing Boards • Structure & functions • Executive function & purpose • Board function & position • Fit for purpose – skills, knowledge etc • Actions & behaviours • Effective board leadership & decision making • Board’s relationships • Performance evaluation • Board & member performance • Source: Barker 2004 (HM Treasury)

  18. Corporate Governance ARC Project Overview • Univ. Canberra’s Australian Research Council Linkage Grant: • Corporate Governance in the public sector - the tensions, gaps & potential • Examines structures & processes of public administration of: • Agencies under Commonwealth Authorities & Companies (CAC) Act 1997 • Departments/agencies under Financial Management & Accountability (FMA) Act 1997 • Principal Investigators at University of Canberra: • Professors Meredith Edwards, John Halligan, Bryan Horrigan; Mr Geoff Nicoll • Project Output • Issue papers • Conference & Workshop • Academic books & Handbook

  19. Corporate Governance ARC Project Our Industry Partners ________________________ Sponsorship monies have also been provided to the Project from the Australian Public Service Commission

  20. Specific Questions • Public-Private Comparisons of governance • Similarities & differences of public & private organisations • How far can you go in adopting private sector governance within the APS? • Public Sector Governance • Different types of governance arrangements within public sector • Is there a separate public sector model? • Selected Issues • What determines the success of Boards in the APS? • How are the interests of stakeholders represented in the different forms of public sector governance? • How are corporate governance elements like accountability, conformance & performance manifested? • Are there principles of design & practice in public sector corporate governance that can guide future decisions in this area?

  21. Conclusion: Issues & Directions • Implementing Uhrig? • New governance environment & balance? • Challenges of horizontal governance & participatory governance? • Connecting governance to performance?

  22. Corporate Gov Developments in Public Sector: Major Documents • Conflicts and Tensions in Commonwealth Public Sector Boards (NIG, 2003) • Current Issues in Public Sector Governance (NCCLPR & NIG, 2003) • Public Sector Governance Volumes 1 & 2: Better Practice Guides (ANAO, 2003) • Review of Corporate Governance of Statutory Authorities and Office Holders (Uhrig Report), 2003 (released 2004) • Public Sector Governance – Australia (CCH, 2004) • List of Australian Government Bodies 2002-2003 (DoFA 2004) • Building Effective Boards: Enhancing the Effectiveness of Independent Boards in Executive Non-Departmental Public Bodies (UK Treasury, 2004) • ARC-funded public sector corporate governance research project (http://www.blis.canberra.edu.au/corpgov%2Daps/whatsnew/default.htm)

More Related