360 likes | 376 Views
Explore the background, clinical features, prevalence, inheritance, and molecular genetics of Huntington's disease, differential diagnoses, George Huntington's legacy, and the challenges and considerations of predictive and diagnostic genetic testing.
E N D
Neurogenetic disorders: Huntington’s Disease + British Neuropsychiatry Association Neurology & Psychiatry SpRs Teaching Weekend 12th - 14th December 2014 David Craufurd University of Manchester, Manchester Academic Health Sciences Centre and Central Manchester University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust Genetic Medicine, St. Mary’s Hospital, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9WL david.craufurd@manchester.ac.uk
George Huntington1850 - 1916 • born 9th April 1850 in East Hampton, Connecticut, USA • father and grandfather were doctors • graduated Columbia University 1871 • lecture ‘On Chorea’ presented 15th February 1872 (age 22) • published same year (Medical & Surgical Reporter of Philadelphia 1872; 26: 320-21) Source: Wellcome Trust Medical Photography
Huntington's diseaseclinical features • motor disorder (hyperkinetic and hypokinetic aspects) • cognitive impairment • behavioural (non-cognitive) symptoms
Huntington's diseaseprevalence • 10 /100,000 (12/100,000 adults) • 6000 affected in UK • HDA (England and Wales) in contact with about 6,000 affected individuals • 10 at risk (50% or 25%) for every 1 affected • adult onset (but 5% have JHD – onset <20 years)
Huntington’s diseaseinheritance • autosomal dominant inheritance (children of affected person have 50% risk) • delayed onset • expanded (CAG)n repeat mutation accounts for all cases
Huntington’s diseasemolecular genetics • gene localised to chromosome 4p by linkage analysis (1983) – the first autosomal gene to be mapped in this way • gene / mutation isolated in 1993 • contains (CAG)n triplet repeat mutation • number of repeats expanded (and unstable) on affected chromosome
Huntington’s Disease IT-15 or htt • Autosomal dominant • Monogenic • (CAG)n effect • Differential cell vulnerability • Natural History Short Arm of Chromosome 4 (4p16.3) • Ubiquitous expression • Spatial & Temporal • Unknown function • Embryonic lethal • Loss of function vs Gain of function (toxicity)
Huntington’s diseasetrinucleotide repeat mutation van Dellen & Hannan 2004
Differential diagnosis of HDother causes of chorea • post-streptococcal autoantibodies (Sydenham’s chorea) • SLE and related disorders • Wilson’s disease • cerebrovascular • DRPLA • dominant Spino-cerebellar ataxias (especially SCA17) • other rare inherited HD-like disorders
Differential diagnosis of HDother neurogenetic disorders resembling HD • Neuroacanthocytosis (CHAC) • areflexia, distal amyotrophy, oral and lingual chorea, may be tics, tongue biting • acanthocytes in blood, creatine kinase elevated • autosomal recessive • Benign hereditary chorea • slow progression, lack of cognitive or psychiatric changes • mutation in thyroid transcription factor 1 (TTF1) • McLeod syndrome • motor neuropathy, cardiomyopathy, anaemia • X-linked, mutation in Kell erythrocyte antigen (XK) gene
Differential diagnosis of HDother neurogenetic disorders resembling HD • Huntington Disease-like 1 (HDL1) • phenotype may be indestinguishable from HD • mutation in PRNP (prion) gene • Huntington Disease-like 2 (HDL2) • all cases to date have had black African ancestry • CAG/CTG repeat mutation in junctophilin-3 gene • Huntington Disease-like 3 (HDL3) • phenotype indestinguishable from HD • gene unknown
Differential diagnosis of HDother neurogenetic disorders resembling HD • Neurodegeneration with Brain Iron Accumulation (NBIA) • phenotype may be indestinguishable from HD • foci of hyperintensity in globus pallidus (eye of tiger sign) • mutations in pantothenate kinase (PANK2) gene • aka Hallervorden-Spatz syndrome • Neuroferritinopathy (NBIA2) • phenotype may be indestinguishable from HD (less symmetrical) • MRI T2 signal loss in basal ganglia, serum ferritin may be reduced • mutations in ferritin light chain (FTL) gene
Huntington’s diseaseproblems facing those at risk • childhood – behaviour of affected parent • fear of being affected • difficult to plan for future • reproduction: worry and guilt • parents: burden of care
Huntington’s diseasedisadvantages of predictive testing • emotional impact • self • family • discrimination • employment • insurance • long-term adjustment • hopelessness • suicide
Huntington’s disease protocol of UK Huntington’s prediction consortium • clinical genetic centres only • previous genetic counselling • two pre-test counselling sessions • results given in person • follow-up always offered Craufurd & Tyler, J. Med. Genet. 1992
Huntington's diseaseproblems associated with diagnostic genetic testing • requests for testing on presymptomatic individuals • testing when no FH or previous knowledge of HD • person tested is unaware of symptoms • pressure from relatives to test someone who is not yet ready for diagnosis • testing an at-risk person with possible features of HD (eg. psychotic symptoms) • results given by post or telephone • lack of follow-up
Huntington's diseasemotor abnormalities • hyperkinetic • chorea • dystonia • hypokinetic • bradykinesia (slowing of movement) • rigidity • clumsiness, impaired control • abnormalities of gait reduced mobility • loss of automatic motor routines fatigue • problems with speech and swallowing
Huntington's diseasemotor abnormalities • patients tend to be unaware of involuntary movements (especially in early stages) and less concerned about them than carers [Snowden et al., Archives of Neurology 1998; 55: 801-5] • treatment of chorea with tetrabenazine or neuroleptics tends to increase the hypokinetic disorder (also apathy and impairment of cognitive function) – risk of worsening functional disability • tetrabenazine and haloperidol are the only drugs licensed for treatment of chorea, but are probably the worst in this respect • sulpiride and tiapride (selective D2 and D3 antagonists) are best tolerated • olanzapine, risperidone, quetiapine are reasonable alternatives • amantadine has also been shown to reduce chorea in HD • pridopidine (Huntexil) (aka ACR16 / TV7820) may have a role in future
“In all the families, or nearly all in which the choreic taint exists, the nervous temperament greatly predominates, and….nervous excitement in a marked degree almost invariably attends upon every disease these people may suffer from…..The tendency to insanity, and sometimes that form of insanity which leads to suicide, is marked.” George Huntington (1872)
Huntington's diseasebehavioural aspects • behavioural symptoms are often more distressing than motor and cognitive components of HD, and have greater impact on Quality of Life for both patients and carers1 • psychiatric and cognitive variables had greater impact on Functional Capacity in TRACK-HD study2 (and thus viability of community care?) • respond to symptomatic treatments available now • Read et al. Journal of Huntington’s disease 2013; 2: 159-75. • Tabrizi et al. Lancet Neurol. 2013; 12: 637-49.
Huntington's diseasebehavioural aspects • mood changes • depression and suicide • anticipatory anxiety and tension • personality changes • irritability and aggressive outbursts • situational apathy • blunting of affect • obsessive-compulsive phenomena (especially perseveration) • psychotic symptoms • auditory hallucinations / delusions • sleep abnormalities • insomnia, day / night reversal • REM sleep behaviour disorder? • impaired insight
Huntington's disease depression in Maryland HD patients (N=186) • epidemiological survey (1st April 1980) • interviewed using DIS and DSM-III • major affective disorder 61/186 (33%) • dysthymic disorder 9/186 (5%) • population lifetime prevalence of major affective disorder in Baltimore (ECA study) was 4.3% • affective disorder preceded chorea and dementia by average of 5.1 years Folstein et al. (1987)
Major Depressive EpisodeDSM-IIIR diagnostic criteria • 5 or more of the following in same 2-week period (at least one must be low mood or anhedonia): • depressed mood most of the day, nearly every day • markedly diminished interest or pleasure in all, or almost all, activities • significant weight loss (when not dieting) or weight gain • insomnia or hypersomnia • psychomotor agitation or retardation • fatigue or loss of energy • feelings of worthlessness or excessive/inappropriate guilt • diminished ability to think or concentrate, or indecisiveness • recurrent thoughts of death, or suicidal ideation • symptoms are not due to substance abuse or a general medical condition
Lifetime prevalence of Major Affective disorder (DSM-III) and relationship to clinical onset in presymptomatic gene carriers requesting predictive testing (N=89 carriers, 115 non-carriers) Significant effect of closeness to clinical onset on prevalence of major affective disorder (χ² = 17.4, p< .01) and on subthreshold depressive symptoms (χ² = 10.8 , p < .05) Julien et al., JNNP2007; 78: 939-943
Huntington's diseasetreatment of depression • responds to conventional antidepressant medication • Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors (SSRIs) are first-line treatment (also useful for irritability) • higher doses may be necessary • tendency to relapse when treatment discontinued • Switch to venlafaxine or augment with mirtazapine if poor response • Monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs) e.g. moclobamide may work • avoid tricyclic antidepressants (except clomipramine) • may be a place for CBT in early stages • general psychological support is important
Huntington's diseasefactors influencing irritability and aggression • hunger • fatigue • frustration (e.g. clumsiness, communication) • cognitive overload • depression • impaired ability to defer gratification • inability to anticipate consequences • emotional blunting • loss of inhibitory input due to neurodegenerative changes in fronto-striatal circuits
Huntington's diseasetreatment of irritability and aggression • psychological measures (especially education of families and caregivers) • propranolol (usually 80mg twice daily) • SSRIs (high doses) • citalopram, escitalopram or sertraline (other SSRIs inhibit CYP2D6 – potential drug interaction with tetrabenazine) • caution using citalopram with other drugs which prolong QTc interval (e.g. sulpiride) • mood-stabilising antiepileptics e.g. carbamazepine, sodium valproate, lamotragine, pregabilin • neuroleptics e.g. sulpiride, tiapride (last resort)
Mean PBA score (factor 1) by duration Craufurd et al., Neuropsychiat Neuropsychol Behav Neurol, 2001
Mean PBA score (factor 2) by duration Craufurd et al., Neuropsychiat Neuropsychol Behav Neurol, 2001
Mean PBA score (factor 3) by duration Craufurd et al., Neuropsychiat Neuropsychol Behav Neurol, 2001
Huntington's diseasedo we misdiagnose apathy as depression? • research diagnostic criteria for depression rely heavily on loss of motivation and vegetative symptoms • apathy is a common feature of many other neuropsychiatric disorders e.g. Alzheimers disease, Parkinson’s disease, stroke and acquired brain injury as well as HD • apathy is more common than mood changes in HD patients and there is evidence to suggest a different aetiology • clinical experience suggests that antidepressants improve low mood and irritability, but not apathy, in HD patients
Huntington's diseasetreatment of apathy • education of patient and family • psychological measures – structured environment (day care, exercise, etc.) • no established pharmacological treatments • try to avoid unnecessary or excessive use of dopamine blocking / depleting drugs (i.e. neuroleptics, tetrabenazine) • clinical trial of bupropion in progress (ACTION-HD)