1 / 16

Potomac River basin-wide stream habitat condition index & benthic macroinvertebrate index

Potomac River basin-wide stream habitat condition index & benthic macroinvertebrate index. Presented to the CBP Non-Tidal Water Quality Workgroup 2/13/2008 Claire Buchanan Interstate Commission on the Potomac River Basin. ICPRB. “Interstate Compact Commission”

cathy
Download Presentation

Potomac River basin-wide stream habitat condition index & benthic macroinvertebrate index

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Potomac River basin-wide stream habitat condition index & benthic macroinvertebrate index Presented to the CBP Non-Tidal Water Quality Workgroup 2/13/2008 Claire Buchanan Interstate Commission on the Potomac River Basin

  2. ICPRB “Interstate Compact Commission” Mission - help Potomac basin states and federal government to enhance, protect, and conserve the water and associated land resources A Goal - promote watershed-based management protective of ecosystems and water resources • basin-wide indicators www.potomacriver.org

  3. Basin-Wide Indicators Potomac Estuary & Chesapeake Bay Led inter-agency development of IBIs for • Phytoplankton (PIBI) • Zooplankton (ZIBI) – in high salinity waters Supporting CBP development & uses of • Food Availability Index (FAI) - anadromous fish • Benthos (BIBI) – soft-bottom macroinvertebrates • Habitat Suitability Indexes – fish Developing • Phytoplankton Habitat Index - water quality parameters • Indicators of Tidal Embayment Status Potomac Non-Tidal Wadeable Streams/Rivers DevelopedLeAnne Astin (2006, 2007) • Stream Habitat Condition Index • Basin-wide Index of Biotic Integrity (for benthic macroinvertebrates) www.potomacriver.org

  4. What the individual programs say about benthic macroinvertebrates:

  5. Advantages of Basin-Wide Indicators • Larger data sets • Metrics are more rigorously tested • Broader geographic distribution • Less unintentional bias in results • More reference sites • Thresholds for “good” and “bad” are more accurate • Consistent scoring across state boundaries • Inequalities due to different scoring protocols minimized

  6. Calibration Data Sets • MD Biological Stream Survey (MBSS) 1995 - 1997 (n = 290) probabilistic sampling • PA Unassessed Waters/State-Wide Surface Waters Assessment (UW/SSWAP) 1997 – 2001 (n = 269) probabilistic sampling • VA Ambient Water Quality Monitoring Program (AWQM) 1994 - 2000 (n = 428) targeted sampling • WV Watershed Assessment Program (WAP) 1996 – spring 2001 (n = 336) census sampling Total n = 1,323

  7. Analysis Approach • Resolve method and data comparability issues • Merge habitat, water quality, and macroinvertebrate data provided by multiple monitoring programs (Access database) • targeted, random-stratified, and census study designs can be combined if data arerepresentative of the range of conditions • Establish uniform benchmarks to evaluate key habitat parameters common to all programs • Anthropogenic Alteration - Instream Condition • Bank Stability - Riparian Zone • Channel Alteration - Substrate Quality • Habitat Heterogeneity • pH - Conductivity

  8. Analysis Approach (cont.) • Identify reference and degraded habitats in each physiographic region • modified Relative Status Method • Use reference and degraded sites to develop Habitat Condition Index ratings • Select robust, discriminatory biological indicators (62 tested, 7 selected) • # EPT taxa - % Dominant taxon • Hilsenhoff Family Biotic Index - % EPT • % Clingers - Taxa Richness • % Collectors

  9. Analysis Approach (cont.) • Develop standardized metrics and expectations from reference site data • 1-3-5 scoring • Sum of scored metrics  multi-metric BIBI • Test sensitivity of biological metrics and index • Discrimination efficiencies; classification efficiencies • Develop BIBI ratings from reference data distributions • Good is >50th %ile, Fair is 5th – 50th %ile, Poor is <5th %ile • Validate BIBI by physiographic region • additional data, jackknife procedure

  10. What the individual programs say about benthic macroinvertebrates:

  11. What they all say when stitched together with the Basin-wide IBI: Status is measured against a common pool of “reference sites” in each physiographic region No mention of WQ Standards “impairments”

  12. Some Findings • Anthropogenic Alteration is a strong habitat metric but is being phased out by many programs • “grazing”, “disruptive pressure”, “aesthetics”, “remoteness” • Relative abundance (P/A) data can apparently be used with count data at least when data are collected with variants of the RBP protocol • Metric discrimination efficiency can vary depending on physiographic region • e.g., EPT metric is a strong in Piedmont &Valley regions but weak in Highlands region

  13. Some Findings • Good separation of reference and degraded site BIBIs (good classification efficiency) • Positive relationship between BIBI and habitat condition index • General agreement between the BIBI and the individual state assessments … but some notable discrepancies

  14. Some Findings Note: Only validation data sets were used in these comparisons

  15. To-Do List • Collaborate with Non-Tidal Water Quality Workgroup (NTWQW) staff Katie Foreman (acquire 2004-2006 water quality, habitat, and benthic macroinvertebrate data sets) • February – May 2008 • Re-validate ICPRB Habitat Condition Index and Basin-wide Biotic Index of Integrity for Potomac R. • June – September 2008 • Request NTWQW review of 2004 – 2006 results (maps, report with comparisons to state assessments) • Fall 2008 • ICPRB 2008 annual report • Spring 2009

  16. References • Astin, L.E. 2006. Data synthesis and bioindicator development for nontidal streams in the interstate Potomac River basin, USA. Ecological Indicators 6: 664-685. • Astin, L. E. 2007. Developing biological indicators from diverse data: The Potomac Basin-wide Index of Benthic Integrity (B-IBI). Ecological Indicators 7: 895-908.

More Related