10 likes | 99 Views
Based on dataset attribute. Search and gather. Sort. Pros and Cons. can be automated does not require access to full text. identifier (DOI, url , accession #). search for ID in reference sections of all papers. BUT pattern is currently rare lacks tool support.
E N D
Based on dataset attribute Search and gather Sort Pros and Cons • can be automated • does not require access to full text identifier (DOI, url, accession #) search for ID in reference sections of all papers • BUT • pattern is currently rare • lacks tool support Not supported by Web of Science or Scopus Other citation tools have limited scope or messy results publicly archived dataset sort hits to disambiguate reuse from submission submitter name or dataset title search in full text of all papers ! Names and titles are messy identifiers ! Requires full text Requires full text • patterns are common Messy, time consuming • BUT • manual • time consuming • error-prone • requires full text sort hits to disambiguate reuse from other citation contexts data collection article publication gather papers that cite the data collection paper ! ! Requires citation history Link to data collection pub often missing from dataset submission record Requires full text Messy, time consuming This flow misses attributions embedded in supplementary information, reuses attributed through a query description, etc. Roadblock to finding all citations ! Requires subscription access Introduces errors Heather Piwowar