1 / 24

Test 1 results

Test 1 results. Mean: 82 Median: 87. Polar circles. At winter solstice:. 90 o – L – 23.5 o ~ 0, -> L ~ 66.5 o. Real life complications.

mikaia
Download Presentation

Test 1 results

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Test 1 results Mean: 82 Median: 87

  2. Polar circles At winter solstice: 90o – L – 23.5o ~ 0, -> L ~ 66.5o

  3. Real life complications The axial tilt angle is not constant, but has a complex motion determined by many cycles of short to very long periods. Due to nutation the tilt oscillates over 9" (about 280 m on the surface) over a period of 18.6 years. The main long-term cycle has a period of 41000 years and an amplitude of about 0.68°, or 76 km on the surface. Currently the tilt is decreasing by about 0.47" per year, so the Arctic Circle is moving north by about 15 m per year.

  4. Precession

  5. Ophiuchus Astrology Ecliptic and Zodiac Sun travels 360o/365.25 days ~ 1o/day

  6. History of Astrology • Originated by Babylonians about 1000 BC (mundane astrology, i.e. applies to the world) • Greeks developed natal (birth) astrology (codified by Ptolemy in Tetrabiblos, 2nd century AD) Argues that a person's character and destiny can be understood from the positions of the Sun, Moon, and planets at the moment of his or her birth.

  7. Astrology — big business • 10,000 practicing astrologers • 1000 full-time professionals • 20 astrological journals • 10 new books a week • > 1000 newspapers with astrological forecasts • 5 million people spend ~ $200 M per year consulting astrologers

  8. Horoscope • Natal chart uses astronomical information and date and location of birth • Planets, Moon, & Sun in signs of zodiac • Interpretation step: positions of celestial bodies are used to predict a person’s character and destiny

  9. Does it work? • No evidence that it does • Lots of evidence that it doesn’t

  10. Math Corner • How do we decide if a test is statistically significant? • Coin tossing experiment (flip a coin 20 times and count how many “heads” show up)

  11. Statistically Significant • If N hits expected, deviations of sqrt(N) from the expected value • Example: flipping a coin • 18 flips: 9 plus or minus 3 (33% error) • 20,000 flips: 10,000 plus or minus 100 (1% error) • If someone claims that he can “predict” the outcome and his predictions are within sqrt(N) of the mean value, he is a liar.

  12. Example (Gauquelin) • 15,560 successful individuals in 10 professions • No statistically significant relation between Sun sign and profession • Gave a free horoscope evaluation to anyone who wanted it • 95% said they recognized themselves • but it was the horoscope of France’s worst mass murderer

  13. Example - Silverman • 2978 marriages and 478 divorces in Michigan • No correlations between astrological signs and statistics of marriages/divorces found

  14. Example - McGervey • Birth dates and biographies of 6000 politicians and 17000 scientists • Found the astrological signs for both group to be distributed completely at random

  15. Astrology — conclusion • No predictive power • No scientific basis • Broad psychological appeal • Cheap, easy, and entertaining • May help some people (as do many forms of empathetic counseling) • Useless or damaging in other cases

  16. Pseudoscience: Why bother? • Many people view science as just another belief system • Poor understanding about the difference between science and pseudoscience • Widespread ignorance of what constitutes evidence • Ideological doctrines (religious, political etc.) obstructed the progress in science and culture many times in history: Inquisition, Nazi Germany, Communist Russia etc.

  17. How to recognize pseudoscience?

  18. Goals • Science: The primary goal of science is to achieve a more complete and more unified understanding of the physical world. • Pseudosciences are more likely to be driven by ideological, cultural, or commercial goals. Some examples: astrology (from ancient Babylonian culture,) UFO-ology (popular culture and mistrust of government), Creation Science (attempt to justify Biblical interpretation)

  19. Predictive? • science: Must be (falsifiability). Workers in the field commonly seek out counterexamples or findings that appear to be inconsistent with accepted theories. • pseudoscience: No. A challenge to accepted dogma is often considered a hostile act if not heresy, and leads to bitter disputes or even schisms.

  20. Role of evidence? • science: independently verifiable, no contradictions allowed. Each principle must be tested in the crucible of experience and remains subject to being questioned or rejected at any time. • pseudoscience: anecdotal, not independently verifiable. Observations or data that are not consistent with established beliefs tend to be ignored or actively suppressed.

  21. Innovation? • science: can incorporate new evidence; models change; old ideas are built upon, modified where necessary • pseudoscience: relatively rigid and authoritarian since it is not based on empirical evidence. The field has evolved very little since it was first established. The small amount of research and experimentation that is carried out is generally done more to justify the belief than to extend it.

  22. Authority? • science: no special “experts” recognized. Scientific ideas and concepts must stand or fall on their own merits, based on existing knowledge and on evidence. • pseudoscience: often based on ancient authority; high priests and priestesses

  23. Appeals to our needs and desires? • science: may or may not • pseudoscience: yes

More Related