1 / 30

Aiding Development: the Relevance of a Local governance Perspective

Aiding Development: the Relevance of a Local governance Perspective. Isa Baud Department of Geography, Planning and International Development Studies. Trends in development processes and governance. Neo-liberal paradigm in the 1980s led to a re-thinking of the role of the national state

makoto
Download Presentation

Aiding Development: the Relevance of a Local governance Perspective

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Aiding Development: the Relevance of a Local governance Perspective Isa Baud Department of Geography, Planning and International Development Studies

  2. Trends in development processes and governance • Neo-liberal paradigm in the 1980s led to a re-thinking of the role of the national state • Ideas: • development should not be state-led • Economic growth should be led by market forces • National state should step back • Results: • State ceded powers to lower levels of government (local or provincial) • State ceded powers to higher levels of government (international institutions; regional trading blocs) • Government should work with private sector and civil organisations • Local governments started promoting economic growth policies

  3. Local governance perspectives • Local governments have closest contact with their citizens, most responsive to local needs and demands • lowest level of electoral representation for citizens towards government • Classic responsibilities for QoL: public goods provision (water, sanitation, waste management, housing, basic education, health, safety) • Major change that governments received more responsibility for economic growth – entrepreneurial local governments

  4. Potential contributions of local governments to MDGs - 1 • MDG 7c: increasing drinking water access by 50% • 80% piped water in urban areas, 34% in rural areas; coverage in rural areas increased; this target will be met by 2015 • MDG 7c: halving people with no access to sanitation • Southern Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa, 64-69% no access; little progress in these two regions • 40% of urban population in Southern Asia no access: open defecation widespread • In sub-Saharan Africa, rich have access, the poor very little to sanitation

  5. Potential contributions of local governments to MDGs - 2 • MDG 7d: improve lives of 100 million slum dwellers – housing (only 10% of actual slum population) • 2000-2010: % slum dwellers down from 39 to 33%; absolute numbers slum dwellers in cities going up (787 million) • But – sub-Saharan Africa, 70% of urban residents in slums • Conflict increases % of residents in slums: • Iraq from 17% to 51% since 2000

  6. Other contributions by ULGs • Not included in the MDGs; the role of cities as drivers of the economy • Role of cities in political processes – direct interaction with citizens

  7. WRR –report conclusions • Recognizes importance of national governments in ‘aiding development’ • Aid should be relevant to development path of receiving country, and fit national context • diagnose country needs in terms of themes and sectors before providing aid • right aid channel should be chosen • Aid should have catalysing effect (spill-over effects) • How much does aid through local government programmes contribute?

  8. Urban local governments • Netherlands: …. Local governments • urban local governments association VNG • VNG International works with other ULGs in strengthening local governments elsewhere • City-to-city cooperation • Internationally: • UCLG international association of ULGs • UN- Habitat UN agency dealing with urban issues

  9. International role of ULGs • UN conferences indicated importance of LGs in promoting local development (Earth Summit 1992 and Habitat Summit 1996) • ULGs included in WB programmes in policy consultative groups – Cities Alliance • UCLG become member of OECD/DAC group in making aid effective • European Charter on Aid recognized ULGs role through MIC and ACB

  10. Aid from local government perspective • LOGO SOUTH programme 2007-2010 (DGIS aided) • Three components • Municipal International Cooperation (MIC) • Association Capacity Building (ACB) • Policy Development and Research (PD&R)

  11. Municipal international cooperation • MIC partnerships between municipalities • designed to improve capacity of local government by peer-to-peer exchange • contribute to short- and longer term objectives • service provision, poverty alleviation, institutional strengthening, and knowledge exchange • Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) • improve democracy and enhance responsiveness

  12. Dutch MIC • currently programme in 12 countries • 8 countries in Africa, 2 in Asia, 2 in L. Am • 40 twinnings: focus on thematic issues in progr. related to main responsibilities LGs • Waste management, water provision, housing, citizen participation, Hiv/AIDS • Also water boards and housing corporations involved (semi-public companies)

  13. Association Capacity Building • Association Capacity Building (ACB) programmes focus on developing LGAs’ capacities and skills • for their advocacy and lobby roles • provide services to their members and • to act as networking facilitators and knowledge brokers vis-à-vis national governments, regional networks

  14. Recent changes in programme • MIC – one theme per country (40 twinnings) • ACB – stronger regional focus • 3 LGAs in 4 regions • Focus on improving service delivery; management capacities; capacity for lobby and advocacy; financial sustainability • Pd& R – recent addition • LG in peace-building and fragile states; • LG and MDGs; • Aid architecture, policy dialogue, accountability; • Support to LG in conflict areas

  15. Zuid Afrika: water en afval management • Water management: water scarcity but also very unequal division of water • Explicit request national government to Netherlands for developing Dutch water board model • Water boards with stakeholder participation set up: cross-border negotiation with Mozambique also developed

  16. C2C Buffalo City – Leiden (Waste) Activities • Exchange NL-SA - SA – NL • P2P, many forms of informal learning • Exchange within SA of municipal staff and community leaders (BCM-Ekuhurleni and Port Elizabeth) • Tailor made training (PR skills in NL • Construction of Waste-drop off points

  17. Results in Pilot Community Duncan Village • Construction of 36 waste collection points in Duncan village. • Ca. 30 community members trained in basic principles and functioning of waste-cooperatives (in exchange visits) and in all aspects of waste-management (during trainings). • Basic materials bought to ensure that 100 community members can now act as managers of the waste collection points and clean litter. • All relevant ward-councillors trained in principles of the project and the role of the community • Public awareness campaigns on waste issues in Duncan Village • The community members very proud of the project, and attract many visitors to their community

  18. Results within BCM municipality • Numerous learning effects for the staff involved who reported • Increased technical skills (better understanding of waste-management system, increased PR-skills) • Increased project management skills, including project-formulation and fundraising • Change in work-attitude (substantially more committed to their work, pride, no longer working for a salary only). • In Leiden: increased creativity, commitment and possibilities for “out-of the box” thinking. • Strengthening of Buffalo City Municipality • Improved cooperation between departments involved (road and infrastructure (stormwater), waste-management, community services) • Improved management skills of staff involved (including capacity to raise additional funding)

  19. WRR: Development aid has to be relevant • Relevance high because • Covers key sectoral priorities of LGs and LGAs • Follows national policy in relevant sectors

  20. ULG programme • Addresses key priorities of LG • Municipalities and sectoral organisations involved • Possible upscaling good practice to country level • Ownership and commitment high among staff • political commitment varies locally

  21. WRR: A good diagnosis is necessary…. • Peer-to-peer exchange is basis for diagnosis • ULGs in South directly involved in preparing project proposals: South Africa • Projects provide direct inputs to local policy making • Learning exchanges between partners N-S, S-N, S-S

  22. WRR: The right channel should carry it out… • Unique in efficiency and sustainability • Builds on existing organisation and staff on both sides – in-built capacity for long-term sustainability • Overhead costs of programme much lower than other types of development coop programmes (PMUs, salaries) • Missions effective means of peer-to-peer exchanges; learning from practice • Knowledge exchange through expert networks nationally and regionally

  23. Creativity in MIC projects • Adaptability in funding programme; • Partners bring in extra resources (human, technical, financial) • knowledge exchange, research added • Country coordinators important • Missions to Netherlands useful

  24. Can still be strengthened.. • Working together with LGAs and sectoral organisations (water boards, housing corporations) and with national government dpts. • Comparing examples of ‘good practice’ nationally, for other ULGs to utilize • Political representatives need to included more (ACB) • Local public goods, but also global public goods should be included (CO2 reduction, energy saving, recycling, water management)

  25. WRR: Effectiveness linked to knowledge exchange and learning • Learning effects strong between peers N-S, S-N, S-S • Strengthened municipal organisations: policy formulation, project management, technical skills • Potential leverage learning effects to sectoral and national levels • Embedding programme in existing organisations provides learning continuity beyond project period • Dissemination to other municipalities strong

  26. Strengthening local government programmes; recommendations 1 • Maintain adaptability in funding programme • Make strategic choices for critical mass by country • Promote combinations of stakeholders at different levels, • Promote learning between municipalities by sector • Promote scaling-up impact of municipal activities by links with sectoral and national organisations

  27. Recommendations 2 • Involve councillors and mayors to increase political support • Combine ACB with MIC components for synergy • Include MDGs in programme in accordance with municipal priorities • Knowledge partnerships with universities, knowledge centres • Promote model of working with existing staff and organisations as efficient and effective model for other aid programmes

  28. Thank you!

More Related