1 / 31

The United States Health Care System: A Case of Voodoo Economics?

The United States Health Care System: A Case of Voodoo Economics?. Actuaries Club of Philadelphia February 15, 2011. John Dante, FSA, MAAA , FCA. Outline. Why should we care about Health Care? What is Voodoo Economics?

meir
Download Presentation

The United States Health Care System: A Case of Voodoo Economics?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. The United States Health Care System:A Case of Voodoo Economics? Actuaries Club of Philadelphia February 15, 2011 John Dante, FSA, MAAA, FCA

  2. Outline • Why should we care about Health Care? • What is Voodoo Economics? • What are some not-so-good attributes of the Current Health Care System? • What are some attributes that I consider to be Voodoo Economics? • What do I consider to be some better ideas?

  3. Why should we care about health care? • Currently, the U.S. spends more per capita on health care than any other member nation of the United Nations. • Cost – Rising faster than inflation

  4. U.S. is the Cost Leader OECD = Org. for Economic Co-operation and Development

  5. Projected Federal Spending (% of GDP) Concerns: Rising cost of health care + aging of U.S. population

  6. What is Voodoo Economics? • This was a term that George H. W. Bush used to describe Ronald Reagan’s economic policies prior to becoming Reagan’s running mate. • Later coined Reaganomics, the expectation was that reduced tax rates and regulation would actually result in more revenue for the Government.

  7. Attributes of US Health Care System • Inconsistency in Costs of Health Care • Multiple Systems that Provide Funding • Third Party Payment • Lack of Coordination of Care • Large Segment of Population Lacks Coverage • Emergency Rooms are Crowded

  8. Inconsistency in Costs of Health Care • Uninsured receive no discounts • Small Commercial Carriers receive small discounts from providers • Large Commercial Carriers receive large discounts from providers • Government Funded Programs (Medicare, Medicaid) pay the least

  9. Multiple Systems that Provide Funding • Medicare • Medicaid • Veterans • Indians • Federal Employees • Employer-Based

  10. Third Party Payment • Consumers are insulated from the costs • Cannot do their Consumer Thing • Few of those paying have the clout to influence cost containment

  11. Lack of Coordination of Care • Physicians are not always sharing important information about patients • Duplication of tests • Lack of follow-up

  12. Large Segment of Population Lacks Coverage • 50.7 million lacked health care insurance in 2009 • Even more lack health care insurance for some portion of a year • Constant flow of individuals terminating and re-enrolling in health insurance coverage

  13. Emergency Rooms are Crowded • Wait for treatment can be several hours • Triage system employed • Some individuals use ER for primary care • Or lack of primary care results in some individuals ending up in ER

  14. Attributes that I consider Voodoo Economics • Don’t Know Costs • Third Party Payer • No Incentive to Make Us Better • Efficacy of Treatments and Drugs Questionable

  15. Don’t Know Costs • Patient is rarely aware of the cost • Physicians many times don’t know cost • Large variation is costs for same procedure

  16. Third Party Payer • Consumer insulated from cost • System is structured improperly to provide incentive to contain costs

  17. No Incentive to Make Us Better • What happens when you get a treatment that doesn’t make you better? • More physician visits, tests and drugs • You pay more • Physician makes more

  18. Efficacy of Treatments and Drugs Questionable • Post treatment studies show that treatments are not always medically necessary • Drug efficacy studies most commonly funded by Drug company and Physician spokespeople often receive compensation

  19. Some Better Ideas • National Fee Schedule • Efficacy of Treatments and Prescription Drugs • Simplification of Plan Designs • Single System • Expand Primary Care • Integrated Health Care Systems

  20. National Fee Schedule • Variation hides price • Variation discourages competitors from entering the market • Variation causes Physicians to not take some insurances • Much time and money spent on fee schedule negotiations • When there is more transparency, Physicians can ask for more and consumers can shop

  21. Efficacy of Treatments and Prescription Drugs • Use money from system simplification to study and create data bank of the most effective treatments and the most effective drugs • Structure greater payments to providers for these as well as lower copays to patients

  22. Simplification of Plan Designs • Has innovative plans designs really made our system better? • The average person does not understand all the nuances of plan designs • Behaviorists say that when people are offered more than six choices, they get overloaded and are less likely to select the optimal choice • Every design could have a specific purpose • Leads to greater customer satisfaction?

  23. Simplification

  24. Single System • Not necessarily single payer • Structured so that various funders could just plug into it • Everyone has an equal vested interest in the system • Savings can be put towards making system more efficient and addressing fraud

  25. Single SystemOne Proposal • Utilize a National Fee Schedule • Clinical Excellence Board to decide what is covered and how • Enrollment, Billing and Claims Payment • Wellness – Programs to encourage lower utilization • Risk Sharing Mechanism

  26. Single SystemAdvantages of One Proposal • Compete on customer service • Make money through greater enrollment and more efficient systems • Make more money by making your population healthier • Beat the risk factor • Perhaps Medicare can outsource to private carriers

  27. Expand Primary Care • Higher percentage of Primary Care Physicians (PCPs) leads to lower costs without a drop in quality • Encourage medical students to become PCPs • Utilize Physician Assistants, Nurse Practitioners and Clinics • Pay more for off-hours care

  28. Integrated Delivery Systems • Encourage the use of Integrated Health Care Systems such as Accountable Care Organizations, Patient-Centered Medical Home and Integrated Hospital/Physician Systems • Take the money from those who want to continue business as usual

  29. BOTTOM LINE • SIMPLIFY SYSTEM • ALIGN INCENTIVES PricewaterhouseCoopers Study • Wasteful spending in U.S. Health Care System calculated to be $1.2 Trillion • of the $2.2 Trillion Total Medical Spend

  30. Questions&Answers

  31. Contact Information John Dante, FSA, MAAA, FCA (570) 417- 9039 johndante@danteactuarial.com

More Related