1 / 104

School-based Support for Students with ADHD: Is There Life After Ritalin?

School-based Support for Students with ADHD: Is There Life After Ritalin? . George J. DuPaul, Ph.D. School Psychology Program Lehigh University Bethlehem PA 18015. Conclusions. ADHD has enormous impact on school functioning

eman
Download Presentation

School-based Support for Students with ADHD: Is There Life After Ritalin?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. School-based Support for Students with ADHD:Is There Life After Ritalin? George J. DuPaul, Ph.D. School Psychology Program Lehigh University Bethlehem PA 18015

  2. Conclusions • ADHD has enormous impact on school functioning • Medication is effective for changing behavior, but not necessarily for academic performance • Individually tailored school-based interventions have potential for building upon medication effects • Must go beyond “one size fits all”

  3. DSM-IV CRITERIA FOR ADHD • Significant problems with inattention • Significant problems with hyperactivity-impulsivity • Symptoms present for at least 6 months • Symptoms that caused impairment before age 7 • Some impairment in two or more settings • Impairment in social, academic, or occupational functioning • Not due to another disorder • Subtypes: Combined, Predominantly Inattentive, Predominantly Hyperactive-Impulsive

  4. PREVALENCE AND SEX RATIOS • Occurs in 3 to 5 % of children • Ratio of males:females is 3:1 in community and 6:1 in clinic referrals • Makes up high percentage of referrals for academic and behavior difficulties • Found in all countries and ethnic groups with varying prevalence - highest in US

  5. PROBLEMS ASSOCIATED WITH ADHD • Conduct problems (e.g., oppositional behavior, lying, stealing, and fighting) • Academic underachievement • Specific learning disabilities • Peer relationship problems

  6. Model for School-based Assessment of ADHD (DuPaul & Stoner, 2003) • Screening • Multi-method Assessment • Interpretation of Results • Intervention Planning & Design • Intervention Evaluation

  7. SCREENING: QUESTIONS TO BE ADDRESSED • Does this student have a problem related to possible ADHD? • Is further assessment of ADHD required?

  8. SCREENING METHODS • Parent and/or teacher ratings of ADHD-related behaviors • Brief interview with teacher and/or parent

  9. MULTIMETHOD ASSESSMENT: QUESTIONS TO BE ADDRESSED • What is the extent and nature of the ADHD-related problems? • What factors (e.g., organismic and environmental) maintain these problems? • What is the frequency, duration, and/or intensity of the problem behaviors? • In what settings do the ADHD-related behaviors occur?

  10. MULTIMETHOD ASSESSMENT STRATEGIES • Parent and teacher interviews • Reviews of school records • Behavior rating scales • Observations of school behavior • Academic performance data • Functional behavioral assessment

  11. INTERPRETATION: QUESTIONS TO BE ADDRESSED • Does the child exhibit a significant number of behavioral symptoms of ADHD ? • Are behaviors occurring significantly more frequently than children of the same gender and age? • At what age did these begin and are these behaviors chronic and evident across many situations? • Is the child’s functioning significantly impaired? • Are there other possible problems or factors that could account for symptoms?

  12. INTERPRETATION OF RESULTS • Number of ADHD symptoms • Deviance from age and gender norms • Age of onset and chronicity • Pervasiveness across situations • Degree of functional impairment • Rule out alternative hypotheses

  13. Developmental Trends for ADHD Symptoms: Boys

  14. Developmental Trend for ADHD Symptoms: Girls

  15. Teacher-rated Inattention as a Function of Age & Ethnicity

  16. Teacher-rated HypImp as a Function of Age & Ethnicity

  17. ALTERNATIVE HYPOTHESES FOR ADHD BEHAVIOR • Environmental factors • Antecedent/consequent events • Placement in curriculum • Psychosocial stressors • Within-child factors • Academic skills deficits • Other forms of emotional or behavioral disturbance

  18. DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS • Disorders to be “ruled out”: • Separation Anxiety Disorder • Other Anxiety Disorders • Depression/affective disorders • Tourette’s Disorder • Disorders which frequently co-occur with ADHD: • Oppositional Defiant Disorder • Conduct Disorder • Learning Disabilities

  19. LD VS. ADHD • Lacks early childhood history of hyperactivity • “ADHD” behaviors arise in middle childhood • “ADHD” behaviors appear to be task- or subject-specific • Not socially aggressive or disruptive • Not impulsive or disinhibited

  20. INTERVENTION PLANNING: QUESTIONS TO BE ADDRESSED • What are the behavioral objectives? • What are the student’s strengths and weaknesses? • What are the optimum intervention strategies? • What additional resources are available to address the child’s ADHD-related problems?

  21. INTERVENTION PLANNING • Severity of ADHD-related behaviors • Functional assessment of behavior • Presence of associated disorders • Response to prior interventions • Availability of community resources

  22. Possible Functions of ADHD Behavior • Avoid/escape effortful tasks • Obtain peer attention • Obtain teacher attention • Obtain tangible object • Sensory stimulation

  23. Design Interventions Based on Functional Assessment • Descriptive analysis • Identify antecedents, consequences, sequential conditions • Direct observation, teacher interview, parent interview, student interview • Experimental Analysis • Develop hypotheses related to function of behavior • Test hypotheses using direct observation • Develop intervention plan based on results of experimental analyses

  24. INTERVENTION EVALUATION: QUESTIONS TO BE ADDRESSED • Are changes occurring in the target and collateral behaviors? • Are the treatment changes socially valid and clinically significant? • Are target behaviors normalized? • Are “side-effects” present?

  25. INTERVENTION EVALUATION • Periodic collection of assessment data (e.g., teacher ratings, observations, academic performance measures) • Consumer satisfaction ratings • Comparison with normal peers • Revision of treatment plan based on assessment data

  26. What are the most common school difficulties associated with ADHD? • High rates of disruptive behavior • Low rates of engagement with academic instruction and materials • Inconsistent completion and accuracy on schoolwork • Poor performance on homework, tests, & long-term assignments • Difficulties getting along with peers & teachers

  27. Project PASS: Initial Group Differences • 1st through 4th grade students in public elementary schools in eastern PA • N = 87 children with ADHD • N = 38 normal controls • 20 min observations in math and reading using the BOSS (Shapiro, 1996) • Woodcock-Johnson Reading & Math subtests (WJ-III) • Teacher ratings on the Academic Competency Evaluation Scale (ACES; DiPerna & Elliott)

  28. Project PASS: Classroom Behavior in Reading

  29. Project PASS: Classroom Behavior in Math

  30. Project PASS: WJ-III Achievement Test Scores

  31. Project PASS: ACES Teacher Ratings

  32. Kindergarten Subjects Compared to District Norms on DIBELS OnRF

  33. Letter Naming Fluency: Kindergarten Benchmark Scores

  34. Comparison of Kindergarten Subjects and Peers on Benchmarks

  35. Comparison of First Grade Subjects and Peers on Benchmarks

  36. Most Common Interventions for Children with ADHD • Psychotropic Medication (e.g., CNS stimulants such as methylphenidate) • Home-based contingency management (behavioral parent training) • School-based contingency management interventions (e.g., token reinforcement) • Academic tutoring • Daily report card or school-home notes

  37. MEDICATIONS FOR ADHD • Stimulant Medications • Methylphenidate (Ritalin, Concerta, Metadate) • Dextroamphetamine (Dexedrine) • Adderall • Tricyclic Antidepressants • Desipramine (Norpramine);Imipramine (Tofranil) • Other Antidepressants • Bupropion (Wellbutrin); Fluoxetine (Prozac) • Other Medications • Clonidine (Catapres) • Atomoxetine (Strattera)

  38. BEHAVIORAL EFFECTS OF STIMULANTS • Increased Attention and Concentration • Decreased Impulsivity • Decreased Task-Irrelevant Activity Level • Decreased Aggressiveness • Increased Compliance • Improved Handwriting and Fine Motor Skill • Improved Peer Relations and Social Status • Possible enhancement of academic productivity

  39. SIDE EFFECTS OF STIMULANT DRUGS • Insomnia & Decreased Appetite (50-60%) • Headaches and Stomachaches (20-40%) • Prone to Crying (10%) • Nervous Mannerisms (10%) • Tics (<5%) and Tourette’s (Very Rare) • Overfocused behavior; Cognitive toxicity • Mild Weight Loss (A Few Pounds First 1-2 Years); No effect on Skeletal Growth • Mild Increases in Heart Rate and Blood Pressure • Cylert Affects Liver Functioning; Needs Monitor

  40. Problems with Currently Available Research Literature • Limited data on school-based interventions in gen. ed. settings • “One size fits all” approach is typical • Emphasis on reduction of disruptive behavior rather than improvement in social behavior or academic skills • Few studies of adolescents • Focus on short-term outcomes & limited data on generalization of effects

  41. Multimodal Treatment Study (MTA) • N = 579 children from Gr. 1-5 (M age = 8.5) randomly assigned to tx groups • Medication management (n = 144), Behavioral tx (n = 144), Combined tx (n = 145), and Community Care Control Group (n = 146) • 14 mos of tx (manualized) at mult. sites • Multiple assessment measures collected on three occasions

  42. MTA Psychosocial Interventions • Parent Training • 27 group sessions over 14 mos • School Intervention • Child-Based Treatment: Summer Treatment Program • Comprehensive behavior mod. Program • Peer interventions • Sports skills training • Daily report cards • Individualized programs, as necessary

  43. MTA School Intervention Component • Teacher consultation • Biweekly meetings with teachers over 14 mos • Daily Report Card implemented • Basic behavioral principles and classroom interventions as necessary (e.g., token economy); Stage II tx (response cost) as necessary • Paraprofessional Program (UCI model) • Para spent half day in classroom for 12 weeks in fall of 2nd school year • Implemented behavior modification procedures including daily report card & merit badge system for social skills

  44. MTA Study (cont.) • Reductions in symptoms in all groups • Combined tx & medication greater symptom reduction than BT & control • Combined tx > BT & control in reduction of agg./ODD symptoms & improved social skills, parent-child relations, and reading achievement • Medication > BT in most cases; however meds still active while BT had been faded • Predictors of individual response? • Effects of school intervention component?

  45. School-based Intervention for ADHD: A Meta-analysis (DuPaul & Eckert, 1997)

  46. School-based Intervention for ADHD: Effects on Behavior

  47. School-based Intervention for ADHD: Effects on Academics

  48. Balanced “Game” Plan • Too often rely solely on defense (reactive) strategies • Need a strong “offense” (proactive) and a strong “defense” (reactive) • Intervention plan should always include both proactive & reactive procedures (emphasis on positive)

  49. School-Based Interventions for ADHD • Manipulating Antecedents (Proactive) • Post Rules • Instructional Modifications • Workload Adjustment • Providing Choices • Peer Tutoring

  50. School-Based Interventions for ADHD (cont.) • Manipulating Consequences (Reactive) • Token Reinforcement • Verbal Reprimands • Response Cost • Time Out from Positive Reinforcement • Self-Management

More Related