1 / 20

Anticonvulsants 治療 diabetic neuropathic pain 的效果

Anticonvulsants 治療 diabetic neuropathic pain 的效果. 小港醫院 R2 董錦松. 臨床問題. Anticonvulsants 對 diabetic neuropathic pain 的治療效果如何？ 若 anticonvulsants 治療 diabetic neuropathic pain 有效，那一種 anticonvulsant 為最佳選擇？. 背景說明.

eloise
Download Presentation

Anticonvulsants 治療 diabetic neuropathic pain 的效果

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Anticonvulsants治療diabetic neuropathic pain的效果 小港醫院 R2董錦松

  2. 臨床問題 • Anticonvulsants對diabetic neuropathic pain的治療效果如何？ • 若anticonvulsants治療diabetic neuropathic pain有效，那一種anticonvulsant為最佳選擇？

  3. 背景說明 • 1960年代起，即開始使用anticonvulsants來治療neuropathic pain，如diabetic neuropathy，trigeminal neuralgia，post-herpetic neuralgia等。 • Diabetic neuropathic pain是臨床上常見之病症，困擾許多DM病人，近年來多種新的anticonvulsants上市，是否也代表治療diabetic neuropathic pain的選擇更多，副作用更少，因此找尋文獻比較各種anticonvulsants對diabetic neuropathic pain的療效。

  4. Diabetic peripheral neuropathy • 15% DM p’t have S/S of neuropathy • DM>25 years affect nearly 50% p’t • Pathogenesis: unknown • Hyperglycemia • Microvascular diasease • Treatment: TCAs, NSAID, anticonvulsants, opioids, topical anesthetic agents, nerve block

  5. 期待目標 • anticonvulsants對diabetic neuropathic pain的治療效果，並找出何種anticonvulsants 是最佳的選擇。

  6. 搜尋步驟 • 搜尋字串： • Neuropathy • anticonvulsant, anticonvulsants, carbamazepine, oxcarbazepine, valproate, phenytoin, lamotrigine, vigabatrin, gabapentin, topiramate • Clinical trial (PubMed) • 搜尋範圍： • ACP Journal Club -- 1 • Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews -- 1 • Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, PubMed -- 15

  7. 結 果

  8. 結果摘要(I) Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews • Anticonvulsant drugs for acute and chronic pain (2000) • Diabetic Neuropathy: Four placebo-controlled studies • one with carbamazepine (Rull 1969), two with phenytoin (Chadda 1978, Saudek 1977), and one with gabapentin (Backonja 1998)). • Rull (Rull 1969) and Chadda (Chadda 1978) found that with two weeks' treatment between 30 and 50% more patients improved on anticonvulsant than on placebo. • Saudek 1977, using phenytoin (300 mg/day) for 23 weeks of treatment found no difference in mean pain intensity compared with placebo • Backonja (Backonja 1998) reported a 60% improvement on a global scale for patients on gabapentin (up to 3.6 grams per day) after four weeks' treatment in a study of 165 participants. • one active control study comparing carbamazepine 200 mg versus a nortriptyline 10 mg/fluphenazine 0.5 mg combination (Gomez -Perez 1996). Only mean data were reported and the authors could not show a difference between the two treatments although it is stated that all patients improved • Conclusion: gabapentin is effective in post-herpetic neuralgia and diabetic neuropathy but does not appear to be superior to carbamazepine, a cheaper alternative in many countries. There were, however, no direct comparisons between these two drugs

  9. 結果摘要(II) ACP journal (2002) • Review: Anticonvulsant drugs relieve chronic but not acute pain • 6 drugs: carbamazepine (12 trials), phenytoin (6 trials), sodium valproate (2 trials), gabapentin (2 trials), clonazepam (1 trial), and lamotrigine (1 trial) • Carbamazepine, phenytoin, and gabapentin were more effective than was placebo in relieving the pain of diabetic neuropathy • all caused such minor side effects as drowsiness, dizziness, constipation, nausea, and ataxia (numbers needed to harm [NNHs] ranged from 3 to 4). The NNHs for major harm were not statistically significant for any drug

  10. 結果摘要-Carbamazepine • 3 randomized clinical trial • 2 with placebo (Rull, 1969; Wilton, 1974) • More effective then placebo • 1 with nortriptyline and fluphenazine (Gomez-Perez, 1996) • Both drugs: improvements from baseline, but no significant difference between 2 drugs • Dose: 300-1000mg/d • Adverse events (up to 70%): Somnolence, dizziness, gait disturbance • Withdrawal rate: 0-7%

  11. 結果摘要-Phenytoin • 2 randomized clinical trial(Chadda, 1978; Saude, 1977) • Conflicting result

  12. 結果摘要-Sodium valproate • 2 randomized clinical trial(91 p’t)(Kochar, 2002; 2004) • Significant improvement then placebo • SF-MPQ: 53.41 (1 month) • VAS: 6 3, SF-MPQ: 19.479.66, PPI: 2.711.33 (3 months) • Side effect: nausea:2, sedation:1, liver change:2 • Dose: 1200mg, 1000mg/d

  13. 結果摘要-Gabapentin I • 4 randomized clinical trial • 3 with placebo, 1 with morphine, 1 with amitriptyline • Backonja, 1998 (165p’t) • 900 titrated to 3600mg/d • Significant pain relief than placebo, improvement of sleep, mood (pain score: 6.43.9; placebo:6.55.1) • Pain relief was observed during 2nd week when dose reached 1800mg/d • Dizziness 24%, somnolence 23%, headache 11%, diarrhea 11% • Gorsen, 1999 (40 p’t) • 900mg/d • Ineffective at dose of 900mg/d

  14. 結果摘要-Gabapentin II • Morello, 1999 (28 p’t) • Gabapentin 900-1800mg, or Amitriptyline 25-75 mg /d • No significant different in pain relief • No significant difference in occurrence of adverse effects (17 in amitriptyline, 18 in gabapentin) • Gilron, 2005 (57p’t) • Gabapentin (3200mg), Morphine(120mg), combine(G 2400mg, M 60mg), placebo • Gabapentin and Morphine combined achieved better analgesia at lower dose of each drug • Adverse effect: • Combination: contipation↑than gabapentin, dry mouth↑than morphin

  15. 結果摘要-Lamotrigine • 1 randomized clinical trial (53 p’t)(Eisenberg, 2001) • Lamotrigine attenuates painful diabetic neuropathy at a daily dose of 200-400mg then placebo (NPS: 6.44.2, MPQ, PDI, BDI: unchanged) • Maximal pain reduction:37%, 12 p’t 50% pain reduction • Adverse events: similar to placebo (exception 2 rash developed)

  16. 結果摘要-Topiramate • 2 randomized clinical trial • Topiramate diabetic neuropathic pain study group, 2004 (3 trial)(1259 p’t) • 100mg, 200mg, 300mg • 1 effective, 2 no significant (placebo effect high, 38% and 48%) • Overall: no significant more effective than placebo • 16 ~ 31% discontinuation due to adverse events • Raskin, 2004 (12weeks, 323 p’t, 400mg) • ½ - 30%, 1/3 - 50% pain reduction • Reduced pain and body weight more effective than placebo • Adverse event: nausea, somnolence, dizziness, paresthesia, cognition dysfunction, appetite decrease • 48% dropout rate

  17. 結果摘要-Oxcarbazepine • 1 open-label trial (30p’t)(Beydoun, 2004) • Significant improvement in total pain score, and present pain intensity (VAS score: 66.334.3, 48.3%) • Dose: up to 1200mg/d (mean 814mg) • Adverse events(>10%): drowsiness, dizziness, headache, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea

  18. 總結(I) • 目前證據顯示carbamazepine, sodium valproate, lamotrigine, gabapentin在治療diabetic neuropathic pain可以顯著改善臨床症狀，但並無試驗直接比較不同anticonvulssants間的差別。 • Topiramate, phenytoin在不同的臨床試驗出現不同的結果，對於diabetic neuropathic pain的效果尚無定論。 • Oxcarbazepine, vigabatrin並無RCT來支持治療diabetic neuropathic pain的效果。 • 新的anticonvulsants (gabapentin, topiramate, oxcarbazepine)，仍有許多常見adverse effects如dizziness, somnolence, sedation的作用。 • Sodium valproate及Lamitrigine的小型試驗中，有較少的副作用。

  19. 總結(II) • 對於治療diabetic neuropathic pain，anticonvulsants可以有效減緩疼痛症狀，但需注意治療所引起的不適及副作用。 • 目前無證據顯示何種anticonvusants為最佳選擇，若考量花費，傳統anticonvulsants仍是優先選擇，若病患不能忍受副作用或是有過敏反應，則可給予不同的anticonvulsants。

More Related