1 / 6

Questions of scale

Questions of scale. Finding your way to a compelling question. topics. What is your interest area broadly described? Is there a physical or virtual “site” in which your interest lies? Is there a population or characteristic group about which your interest lies?

bill
Download Presentation

Questions of scale

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Questions of scale Finding your way to a compelling question

  2. topics • What is your interest area broadly described? • Is there a physical or virtual “site” in which your interest lies? • Is there a population or characteristic group about which your interest lies? • Complete the following sentence: • The topic of my paper/study/research is ____________. • Now frame that topic as a question…this requires thinking of the topic from a particular perspective or context.

  3. Frames • Conceptual frames can come from disciplinary fields: • Psychology • Sociology • Economics • History • Political Science • Conceptual frames can come from comparative analysis: • Compare and contrast • Thematic similarities or differences • Conceptual frames can come from problems of practice (often still disciplinary) • How can we make this better?

  4. Levels of analysis • Using a single conceptual frame, try scaling up and scaling down your topic to explore different levels of analysis: • Mega: what is your topic at an almost global level? • Meta: what is your topic at a disciplinary level? • Mezzo: what is your topic at a theoretical level? • Micro: what is your topic at a practical level? • Minutiae: what is your topic at an exemplary level?

  5. Questions • For example, if my topic is socialization in student organizations, here’s a draft (not perfect) of five levels of questioning: • Mega (humanity): how do people form groups? • Meta (disciplinary): what is the nature of socialization? • Mezzo (theoretical): how do norms work to control human behavior? • Micro (practical): how does hazing serve to socialize new fraternity members into group membership. • Minutiae (exemplary): how does drinking upside-down martinis help fraternity pledges bond with one another?

  6. Finding the right level • Depending on your assignment or task there is an appropriate level of analysis and questioning to explore. • Most students suffer from working with topics that are either too broad or too detailed. • Many students suffer from working with topics that have not been framed conceptually thus they have difficulty constructing a question or thesis. • To write a good paper or design a good study you must appropriately name your topic and conceptually frame that topic as a compelling question.

More Related