1 / 27

Seeking c ommon ground on carbon taxes

Seeking c ommon ground on carbon taxes. Yoram Bauman, Eric de Place, Ian Siadak Sightline Institute Nov 14, 2012. Carbon concentrations going up. Source: : http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/. Arrhenius (Swedish chemist), 1896.

porter
Download Presentation

Seeking c ommon ground on carbon taxes

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Seeking common groundon carbon taxes Yoram Bauman, Eric de Place, Ian Siadak Sightline Institute Nov 14, 2012

  2. Carbon concentrations going up Source:: http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/

  3. Arrhenius (Swedish chemist), 1896

  4. We can solve both problems with a carbon tax • A tax on the carbon content of fossil fuels • The tax will reduce carbon emissions... • ...and the revenue can be used to make our economy stronger and create jobs by funding public investment. • Transportation infrastructure is my focus today, but education/health also possible

  5. BC’s carbon tax: $30/ton CO2 • Revenue of over $1 billion per year • Impact on energy prices • Petroleum: ≈30¢ per gallon • Electricity from coal: ≈3¢ per kWh • Electricity from natural gas: ≈1.5¢ per kWh • (≈$1.50 per mmBTU/ mcf/ 10 therms)

  6. BC Emissions 2007-2010

  7. Revenue neutral $4,109 million Personal income tax cuts - Lowest provincial income tax up to $119,000 $935 $3,348 million $543 Low income tax credit - Family of 4 receives $300 annually • Business tax cuts • Lowest Corporate Tax rate of G7 countries by 2012 • No small business tax in 2012 $2,631 *Projected total revenue and reductions for fiscal 2011/12 through 2013/14 Carbon tax revenues* Tax reductions

  8. Benefits for British Columbia’s economy and environment • Emissions have dropped both in absolute terms and relative to the rest of Canada • GDP grew faster than the rest of Canada (and faster than in the U.S.) • Reduced business and personal taxes to some of the lowest levels in Canada

  9. What would this look like here? • 85m tons of CO2, raising $2.3b per year • Could eliminate state property tax, nearly eliminate B&O, or cut sales tax by 1/3rd • And/or could boost public investment • Jim Sinclair, BC Federation of Labour: “If you're going to keep [the tax], then the money should be used for creating jobs and greening the environment” (including public transportation, housing retrofits).

  10. Transportation Option • Carbon tax as in BC • 50% for tax rebates as in BC, including targeted offsets for the manufacturing sector and for low-income households • 50% for public investment, focused on road maintenance, transit, freight mobility

  11. 50% public investment, 50% tax rebates ($2.3b total) 50% tax reductions 50% public investment

  12. Economic modeling • We contracted with PERI (out of U Mass – Amherst) • Used IMPLAN input-output model of Washington State • No small-grain detail to do industry-level analysis, so the results are preliminary.

  13. Economic modeling

  14. Economic modeling • Result from IMPLAN: Net increase of 4,000 jobs, $385m in GDP • Underlying idea: Shifting consumption from fossil fuels to infrastructure can be good for jobs and economic growth • Caveat: This does not include detailed analysis of impacts on specific industries

  15. Economic modeling • Next step: industry-level analysis • Costs: $30/ton CO2 • Benefit: $650m for road maintenance • Benefit: $300m for freight mobility/transit • Benefit: $160m for eliminating B&O taxes for manufacturers • Benefit: $650m in property tax rebates

  16. Economic modeling • Next step: industry-level analysis • Costs: $30/ton CO2 • Benefit: $650m for road maintenance • Benefit: $300m for freight mobility/transit • Benefit: $160m for eliminating B&O taxes for manufacturers • Benefit: $650m in property tax rebates

  17. Common ground? • This could be a win-win, and that doesn’t happen all the time • We need to fund transportation infrastructure • We need to reduce carbon emissions

  18. Asks • Help us investigate whether this could be a win-win in specific industries • Help us craft a policy that will lead to good jobs in Washington • Yoram Bauman, Eric de Place, Ian Siadak • Contact us all via eric@sightline.org

More Related