40 likes | 54 Views
Test ERCOT transmission system one year in advance to determine if meeting planning criteria, identify possible system operation concerns, develop updated operations contingency lists, and develop/review Remedial Action Plans and/or Special Protection Systems. NERC compliance testing.
E N D
ERCOT 2004 RELIABILITY ASSESSMENT (CONTINGENCY EVALUATION) • Purpose • Test ERCOT transmission system one year in advance • Determine if meeting planning criteria • NERC compliance testing • Identify possible system operations concerns in advance • Develop updated operations contingency lists • Develop/review Remedial Actions Plans and/or Special Protection Systems • 2004 SSWG Data Set A Eight Seasonal Base Cases • On Peak and Off Peak for each season • Snapshot generation dispatch as outlined in SSWG Procedures • Fast Decoupled AC analysis using PTI MUST software • All planning contingencies on the current “B” list limited to 130 kV or above • One run done with “locked” transformer taps and “locked” switched shunts • Another run with “moving” transformer taps and “automatic” switched shunts • Both runs combined to show possible differences • Monitored all branches (lines) above 60 kV for Steady State thermal limits • Reported any violations above 100% of Rate B • Monitored all buses (nodes) above 60 kV for Steady State voltage limits • Reported any voltages outside of 0.9 PU to 1.05 PU • Used exclude file • Used Centerpoint DTAP file (multisection line modeling) • Merged known information from last year’s assessment in to this year • Valid contingency and corrective action
ERCOT 2004 RELIABILITY ASSESSMENT (CONTINGENCY EVALUATION) • 2004 Summer On Peak Conditions • 1168 above rating and voltage violations (some may not be valid) • Top twenty five contingencies with the highest number of violations • 40 - BGRPR138-GIBCRK C & BRY E C-GIBCRK C • 3423 KILL SS 138 3627 KILLFH T 138 1 • 3597 GROESPOD 138 3634 GROES SE 138 1 • 7258 GLIDDE13 138 8109 CPL-GLN4 138 1 • 8510 FALF 4 138 8695 CRSTNIO4 138 1 • 8392 BATES 4 138 8399 GARZA 4 138 1 • 429 - SMIGL 8-DILYSW 4 & DILYSW 4-COTULLA • 3413 TEMPSSLT 345 3422 KILL SS 345 1 • 3632 MEX2 SE 138 3634 GROES SE 138 1 • 3422 KILL SS 345 3423 KILL SS 138 1 • 1816 COMM SS 138 1820 COMM 138 1 • 3118 LUFKN SS 138 3333 TX FND T 138 1 • 108 - MOSES-T-ALLEN2SS & ROYSE S-ALLEN1SS • 8212 DILYSW 4 138 5704 SMIGL 8 138 1 • 656 - MCNEILW-DECK MB2 & DAFFIN G-DESSAU & • 657 - MCNEILW-DECK MB2 & DAFFIN G-DESSAU & • 8297 BRUNI 4 138 8695 CRSTNIO4 138 1 • 6655 BARRILA4 138 6680 ALAMITO4 138 1 • 1698 SULSP SS 138 1814 SULSPG 138 1 • 8392 BATES 4 138 8980 FRONT 138 1 • 292 - ROYSE A-RKWL E & ROYSE B-BLACKLND • 2472 ROYSE B 138 2713 BLACKLND 138 1 • 280 - PARKD B3-E NET 2 & PARKD B2-E NET • 8503 ALICE 4 138 8518 KINGSVL4 138 1 • 5704 SMIGL 8 138 5902 MIGUEL 8 138 1
ERCOT 2004 RELIABILITY ASSESSMENT (CONTINGENCY EVALUATION) • 2004 Summer On Peak Conditions (Continued) • Top contingencies with worst above rating (overload) • 127 - EV WEST-VENUS S & EV EAST-VENUS N • 604 - VENUS S-C HILL & VENUS N-WEBB 1 & LI • 1882 EV WEST 345 1906 VENUS S 345 1 • 136 - VENUS S-C HILL & VENUS N-WEBB 1 • 605 - VENUS S-C HILL & VENUS N-WEBB 1 & SH • 1906 VENUS S 345 2420 C HILL 345 1 • 608 - VENUS S-C HILL & SHERRY T-CENTURY1 & • 658 - EV WEST-EVER 1BT & EVER 1BT-EV EAST • 671 - FARM SW-VALLEY & FARM SW-MOSES & FAR • 600 - EV WEST-EVER 1BT & EVER 1BT-EV EAST • Top contingencies with highest overload severity index • 127 - EV WEST-VENUS S & EV EAST-VENUS N • 604 - VENUS S-C HILL & VENUS N-WEBB 1 & LI • 05 - VENUS S-C HILL & VENUS N-WEBB 1 & SH • 136 - VENUS S-C HILL & VENUS N-WEBB 1 • 1882 EV WEST 345 1906 VENUS S 345 1 • 1906 VENUS S 345 2420 C HILL 345 1 • 658 - EV WEST-EVER 1BT & EVER 1BT-EV EAST • 608 - VENUS S-C HILL & SHERRY T-CENTURY1 & • 3423 KILL SS 138 3627 KILLFH T 138 1 • Top contingencies with highest voltage severity index • 8392 BATES 4 138 8399 GARZA 4 138 1 • 3597 GROESPOD 138 3634 GROES SE 138 1 • 40 - BGRPR138-GIBCRK C & BRY E C-GIBCRK C • 3423 KILL SS 138 3627 KILLFH T 138 1 • 3632 MEX2 SE 138 3634 GROES SE 138 1 • 1816 COMM SS 138 1820 COMM 138 1 • 280 - PARKD B3-E NET 2 & PARKD B2-E NET • 3238 ATHENS 138 3247 ATHENS T 138 1 • 3410 LAKE CRK 138 3597 GROESPOD 138 1 • 7258 GLIDDE13 138 8109 CPL-GLN4 138 1
ERCOT 2004 RELIABILITY ASSESSMENT (CONTINGENCY EVALUATION) • Proposed ROS Action Items • SSWG review to determine if valid contingency by indicating in workbook (complete by Nov 15) • For valid contingencies TDSP’s provide corrective action and indicate transmission additions that would resolve problems by indicating in workbook (complete by Dec 15) • Examine FERC 715 not a valid response • TDSP’s develop any needed special protection systems (complete by Feb 15) • OWG review and develop remedial action plans (complete by Feb 15) • All tasks should be completed by May 1 to maintain reliability during peak load seasons