190 likes | 222 Views
Methanol Economy. Hydrogen Economy. vs. Ryan Morrison ChE 384 11/20/2006. Outline. Introduction Hydrogen Production, Storage, Distribution Methanol Production, Storage, Distribution Fuel Cells Conclusions. Introduction. Persistent fossil fuel burning
E N D
Methanol Economy Hydrogen Economy vs. Ryan Morrison ChE 384 11/20/2006
Outline • Introduction • Hydrogen • Production, Storage, Distribution • Methanol • Production, Storage, Distribution • Fuel Cells • Conclusions
Introduction • Persistent fossil fuel burning • Adverse effects on the climate (global warming) • World needs to dig itself out • Will cost an arm & a leg • Hydrogen/Methanol are proposed solutions
Hydrogen • Infinitely abundant • Ideally clean burning fuel • No CO2 with H2O as a by-product
Hydrogen Production • Worldwide production is 50 million tonnes per year • Steam reforming of fossil fuels • Produces CO2, so potential for capture/sequestration • Electrolysis of water • Highly energy intensive, but highly efficient
Hydrogen Storage • Compressed H2 in carbon fiber tanks • 5,000 – 10,000 psi • Liquid H2 • -253 oC cooling required, or else boil-off • Absorption • Solid state uptake/release
Hydrogen Storage • Compressed H2 in carbon fiber tanks • 5,000 – 10,000 psi • Liquid H2 • -253 oC cooling required, or else boil-off • Absorption • Solid state uptake/release
Hydrogen Distribution • Centralized & decentralized locations • Both have their differences in CO2 capture, transportation methods, and safety • Common ground is magnitude of capital investment
Methanol • Liquid fuel • Precursor to ethylene/propylene
Methanol Production • Worldwide production is 32 million tonnes per year • Steam reforming of fossil fuels • Syngas reacts with H2 • Direct conversion from CO2 • From captured flue gas or atmosphere
Methanol Storage & Distribution • Current filling stations and storage vessels can be re-used or retrofit • Only minor changes to materials of construction or coatings
Fuel Cells • Uses chemical energy to produce electricity directly • Low operating temperature, volume, weight • High efficiency • Methanol fuel cells are more reasonable now until H2 issues are settled
Conclusions • Hydrogen has too many issues • Methanol would be a good substitute fuel for gasoline • Neither are 100% proven, so hybrid devices will control markets • Fate of methanol or hydrogen is coupled with fate of fuel cells