1 / 13

Pros and Pitfalls of Assessing Writing

Pros and Pitfalls of Assessing Writing. Kathryn Byrne Writing Center Director Associate Professor x3497. Writing originates and creates unique constructs that are graphically recorded ( Emig 1977, 123).

belita
Download Presentation

Pros and Pitfalls of Assessing Writing

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Pros and Pitfalls of Assessing Writing Kathryn Byrne Writing Center Director Associate Professor x3497

  2. Writing originates and creates unique constructs that are graphically recorded (Emig 1977, 123). • Writing establishes explicit and systematic conceptual groupings through lexical, syntactic, and rhetorical devices (Emig, 1977,128). • Writing is one of JCCCs learning outcomes • Writing is the currency of all business and creative endeavors Why use writing?

  3. Time • Agreement • Confusion • Possible Loss of Camaraderie Pitfalls

  4. When our purpose in reading student text is to defend our position, “we do not apply any of our natural response to a text. Instead, we search for ways in which it does not measure up” (Maja Wilson 2006). Assessment (especially assessing writing) can put us at odds with our convictions about teaching and at odds with our fellows. Pitfalls

  5. Assessment works best when we use it as a tool to help us find out how well students are doing—how much deeper into the assimilation process they have come this semester/year. For the Good

  6. Opens our minds • Broadens our relationships • Keeps us on our toes • Next steps-- For the Good

  7. ONE: Have a discussion with all or a majority about elements of student writing your department members value- • KISS • Expect heat • Expect time consumption • Negotiate to consensus For the Good

  8. Two: Match Writing Values to Department Values • Ensures validity when course expectations meet criteria stated in syllabi and department outcomes • Ensures fairness. Assessments must be free of bias. For the Good

  9. Three: Do Something with the Data • Analyze it • Numbers need interpretation • You will not know what you have until you start to group, regroup, write, the rewrite • Share with your peers • Numbers • Artifacts • Assumptions • Questions

  10. Break up the monotony- • Embed kinds of writing assessments into your curricula • Discuss numbers (at what point does the research have statistical value?) • Visit Shari Barrett (a lot) For the good

  11. Still worried that WRITING correctness should play a larger role in the assessment? • Have a list of contact names from English who would consult with your faculty (help) • Ask them to be a rater in your assessment • Ask them to give you a grammar/mechanics workshop so everyone is on the same page • Just ask them quick questions For the Good

  12. “Writing should be understood as the critical link between doing and knowing in the disciplines” (Carter, Ferzli, Wiebe, 2007). “An assessment method must convince us that it reflects our values about teaching before it seduces us with its claim to save time” (Wilson 2006). Writing is the currency in all business and creative endeavors and should be at the heart of every discipline.

  13. Maja Wilson. Rethinking Rubrics in Writing Assessment. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann Educational Books, 2006. Print. Michael Carter, Miriam Ferzli and Eric N. Wiebe. Writing to Learn by Learning to Write in the DisciplinesJournal of Business and Technical Communication 2007 21: 278 DOI: 10.1177/1050651907300466 References

More Related