1 / 27

Digital Inclusion in San Francisco

Digital Inclusion in San Francisco. Tom Berman Matthew Case Joshua Daniels Mara Larsen-Fleming Sun Ha Lee May 17, 2007 San Francisco City Hall. Roadmap of Project. What is the digital divide and what is its impact? The magnitude and scope of the digital divide in San Francisco

gwyn
Download Presentation

Digital Inclusion in San Francisco

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Digital Inclusion in San Francisco Tom BermanMatthew CaseJoshua DanielsMara Larsen-FlemingSun Ha LeeMay 17, 2007San Francisco City Hall

  2. Roadmap of Project • What is the digital divide and what is its impact? • The magnitude and scope of the digital divide in San Francisco • Current digital inclusion efforts and city resources • Further considerations and suggested research

  3. What is the digital divide and what is its impact?

  4. The Digital Divide • Digital Divide: inequities in the use of technology by certain populations. • Access • Skills & Knowledge

  5. Impact of the Divide As more economic, social, and government activities move online, many San Franciscans are less able to experience the educational, workforce, and civic benefits of digital technology.

  6. The magnitude and scope of the digital divide in San Francisco

  7. The Personal Access Divide Exists in San Francisco • Location is a significant factor in home use • Mapping of City Survey Results (Bay Area Council/Field Research, 2007), (BAYCAT/Full Circle Fund, 2006)

  8. Computer at home by District 83% 91% 68%

  9. Internet at home by District 78% 78% 87% 87% 63% 64%

  10. Skill divide exists for under-served communities National data indicates that certain demographic groups have lower levels of knowledge about and skills to use digital technology: • Low-income • Elderly • Less-educated • African-American • Latinos • Limited-English speakers

  11. Skill divide exists for under-served communities in SF

  12. What are current digital inclusion efforts and are they enough?

  13. Recent Policy Efforts to Close the Personal Access Divide SF Tech Connect Initiative • Universal Wireless • Hardware Access • New PC Purchase Program • Refurbished computer purchase

  14. Are hardware and internet access programs enough to deal with the divide? While PC purchase programs address most resource barriers to personal access, they do not address barriers due to: • Skills • Knowledge • Limited resources of very poor

  15. Recent Efforts to Provide Public Access & Training • SF Connect Community Events • Public Schools • Libraries • City Colleges • Community Technology Programs • Housing Developments

  16. Public Schools (SFUSD) Challenges of providing consistent and adequate across schools: • SFUSD Technology Master Plan • Under-funded • Student-to-computer ratios widely variant across schools • Aging equipment & under maintained equipment • Technology integration into curriculum lacks funding and infrastructure

  17. Libraries • Not enough computers in some branches • Maximum of one hour use per day for patrons • Funding limited due to Child Internet Protection Act (CIPA) non-compliance • Some foundation money to mitigate this, but not a guarantee going forward • Training programs inconsistent across libraries

  18. City Colleges • Some free computer classes • Locations and public access sites limited • Computer classes in Chinese and Spanish limited • Funding through workforce development board

  19. Community Technology Programs • 140 Community Technology Programs provide access and training services to under-served groups and neighborhoods • Concentrated in the city center, fewer in “at risk” areas • Housing Project CTC and Wifi pilot projects

  20. Community Technology Programs in San Francisco

  21. SFUSD Student to Computer Ratios (All Computers)

  22. Student to Computer Ratios (4 Years or less)

  23. Computers in the Libraries

  24. Summary of Remaining Gaps • Community Technology Program coverage is incomplete • Schools are not meeting their target student computer ratios (5:1) • When older computers are excluded, the ratios get much larger (as high as 435:1) • School and library resource gaps are citywide problems, not location-specific • Not sufficiently meeting additional need in low home use areas

  25. Important Considerations • Targeting vs. Leveling of Technology Resources Across the City • Stakeholder Involvement (Schools, Libraries, Community Technology Programs, etc.) • Needs of Providers vs. End-Users • Evaluation/Benchmarks for Success

  26. Further Research • More concrete information is needed about skills and knowledge in SF • Targeted community assessment of special needs (i.e. limited-English, older adults, disabled) • Role of attitudes in persistence of digital divide

  27. Closing Rapidly changing nature of digital technology requires ongoing commitment to ensure that underserved communities are able to keep up

More Related