1 / 58

Objectives of Presentation

Emerging Technologies for the Treatment of Organic and Aqueous Waste Streams: International and U.S. Department of Energy Case Studies Dennis Kelley, Pacific Nuclear Solutions. Objectives of Presentation.

pilar
Download Presentation

Objectives of Presentation

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Emerging Technologies for the Treatment of Organic and Aqueous Waste Streams:International and U.S. Department of Energy Case StudiesDennis Kelley, Pacific Nuclear Solutions

  2. Objectives of Presentation • Examine several case studies that describe polymer solidification technology for use on complex liquid waste streams: • STMI-Areva, France • British Nuclear Group, Sellafield, U.K. • Cernavoda, Romania; Krsko, Slovenia & OPG Canada • Khlopin Radium Institute, St. Petersburg, Russia • China Institute of Atomic Energy, Beijing, China • U.S. DOE Rocky Flats, Colorado • U.S. DOE Mound, Ohio

  3. Nochar Polymer Technology • ABsorbent, mechanical process; not an ADsorbent material (surface collector) • Not an encapsulation technology • Minimal volumetric increase: 5% or less • No leaching / no liquid release • Solidification time: 1 hour to 48 hours depending on waste stream composition • Mechanical / chemical reaction; no heat build-up, no heat release • Polymers reduce the risk of fire; suppress vapor

  4. Polymer Technology • Stability of Solidification: Cobalt 60 gamma • 270 million rad on organic / acid waste • 90 million rad on organic waste – TBP • 75 million rad on aqueous waste – 14.2 pH • Helps to immobilizes heavy metals • Safe / simple process: mixing or no mixing, depends on composition of waste stream • Final product for short, intermediate or final storage / burial • Incineration: less than .02% ash • Combined with grout / cement for monolithic matrix possible

  5. Polymers • N910: styrene block co-polymer • styrene-ethylene/butylenes-styrene • N960: 100% cross linked, co-polymer of acrylamide

  6. France • Partner: STMI (Areva Group) • 2003, analyzed 20 year old tank waste • 4 phase complex organic / aqueous waste stream, with alcohol and solid material • Good characterization made testing easy • Polymer formulas created according to each phase • 2 : 1 bonding ratio for each phase • Encapsulation of polymer waste in cement

  7. France • Cementation tests – passed ANDRA requirement, but not cost effective • ANDRA does not accept sorbent (organic) materials • Incineration at Centraco • 2007 project at AREVA – Marcoule • Complex aqueous waste stream with low pH • 2010 project at AREVA SICN Veurey • DU, oils & solvents + low amount of water, classified as “liquid muds”

  8. U.K. Contacts • Sellafield • NNL, Workington • AWE, Aldermaston • UKAEA, Harwell • LLWR / NDA • Magnox stations, Berkeley • British Energy • AMEC • NSG Environmental

  9. United Kingdom - Sellafield • Oil immobilization program initiated by British Nuclear Group: 2006 • Waste oil, non-standard waste stream, treatment and disposal issues on site • Waste Characterization & Clearance group and PNS conducted 3 experimental campaigns • Small scale test program: 90+ oil types

  10. Experimental Methodology • Polymers: N910, N935, N960 • 1.5 : 1 ratio (liquid to polymer by weight) • Light mixing applied if “pooling” occurred on surface, due to quick solidification • Curing period: 24 – 48 hours • Polymers blended, depending on waste composition • Compositions unknown

  11. I024-A Sample at 24 Hours

  12. I048-A Sample at 24 Hours

  13. Oil Solidification at Different Ratios

  14. Results of Experiments:British Nuclear Group Analysis • Polymer systems proved effective in immobilization of waste oil into a solid product • No leaching of liquid on compression • Need to test for compatibility of polymers to waste and assess ratios on case by case basis • 2 : 1 ratio is optimum for economic and security reasons

  15. Cementation Test Program • UK Conditions for Acceptance for LLW disposal call for compressive strength minimum • Consider cement encapsulation of polymer solidification to be suitable for final disposal • Tests demonstrated oil solidification + grout can form a safe, non-compactable matrix suitable for final disposal

  16. U.S. Department of Energy’s Initiatives for Proliferation Prevention in Russia:Results of Radioactive Liquid Waste Treatment Project, Year 1 Y. Pokhitonov, V. Kamachev V.G. Khlopin Radium Institute, Russia D. Kelley Pacific Nuclear Solutions, USA

  17. Russia since 2002 • Partner: Khlopin Radium Institute, St. Petersburg • Over 60 tests conducted on complex liquid waste streams: Gatchyna and RADON – Sosnvoy Bor NPP • Sludge types from decontaminating solutions • Several forms of TBP from extraction facility for spent fuel reprocessing • Spent extractant solutions with heavy metal content

  18. Oil Sludge Nitric Acid with Plutonium

  19. Purpose of Project • Program sponsored by DOE to engage Russian weapons scientists in peaceful use of existing and newly developed technologies • DOE’s IPP program is a mechanism for U.S. private sector companies to enter Russian market: radwaste treatment • Introduce USA environmental technology to weapons sector and seek joint technologies • Investigate solutions for Russia & USA liquid radwaste problems resulting from Cold War • DOE compensates scientists to participate in program • Long-term, commercialize project, employ scientists

  20. Project Participants • Russia • Russian State Atomic Energy Corporation (ROSATOM) • VG Khlopin Radium Institute (project manager) • Seversk (SCC ), Zheleznogorsk (MCC), Ozersk (MAYAK), Gatchyna • 90+ participants, 68 weapons scientists • USA • Department of Energy (GIPP) • Argonne National Lab • Pacific Nuclear Solutions (project manager) • International Science & Technology Center (ISTC) • Project administrator, Moscow

  21. Experiments • Stability (Differential Thermal Analysis) • Irradiation • Gas generation • * Polymer solidification /capacity / evaporation • * Leaching / water contact • * Encapsulation in cement * Represents test data / results published in paper

  22. Differential Thermal Analysis Polymers: N910, N930, N960 Solidified samples with nitric acid and sodium nitrate possess high thermal stability

  23. Irradiation Tests / Results • Extensive irradiation testing conducted, required for ROSATOM certification • All high dose rates • Cobalt 60 gamma irradiator • One example: nitric / organic solution 30 rad per second 30 days = 77 M Rad + 73 days = 270 M Rad • Brittle, size reduction, no degradation / leaching • Conducted for gas generation tests

  24. Stability and Irradiation Cobalt 60, gamma installation, dose rate 3.9·10⁶ gray N960 polymer, HNO₃, 1M, after irradiation N910 polymer, oil + TBP, after irradiation

  25. Irradiation Tests

  26. Gas Generation Tests • Preliminary tests, more testing and analysis is required • Tests required to determine fire and explosion safety conditions • Tests carried out under static conditions in sealed glass ampoules • N960 polymer + nitric solution: no changes in the solidification and no gas release • N910 polymer + TBP / oil: variable results • Preliminary judgment: polymers are not gas generators

  27. Rate of gas release during irradiation of sample: N910 polymer + 50%-TBP / 50%-oil

  28. Solidified sample after addition of waterSolution: HNO₃ 1,0M No volumetric increase

  29. Polymer Solidification/ Capacity / Evaporation: Conclusions • Polymer technology is irreversible, liquid permanently immobilized in polymer matrix • Advantage: direct application of polymer to waste without conditioning / additives • Little or no volumetric increase in the process • Appreciable volume reduction through evaporation; no measurement of water vapor • Polymers slow evaporation process • Polymers are versatile, solidify aqueous / organic waste of varying acidities, specific activities, suspensions and sludge types & salts

  30. Chemical Stability – Leach Test • Various leach tests conducted • samples with cesium and water contact • samples mixed with cement • Aqueous polymer has capacity limits, water contact will cause leaching • Cementation may be required by regulators • Cementation tests not conducted properly; precise bonding ratios are necessary • Results: • Immediate contact with water after solidification caused leaching • Better results when sample had aged 1 month

  31. Encapsulation of Polymer Solidification • Cementation tests at AREVA & Sellafield successfully completed, with 90% organic / 10% aqueous streams • When aqueous is above 10%, new technique for encapsulation is required • Encapsulation research underway: • additives to solidification • additives to cement • tests with inorganic materials encouraging

  32. Applications • Waste in above ground & underground tanks • Small containers / drums / self-contained generator (Yttrium -90) • Direct application to closed vessels to prevent leakage • Emergency spills at NPPs • Decommissioning sites, legacy waste

  33. Markets • Weapons production sites • Nuclear power plants • Submarine decommissioning • Toxic chemical industrial complexes • Research institutes • Uranium mining • Medical waste • Land & water remediation projects

  34. Year 2: Work Plan • Polymer certification • Required to import & sell polymer in Russia • Licenses required for health / safety, fire / explosion, irradiation / stability • Final certification issued by ROSATOM • Commence sub-site test work • Active solutions • Problematic waste streams • Continuation of experiments

  35. Cernavoda, Romania • Cernavoda NPP approval – 2005 • CNCAN approval – early, 2007 • Waste streams to be solidified: • mineral oil with tritium / cesium, 200+ drums completed • machine oil with tritium • scintillation fluid • Interim storage on-site (20+ years), plan to incinerate at Studsvik, Sweden

  36. Krsko, Slovenia • First Nochar user in Europe, 2002 • Oil with tritium / solvents • Waste transported to Studsvik Nuclear, Sweden for incineration • Incineration with excellent results • Safety booms in power plant for emergency spills

  37. Ontario Power Generation - Canada • 2010 test program • FRF, Fire Resistant fluid for turbine governing system • Paint, latex (used N930) • Glycol (used N935) • Kodak developer (used N960) • Solvents, machine oil

  38. China • China Institute of Atomic Energy, Beijing • Test program 2004-2005 • Formal paper published • Waste treatment regulations to be changed • Repository conditions, similar as WIPP-DOE, desert conditions • 1st large scale project underway

  39. Waste Streams • Six simulant waste streams tested: • Tri-butyl phosphate: 30% TBP / 70% kerosene • Acidic (nitric) solution: less than 0 pH • Alkaline solution: more than 14 pH • Ion exchange resin: anion to cation – 2:1 • Sodium type-beads, chlorine type-beads & 50% water • Vacuum pump oil • Scintillation fluid

  40. Solidification of TBP/OK

  41. 1:1 Ratio after 6 weeks 3:1 Ratio after 6 weeks

  42. Sodium Cation Exchange Resin Solidification

  43. Irradiation Tests • Objectives of irradiation tests of solidified waste streams: • Evaluate degradation of waste form and polymers • Leaching • Durability • Waste sealed in individual ampoules • Cobalt-60, gamma source irradiator • Dose rate: 28 rad per second / 70 million rad • All samples exposed to same dose rate • Loose polymers also irradiated at same dose rate

  44. Irradiation of Vacuum Pump Oil70 Million Rad

  45. IR Spectra-graph Tests/Results • Objective: check for degradation of polymers resulting from irradiation • 100,000 rad for 100 hours = 10,000,000 rad • Conclusion: Little or no degradation of polymer

  46. IR Spectra-graph of N910 Red represents after irradiation Blue represents before irradiation

  47. IR Spectra-graph of N960 Red represents after irradiation Blue represents before irradiation

More Related