80 likes | 207 Views
The Exploration of Airfoil Sections to Determine the Optimal Airfoil for Remote Controlled Pylon Racing. Michael DeRosa Master of Engineering Final Project. What is Remote Control Pylon Racing?. 3 Recognized Classes: 424 class: 120 mph Quickie 500 426 class: 150 mph Quickie 500
E N D
The Exploration of Airfoil Sections to Determine the Optimal Airfoil for Remote Controlled Pylon Racing Michael DeRosa Master of Engineering Final Project
What is Remote Control Pylon Racing? • 3 Recognized Classes: • 424 class: 120 mph Quickie 500 • 426 class: 150 mph Quickie 500 • Focus of Project • 422 class: 190-200 mph • Size of 426 Class airplanes determined by Academy of Model Aeronautics rules • Minimum weight of 3.75 lbs. • 500 square inches of wing area • 50-52 inches of win span • Aspect ratio of 5 • Wing thickness to chord ratio is 0.11875 • Powered by methanol fueled Jett 0.40 cubic inch engine displacement engine • Goal is to fly around a 2 mile course in shortest amount of time • Course is marked by 3 pylons: 2 are 100 ft. apart and 1 is 475 ft. from the centerline of the twin pylons • 4 planes race at a time • 10 laps • Penalties for turning inside of pylons Typical Q-500 pylon racer Viper 500 by Great Planes Typical Q-500 pylon race
Optimal Airfoil For Pylon Racing Not Explored • No official studies on pylon racing airfoils completed to date • Entering into a 50 ft. radius turn at 150 mi/hr creates 30 G’s of force acting on the plane • Wing must pitch up to increase lift coefficient at expense of increased drag • Increased drag can slow down a plane by 15-20 mi/hr in turns • Even a 5 mph speed gain in turns is signifiant. • Widely used airfoil for pylon racing is NACA 66-012 symmetrical laminar flow airfoil • Drag penalties in turning flight translates to significant loss of speeds in turns • Conversely, a cambered airfoil such a Clark Y will retain more speed in turns due to higher lift coefficients at much lower drag increase; higher L/D than NACA 66-012 airfoil • Trade off is lower maximum speed in straight ways due to higher form drag • Modern airfoils created by Martin Hepperle, Selig, and Eppler are useful for drag minimization in pylon racing • Flaps, wing with 2 different airfoil types have not been considered and/or assessed NACA 66-012 Laminar Airfoil Typically Used for Pylon Racing High Lift Clark Y Airfoil Not Typically Used for Pylon Racing
Project will Extensively use XFOIL Airfoil Development Program • Developed by Dr. Mark Drela of MIT • Uses solutions of viscous and invisicid differential equations to solve airfoil shape for: • Lift coefficient for given angles of attack • Drag polars to determine drag coefficient for a given lift coefficient • Moment coefficient for given angles of attack • Velocity ratio with free stream velocity over any given point over airfoil • Pressure distribution over airfoil • Will be used in conjugation with published lift and drag coefficients determined from wind tunnel tests. http://web.mit.edu/drela/Public/web/xfoil
Methodology for Determining Optimal Airfoil • Utilize XFOIL and published airfoil data to obtain necessary lift and drag coefficients for the following airfoils: • NACA 66-012 baseline • Clark Y as high lift option • Martin Hepperle • Selig • Eppler • Wing with 2 airfoils • Airfoils with flaps • Each airfoil trial have wings and planes with following properties: • 500 square inches • 50 inches chord length • Minimum thickness to chord ratio of 0.11875 • 3.75 lb. airplane • 1.7 HP engine • Similar fuselage and tail assumed for each airfoil • Determine speed loss in turns through the use of drag coefficients • Determine maximum speed in straight ways by use of drag coefficients at low angles of attack • Derive equations for acceleration/deceleration in Maple • Tabulate time to 10 laps in Excel • Fastest time to 10 laps is the optimal airfoil section
Final Product is Airfoil that Yields Lowest 10 Lap Times • Lowest 10 lap times calculated in Excel takes acceleration and deceleration due to drag and highest top speed achieved • Optimal airfoil section is compromise between low drag to attain highest speed in straightway and high L/D in turns at higher angles of attack • Low drag airfoil can achieve best of both worlds through use of flaps • Wing can incorporate low drag airfoil and high lift airfoils to achieve best of both • Pylon race course will incorporate: • 10 laps • Assume 1 lap consisting of: • 2x 475.5 ft. straight ways • 2x 50 ft. radius semi circles • 12,65.16 ft. per lap • Total distance covered in race is 2.40 miles Typical pylon race course layout set by Academy of Model Aeronautics rules