1 / 18

Corporate earnings: Facts and fiction

Corporate earnings: Facts and fiction. By Team 3. Introduction. Importance of earnings Input of investors’ valuation model Managers ' compensation and wealth E nterprise performance measurement. Overview. An Anatomy of Earnings Manipulation True Earnings and GAAP Earnings

brody
Download Presentation

Corporate earnings: Facts and fiction

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Corporate earnings: Facts and fiction By Team 3

  2. Introduction • Importance of earnings • Input of investors’ valuation model • Managers' compensation and wealth • Enterprise performance measurement.

  3. Overview • An Anatomy of Earnings Manipulation • True Earnings and GAAP Earnings • Classifying Manipulated Earnings • Why Manipulate Earnings? • How Much Earnings Manipulation Occurs? • The Social Costs of Earnings Manipulations • A Proposed Procedure to Curb EM

  4. An Anatomy of EarningsManipulation • Ex. Case of Enron • Left bar • Analyst forecast • Middle bar • Original report • Right bar • Subsequent restated

  5. True Earnings and GAAP Earnings • What are true earnings? • Correspond to reality, or facts. • Confirmed by bank and custodians’ statements. • What are GAAP earnings? • High-quality earnings following the GAAP framework. • A measure of a company's overall earnings performance.

  6. Classifying Manipulated Earnings • Accounting Manipulation • No effect on cash flows. • Real Manipulation • Involve a change in the firm's level of investment with an intention to affect reported earnings. • GAAP-Consistent Manipulation • Attempt to affect investors' perceptions. • GAAP-Violating Manipulation • Include clear deviations from accepted rules

  7. Why Manipulate Earnings? • Personal gain • Very high executive compensation. • Maximization of multiyear bonuses. • Continuation of investor/supplier support • Operation with adequate funding. • Satisfying contractual arrangements

  8. How Much Earnings Manipulation Actually Occurs? • Direct earnings manipulation • Fraud litigation • Corporate earnings restatements • SEC enforcement actions

  9. Securities Fraud Litigation

  10. Earnings Restatements • A study of 1,068 cases of reinstatement during 1977-2000 • 232 firms faced securities class action lawsuits. • 193 firms had their management replaces. • 108 companies replaced their auditors.

  11. SEC Enforcement Releases • The Account and Auditing Enforcement Releases indicates that approximately two thirds of the recorded manipulations lasted for one to two years.

  12. How Much Earnings Manipulation Actually Occurs? • Indirect earnings manipulation • Discontinuities in earnings distributions. • Deviations from expected accruals. • Earnings patterns around suspicious circumstances.

  13. Discontinuities in earnings distributions • Examine Past earnings and Analysts’ forecasts • Distributions should be fairly smooth with a hump in the center.

  14. Deviation from Expected Accruals • Many accruals require estimates • An inflation tend to boost expected accruals

  15. Suspicious Circumstances • Managers are especially tempted to inflate earnings reported when: • A manager's performance is challenged. • Prior to a stock offering.

  16. The Social Costs of Earnings Manipulations • Increase in firms’ cost of capital. • The losses caused to pension funds, university endowments, and insurance companies. • Cost of unwise investments. • Cost of auditing. • Cost of legal systems and public institutions.

  17. A Proposed Procedure to Curb Earnings Manipulation • Accounting rules have to reflect economic reality. • Shift accounting standard. • Mandatory revision of companies’ annual earnings.

  18. Conclusion • Earnings manipulation is prevalent, but it is hard to detect for very bad cases. • Change the incentives for earnings manipulations. • Make corporate financial reports more truthful and revealing.

More Related