1 / 38

The Criminal Justice Process for Guardians

The Criminal Justice Process for Guardians. Offense reported. Citizen/witness report Victim report Mandated report To Law enforcement/or social services. Team Investigation. Law enforcement and Social Services. WHY Required by law since 1975 in Minnesota GOALS

majed
Download Presentation

The Criminal Justice Process for Guardians

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The Criminal Justice Process for Guardians

  2. Offense reported • Citizen/witness report • Victim report • Mandated report • To Law enforcement/or social services

  3. Team Investigation • Law enforcement and Social Services

  4. WHY • Required by law since 1975 in Minnesota • GOALS • To reduce trauma experienced by child abuse victims (avoid multiple interviews) • To enhance prosecution and other appropriate dispositions of child abuse cases • By gathering more complete and powerful evidence • By assessing needs/risks of child and family

  5. WHAT – Child Abuse • Sexual, physical or neglect by person responsible for the child’s care • Parents, family members, persons living in the residence, babysitters, daycare workers, teachers, custodians, bus drivers, etc. • And as of 8/1/12 – cross report abuse of children by non-caregiver so that Social Services may offer support to victim/family

  6. The child abuse investigation is vastly different from the standard investigation • Victim loves the offender • Victim relies on the offender • for care, housing, food, etc. • Team with other disciplines • to benefit the children

  7. Collaboration of disciplines: • The importance of early meetings • Decide plan for investigation • Meet with experts early • to go over the evidence/findings • Decide if special experts needed • Medical examiner/coroner • Pediatric • Child abuse expert/domestic violence expert • BCA – DNA, etc. • Forensic dentist

  8. Child’s Interview/Statement • Video interview preferred • Good production values – • hear child, see child’s face/expressions • Only one other person in room • Allow child to narrate • Maintain professional distance • balanced with empathy • Details of abuse • Child’s affect during disclosure

  9. Child’s Interview/Statement (continued) • Spontaneity of disclosure • Developmentally appropriate language • Using clear language • Avoid jargon • Corroboration • Look beyond the interview with the child • Identify types of physical evidence –

  10. Other issues • Possible recantation by victim • dynamics • Non-offending parent – • Possible failure to protect • Motives? • Family Court • Coordination with or lack thereof

  11. Document the crime scene • There is always a crime scene • Type of evidence • Suspect’s clothing – match child’s description? • Location – room/furnishings match child’s description? • Photos – jurors love photos • Victim clothing – blood stained power puff girl panties • Vehicles: match child’s description, is it a crime scene? • Computer, discs, zip drives

  12. Recognizing When a Child’s Injury or Illness is Caused by Abuse • Repetitive Accidents • Skin injuries • Location and pattern • Multiple injuries of different ages • Lack of injuries while in hospital or foster care • Bruises • Infants • Bony prominences • Bruise configuration; pattern injury • Natural or normal bruising • Mongolian spots/birthmarks resemble bruises • Burns • History – suspicious • Location • Pattern

  13. Other’s statements • Brainstorm about who else to talk to • Teachers • Bus drivers • Neighbors • Babysitters/daycare • Counselors • Extended family members • Guardian ad Litem

  14. Confession by the suspect • Whenever possible, suspect interviewed • interrogation techniques – • To enhance accuracy/honesty of suspect • Suspect talks – detective listens • Non-confrontational initially

  15. partial confession/admission • Admitted delays in seeking medical treatment • Admissions stressor crying/difficult feeding/toilet learning (the lascivious” or “sexually curious” six year old • Inadequate or changing explanation for injury, • trivial trauma to explain major injury • Child was wearing provocative clothing • Blame shifting • (sibling/spouse caused injury) • (spouse sexually cold) • Controlled call by victim to suspect – • consider age, ability, relationship

  16. WHERE – Venue • Social services has jurisdiction • for children currently residing in county • no matter where abuse occurred • Law enforcement • Crim sex where the crime originates or terminates • Where any element of the offense was committed • Child abuse may be prosecuted • either in the county where the abuse occurred or where the child is found

  17. Child Protection Assessment Process • Child Maltreatment Reporting Form • Conclusion of CP Assessment • Notice to Mandated Reporters

  18. Sexual Abuse – child • Victim of criminal sexual conduct • Victim of Child prostitution • Exposure to or subject of pornography • Exposure to inappropriate sexual behavior

  19. Physical Abuse • Non-accidental injury • Does not include reasonable and moderate discipline. But … • Confinement, locking, caging, tying, interference with breathing, etc. • Threatened physical harm • Giving a child dangerous or harmful substances for punishment

  20. Neglect: will be assessed • Inadequate food, shelter, clothing, medical care or supervision and so on • Emotional Maltreatment: will be assessed

  21. Lack of supervision: will be assessed • Any child 7 years old and younger left alone • Children 8-9 years old alone more than 2 hours • Children 10-13 years old left alone more than 12 hours • 14 year olds left alone more than 1 day • Any age child left alone more than 24 hours without knowing parent whereabouts

  22. Arrest? • The nature of child abuse investigations – defendant not always arrested – an arrest starts a 36 hour time clock – a good child abuse investigation takes longer • Is defendant a flight risk? An immediate danger to public safety?

  23. PROSECUTION • Complaint/Indictment – • multiple counts for one offense • Prosecutor makes charging decision • Probable cause • Proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt • Complaint cites maximum sentence • Sentencing guidelines

  24. AFTER COMPLAINT FILED • Arrest or Summons • First Appearance/Arraignment • Conditions of Release – No contact? • Conditions of contact? • Omnibus Hearing – Plea Negotiations • Contested Hearing

  25. Timeline • Once charged – may take 9 – 12 months • To resolve case in plea or trial and sentence • Continuances common • State can ask for a speedy trial • Once convicted - • Appeals can go on for years

  26. Trial • Witness Preparation • Jury Selection – Opening statements • Victim’s testimony • Other witnesses/physical-scientific evidence • Defendant may testify – present evidence • Closing statements/Instructions • Deliberations by jury or judge

  27. Verdict • Acquittal – “not guilty” • Case not proven beyond a reasonable doubt • Hung jury – another trial scheduled • Guilty • Pre-sentence investigation/psych eval • Victim impact

  28. Sentencing • Probation/Jail/Treatment/no contact • Registration (public when not in compliance) • Prison • 2/3 of sentence in prison (1/3 “parole”) • Conditional release • Registration • Community Notification – (Level 3)

  29. MSG Grid (sample)

  30. Sentencing • Dispositional departures • Durational departures • Mitigating/aggravating factors • Blakely

  31. Report of possible crime/abuse/neglect • Mandated reporters • Mandated report: immediately • Within 24 hours • Failure to report • Misdemeanor • Gross misdemeanor if two children at risk • Felony if child dies

  32. SUPERVISION • Most offenders are on probation • Jail rather than prison • Treatment • No contact • Intensive Supervised release • Risk assessment – • End of confinement review

  33. Questions?

More Related