1 / 34

Markets, Organizations and Accounting

Markets, Organizations and Accounting Shyam Sunder Yale University Contract View of Organizations Chester Barnard, Functions of the Executive , 1937 Organization as a set of contracts

paul2
Download Presentation

Markets, Organizations and Accounting

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Markets, Organizations and Accounting Shyam Sunder Yale University

  2. Contract View of Organizations • Chester Barnard, Functions of the Executive, 1937 • Organization as a set of contracts • Example: Business as a set of contracts among employees, shareholders, managers, customers, vendors, creditors, auditors, government, etc. • A synthesis of markets and organizations Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  3. Synthesis • Pick three broad themes • Classical • Stewardship • Market-based • Differences in the Assumptions • Differences in the Range of Phenomena Organized Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  4. Common Perspective • Accounting as a solution • Same Fundamental Problem in • kingdom • temple • medieval manor • farm • family-run grocery store • textile mill • bank • multinational corporation Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  5. Basic Identity of Organizations • Organizations collect, transform, and disburse resources in various markets • Some markets more developed now • Accounting depends on how developed the markets are • Organizations adapt to changing markets • Transnational corp. dominant today Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  6. Hatfield’s Insight • Substitution of small partnership for the individual trader changed bookkeeping • Then sub-division of ownership caused separation from control • Investment in fixed capital • Business as a continuum--Paciolo • Hatfield (1924) classified by managerial labor and capital markets • We add: classification by product markets Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  7. Classification of Organizations and Accounting • Organizations of various sizes and design coexist • Various forms of accounting to serve them coexist • Each accounting perspective uses an organizational form as a prototype • Use Hatfield’s key events as boundary lines • 1. Separation of ownership and control • 2. Dispersal of shareholdings Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  8. Classification by Market for Managers • Owner-managed organizations use bookkeeping form of accounting • Traditional double entry model • With development of managerial labor markets, ownership and control separate • Then they need stewardship accounting Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  9. Bookkeeping for Proprietorships • Bookkeeping serves proprietorships well • Assists memory • Establishes control • Establishes cause and effect relationship between resource flows (Double Entry: Ijiri, 1975) • Most organizations, and their accounting in this category Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  10. Classical Perspective • Economic activity by family groups, Yamey’s farmer • Counting sufficient initially • Complex forms--repeat trades, credit, recording, Communication • Track resources and obligations • Contracting parties are customers, suppliers, few employees • No shareholders, auditors, or managerial hierarchy • Paciolo as solution for traders Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  11. Stewardship Accounting for Professional Managers • Two or more levels of management hierarchy • Must solve the agency problem • Use managerial accounting techniques: budgeting, performance evaluation, compensation, cost analysis, transfer pricing, and decentralization • Includes bookkeeping, but goes beyond • Separation of ownership and control • Two or more levels of management must deal with independent interests Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  12. Dealing with Multiple Egos • Accountee and the accountor • Temples, king’s household, merchants or lords • Organizations differ from individuals • They must deal with the actions, thoughts, information and motives of more than one person • No single person has all the information • Everybody has a local monopoly on some information • Stewardship accounting addresses information asymmetry and diversity of interests Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  13. Managerial Accounting Tools • Planning, budgeting, Divisional performance evaluation, Managerial Performance evaluation, Compensation, Decentralization, Transfer pricing, Capital budgeting, Activity-based costing • Builds on bookkeeping • Aide-memoir function needed even with single layer of management • Hierarchies need additional features • Undeveloped in Pacioli Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  14. Bookkeeping, Managerial Accounting in Contract theory Managers’ work unobservable • No visible substance • Continuous operations • Complex environment • Manager’s contribution difficult to isolate, even after the passage of time • Compare the evaluation of • Captain of medieval trading ship • Manager of an auto factory Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  15. Ship Vs. Factory • Owner cannot observe manager’s actions in either case • Ship returns, goods sold, profit is known precisely • Captain’s contract function of profit • Auto plant is rarely liquidated • Difficult to know manager’s performance, even after years • How much wait for compensation • Managerial accounting uses budget to address this difficult problem Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  16. Role of Budgets • Budget is manager’s contract • Resources the manager is authorized to spend • Resources manager is expected to generate • Specified in terms of mutual observables • Financial as well as nonfinancial measures • Unobservable managerial effort not included • Stewardship accounting is the “engineering” of modern organizations Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  17. Classification by Market for Capital • Without market for capital, ownership is tightly held • Liquid capital market causes diffuse ownership • Difficulty of directing/monitoring professional managers • Gives rise to financial reporting form of accounting Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  18. Subdivision of ownership into small parts • Supervision of operations by small shareholders not feasible • Modern financial reporting designed to operate such organizations • In United States, the model developed in mid-nineteenth century • Railroads and public utilities needed large amounts of equity capital (Yamaji, 1992) • Publicly-held corporations, • A liquid stock market for trading their shares, • Accounting to sustain such organizations Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  19. Differences from bookkeeping and managerial accounting • Attention to market for capital • Homogenous, undifferentiated (Ijiri) • New Demands of Publicly-held corporation on Accounting • Investors are distant from operations • How to protect their interests • They put up resources up front • Vulnerable to nonperformance by other parties • Need assurance that others will make their promised contributions Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  20. Financial Reporting for Publicly-Held Firms • Investors pre-commit their capital, vulnerable to other’s nonperformance • Rely on rules and standards to defend shareholder interests • Rules limit managerial judgment, informativeness • Elimination of managerial discretion has both costs and benefits • Financial reporting implements contracts among strangers; bookkeeping, managerial accounting, handle acquaintances Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  21. Consequences of Market Mediation • Market-Mediated contracts push accounting towards rules and standards • Investors and analysts invest in alternative sources of information, reliance on financial reports reduced, not eliminated • Market price responsive to future prospect • Shift in emphasis from stock to flow variables • Market-based research made accountants sensitive to the alternative sources of information Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  22. Rules and Standards • U.S.:Interstate Commerce Commission • Federal Reserve Bank • New York Stock Exchange • Securities & Exchange Commission • American Institute of Certified Public Accountants • Financial Accounting Standards Board • Rules and standards limit exercise of judgment • Rigidity • Limits information managers can provide capital markets Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  23. Responsiveness to Prospects • Managers can try to smooth reports to prevent overreaction • But they can also smoothing in self-serving ways • Elimination of discretion is a double-edged sword • Managers reveal themselves by how they exercise discretion Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  24. Stock to Flow Variables • Shift in emphasis balance sheet income and cash flow statements • Markets for assets are imperfect • Historical book values can be poor indicators of the future earning power • But Projection of current earnings and cash flows into future also risky • Investors want to project sustainable earnings • Lengthy debates on isolation of non-recurring elements of income from the rest Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  25. Effects of Market Based Research • Sensitive to the alternative sources of information • With complex interaction among sources • Shares of most U.S. firms not traded, too small • Findings about large firms not generalizable • During for replacement of historical cost accounting during inflation • Market imperfections: historical cost yields more accurate estimates except under high inflation • Trade off: Precise values for trading vs. effectiveness of contracts Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  26. Other Consequences of Financial Reporting • Because of stock market, investors search for information • Many alternative sources of information • Shift in emphasis from balancesheet to income statement • Capital market places new demands and constraints on accounting Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  27. Financial Reporting • Suggestions for inflation adjustments to accounts during high inflation • Balancing benefits against the costs of errors in inflation accounting • Balancing value of accounting for security valuation versus contract enforcement • Most firms not publicly traded; do not use financial reporting model Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  28. Inclusiveness of Financial Accounting • All five functions of accounting • Measurement of resource inflows • Measurement of resource outflows • Reporting on contract fulfillment • Providing information to factor market • Providing common knowledge for contract renegotiation as public disclosure • Public disclosure is absent in bookkeeping and stewardship forms. Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  29. Classification by Markets for Products • Business organizations produce private goods (cars, clothes, furniture) • Have customers who can impose discipline on managers by withholding revenue • Many organizations produce public goods (security, clean air) • They have beneficiaries, not customers, who cannot impose discipline Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  30. Public Vs. Private Good Organizations • Different accounting and control systems needed for the two types of organizations • More power in product market causes managerial discipline to become weaker • Bureaucracy is a solution for such organizations Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  31. To Summarize • Organization as a set of contracts • People join alliances for gain • Accounting as a mechanism to help implement contracts • Various types of organizations depending on managerial, capital and product markets • Forms of accounting suited to each type of organization Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  32. Three Criteria for Classification • Three types of businesses: • Owner managed small businesses (bookkeeping) • Professionally managed businesses with closely-held ownership (stewardship) • Professionally managed businesses with diffused shareholdings (financial) • There are three basic accounting models • Stewardship model includes bookkeeping and financial reporting includes stewardship Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  33. Financial Reporting • The last category of organization, and the financial reporting model are a modern invention • All three forms of organizations, and their corresponding accounting model coexist today • Economic theory of organizations helps synthesize classical, stewardship, and market perspectives on accounting in a harmonious relationship with one another Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

  34. Thank You • The paper and the slides will be available at my web page: • http://www.som.yale.edu/faculty/sunder/research.html • or email to shyam.sunder@yale.edu Shyam Sunder, Markets, Organizations and Accounting

More Related