1 / 9

Theories of the Earth

Theories of the Earth. Thomas Burnet’s ‘Sacred Theory’. Title Page and Frontispiece. Stages of the Earth’s Development. Chaos. A turbulent mixture of water, earth, etc. Paradise. A smooth sphere of fertile soil, with the waters (waiting) beneath.

dalmar
Download Presentation

Theories of the Earth

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Theories of the Earth Thomas Burnet’s ‘Sacred Theory’

  2. Title Page and Frontispiece

  3. Stages of the Earth’s Development • Chaos. A turbulent mixture of water, earth, etc. • Paradise. A smooth sphere of fertile soil, with the waters (waiting) beneath. • The Flood. Brought about by natural (‘secondary’) causes, even though it served a Divine purpose. The soil dried out, cracked and foundered in the depths. • The Present (a wreck…). The natural world seen as in decay, mountains seen as horrible & threatening rather than beautiful. Explanations of various geological phenomena are offered here.

  4. The Changes to Come • Destruction by Fire. Armageddon & coal fires. A link between volcanoes & the Catholic Church. • Paradise Restored. • The Earth becomes a star.

  5. The Relationship between Religion and Science At this point (late 17th Century) the idea that science and religion could wind up in opposition to each other is strongly resisted: No “truth concerning the natural world cannot be an Enemy to Religion; for Truth cannot be an Enemy to Truth, God is not divided against Himself”

  6. Two Books • One important tradition in Christian theology emphasizes the notion that we have received two principle sources of knowledge, in effect two books: • The bible, of course, is one. • The world is the other. • Burnet clearly belongs to this tradition.

  7. Push-back • Other views of the present earth: Providential accounts of the present state of the earth are coupled with more generous aesthetic opinions. • In particular, a more positive take on mountains begins to emerge (for example, in the work of John Ray– an important English naturalist.)

  8. A Wider Concern • For some, the act of mixing scientific ideas and explanations with the stories of Genesis was itself sacrilegious. • But similar views and alternative positions continued to emerge despite the condemnations (and ridicule) Burnet encountered. • Still, the attempt to bring scripture and scientific/causal stories together clearly caused serious difficulties for Burnet.

  9. Where to from here? • Others would take a different tack, treating the scientific story in its own terms, without any direct attempt to link it to the bible. • But efforts to link the two remained significant in geology up until the diluvialists of the early nineteenth century. • The main leader of the Diluvialists (Buckland) finally recanted around 1830, declaring the attempt to link geological evidence to the flood “A scientific heresy”. But we have a few more stories to tell before we get there.

More Related