Charles Dodgson aka Lewis Carroll

1. Charles Dodgson aka Lewis Carroll Once master the machinery of Symbolic Logic, and you have a mental occupation always at hand, of absorbing interest, and one that will be of real use to you in any subject you may take up. It will give you clearness of thought - the ability to see your way through a puzzle - the habit of arranging your ideas in an orderly and get-at-able form - and, more valuable than all, the power to detect fallacies, and to tear to pieces the flimsy illogical arguments, which you will so continually encounter in books, in newspapers, in speeches, and even in sermons, and which so easily delude those who have never taken the trouble to master this fascinating Art

2. Lecture 3, MATH 210G.04, Spring 2011Lewis Carroll and the Syllogism

4. http://durendal.org/lcsl/

6. Dodgson and the syllogism • (a) All babies are illogical. • (b) Nobody is despised who can manage a crocodile. • (c) Illogical persons are despised. • “universe”: set of all people. • “it” in this context refers to a general person. • rewrite each statement in the puzzle as an implication in symbols • B : it is a baby • L : it is logical • M : it can manage a crocodile • D : it is despised ,

7. In symbols: • (a) B → ~L : If it is a baby then it is not logical. • (b) M → ~D : If it can manage a crocodile then it is not despised. • (c) ~L → D : If it is not logical then it is despised. • Aim: stringing together chain of implications, apply transitive reasoning: • A → B ^ V → C → A → C . • We have: B → ~L , and ~L → D so we conclude B → D • Contra positive of (b): D → ~M so… • B → ~L → D → ~M . • Our ultimate conclusion is the statement: • B → ~M : If it is a baby then it cannot manage a crocodile . • Vernacular: Babies cannot manage crocodiles

8. Puzzle # 2 • (a) None of the unnoticed things, met with at sea, are mermaids. • (b) Things entered in the log, as met with at sea, are sure to be worth remembering. • (c) I have never met with anything worth remembering, when on a voyage. • (d) Things met with at sea, that are noticed, are sure to be recorded in the log. • Universe: “things met with at the sea” • N : it is noticed • M : it is a mermaid • L : it is entered in the log • R : it is worth remembering • I : I have met with it at sea .

10. (a) ~N → ~M (M → N) • (b) L → R (~R → ~L) • (c) I → ~R (R → ~I) • (d) N → L (~L → ~N ) • Strung together: • I → ~ R → ~L → ~N → ~M . • I → ~M : If I have met with it at sea then it is not a mermaid . • “I have never met with a mermaid at sea.”

11. Puzzle # 3 • (a) No interesting poems are unpopular among people of real taste. • (b) No modern poetry is free from affectation. • (c) All your poems are on the subject of soap-bubbles. • (d) No affected poetry is popular among people of real taste. • (e) No ancient poem is on the subject of soap-bubbles. • Universe: “poems”, • I : it is interesting • P : it is popular among people of real taste • M : it is modern • A : it is affected • Y : it is your poem • S : it is on the subject of soap bubbles . • (a) I → P (~P → ~I) • (b) M → A (~A → ~M) • (c) Y → S (~S → ~Y) • (d) A → ~P (P → ~A) • (e) ~M → ~S (S → M).

12. (a) I → P (~P → ~I) • (b) M → A (~A → ~M) • (c) Y → S (~S → ~Y) • (d) A → ~P (P → ~A) • (e) ~M → ~S (S → M). • I → P → ~A → ~M → ~S → ~Y , • “contra-positive chain” Y → S → M → A → ~P → ~I . • Solution: I → ~Y, or Y → ~I. • “Your poetry is not interesting.”

13. For Quiz • Every one who is sane can do Logic. • No lunatics are fit to serve on a jury. • None of your sons can do logic.

14. User your clicker to express the right conclusion • Every one who is sane can do Logic. • No lunatics are fit to serve on a jury. • None of your sons can do logic. A.) Jurors can do logic B.) Jurors are sane C.) Your sons are not sane D.) Your sons are not fit to serve on a jury

15. Solution • Every one who is sane can do Logic. • No lunatics are fit to serve on a jury. • None of your sons can do logic. • Sa->DL • FJ->Sa • DL->~So • Anyone fit to serve on a jury is not your son (your sons are not fit to serve on a jury)

16. For group work/quiz 1) The only animals in this house are cats. 2) Every animal is suitable for a pet, that loves to gaze at the moon. 3) When I detest an animal, I avoid it. 4) No animals are carnivorous, unless they prowl at night. 5) No cat fails to kill mice. 6) No animals ever take to me, except what are in this house. 7) Kangaroos are not suitable for pets. 8) None but carnivora kill mice. 9) I detest animals that do not take to me. 10) Animals, that prowl at night, always love to gaze at the moon.

17. Assign letters to each of the following statements • It is an animal that lives in this house • It is a cat • It is suitable to be a pet • It loves to gaze at the moon • I detest it • I avoid it • It is carnivorous • It prowls at night • It kills mice • It takes to me • It is a kangaroo

18. Translate each of the statements in terms of your symbols, e.g., A→C 1) The only animals in this house are cats. 2) Every animal is suitable for a pet, that loves to gaze at the moon. 3) When I detest an animal, I avoid it. 4) No animals are carnivorous, unless they prowl at night. 5) No cat fails to kill mice. 6) No animals ever take to me, except what are in this house. 7) Kangaroos are not suitable for pets. 8) None but carnivora kill mice. 9) I detest animals that do not take to me. 10) Animals, that prowl at night, always love to gaze at the moon.