300 likes | 460 Views
Advertising March 9, 2011. Defining political advertising. 1) ability to control the message 2) use of mass communication channels for message distribution. The Place of Campaign Advertising. Mass media. Mass public. Politicians.
E N D
Defining political advertising 1) ability to control the message 2) use of mass communication channels for message distribution
The Place of Campaign Advertising Mass media Mass public Politicians
In some ways, the US and the UK are at opposite ends of the “campaign environment”
Types of Ads • Negative, positive, contrast • Issue vs. image • Humour
Forms of Advertising • Television • Radio • Print • Direct mail • Billboards • Push polling • Games • Infomercials • Web
Web • Obama Girl
Trends in UK Advertising (PEBs) Early ads (1959) Modern ads from 2005 (Labour and Conservative)
Trends in UK Advertising • Slicker • Shorter • More negative • More focus on leaders
Landmarks in US Advertising • Early elections • Eisenhower in 1952 and 1956 • The Johnson campaign of 1964 • Morning in America and the Bear in 1984 • Willie Horton and 1988 • Soft money and advertising in the 1990s • Rats ad (2000) • ‘Stand by your ad’ since 2004 • Ads from 2008, Obama infomerical , Palin
Trends in US Advertising • Slicker • Shorter • More negative
Intended Effects of Ads • Learning • Candidates’ identities • Policy positions • Personal and political history • Impressions • Favorability • Traits • Electability • Agenda setting and priming
What are the Intended Effects of Political Advertising? • Persuasion • Reinforcement
Intended Effects in UK Elections • Backlash effect of negative advertising, especially on non-partisans • Stronger impact on Lib Dem support • Some effects on party leader images • Little impact on party images • Limited effects on policy perceptions
Intended Effects in US Elections • Learning • Candidates’ identities • Policy positions • Personal and political history
Ad Tone in US Presidential Elections (1960-2000) More negative More positive Source: John Geer (2003)
Unintended Effects of Negative Ads • Turnout and negative advertising WHY MIGHT NEGATIVE ADVERTISING LOWER TURNOUT? Perception that politicians are unresponsive Cynicism Negative ads Less positive public mood
Unintended Effects of Negative Ads • Turnout and negative advertising WHY MIGHT NEGATIVE ADVERTISING LOWER TURNOUT? Perception that politicians are unresponsive Cynicism Negative ads Lower turnout Less positive public mood
Unintended Effects of Negative Ads • Turnout and negative advertising WHY MIGHT NEGATIVE ADVERTISING RAISE TURNOUT? Information Anxiety Negative ads Stakes
Unintended Effects of Negative Ads • Turnout and negative advertising WHY MIGHT NEGATIVE ADVERTISING RAISE TURNOUT? Information Anxiety Negative ads Higher turnout Stakes
Unintended Effects of Ads • Perceptions of politics • Political behaviour
Decline (and rebound?) in Several Indicators of Political Engagement