1 / 31

Health Enhancement Curriculum – Info meeting

Health Enhancement Curriculum – Info meeting. Helena Youth Advocates Lewis & Clark Library June 30 th. Outline . Introduction – Who we are Overview of the proposed draft Main Concerns Things to Consider What you can do to help Questions Sign-ups for volunteers. Who We Are.

rance
Download Presentation

Health Enhancement Curriculum – Info meeting

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Health Enhancement Curriculum – Info meeting Helena Youth Advocates Lewis & Clark Library June 30th

  2. Outline • Introduction – Who we are • Overview of the proposed draft • Main Concerns • Things to Consider • What you can do to help • Questions • Sign-ups for volunteers

  3. Who We Are • A group of parents and concerned community members that agree that “this” curriculum is not the best for our children. • We wish for the board to vote “no” on the current proposal. • We want to see a thorough revision of the draft and want the process to include the input of many parents.

  4. Overview - Draft • A two year process • Committee members included: • Regular classroom teachers & physical education teachers • Health instructors • Law enforcement officials • Department of  Public Health and Human Services • Lewis and Clark Health Department liaisons • St. Peter’s Hospital representatives • administrators, parents and other community members

  5. http://www.helena.k12.mt.us/district/departme/curricul/curricul/healthen/index.dhtmhttp://www.helena.k12.mt.us/district/departme/curricul/curricul/healthen/index.dhtm

  6. Critical Competencies K-12 • Health Maintenance and Enhancement: • Personal Health and Preventative Care • Nutrition • Consumer Health and Safety • Life Management Skills • Functions and Interrelationship of Systems: • Structure and Functions of the Body • Social, Emotional and Mental Health • Human Sexuality • Risk Assessment and Reduction: • Disease Prevention and Control • Injury Prevention and Safety • Environmental Health http://www.helena.k12.mt.us/district/departme/curricul/curricul/healthen/index.dhtm

  7. Main Concerns

  8. Reproductive Health Section Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 36

  9. Reproductive Health Section Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 36

  10. Influence of Family & Peers & Society Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 38

  11. Influence of Family & Peers & Society Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 38

  12. Human Sexuality Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 46

  13. Influence of Family & Peers & Society Influence of Family & Peers & Society Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 39

  14. Influence of Family & Peers & Society Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 38

  15. Human Sexuality Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 45

  16. Human Sexuality Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 45

  17. Sexually Transmitted Infections Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 54

  18. Safe & Unsafe Substances Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 59

  19. Effects of Pollution on Health Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 61

  20. Harassment/Bullying/Refusal and Conflict Resolution Helena Public Schools Health Enhancement K-12 Critical Competencies – DRAFT, pg 23

  21. Things to Consider • This does not fit our own Montana Standards for Sex Education: • Ought to focus on “disease prevention” • “Public health supports a program that is age-appropriate, abstinence based, …” • “… [T]he program public health supports is designed to: (a) support youth who have not had sexual intercourse to continue to postpone the initiation of sexual intercourse, (b) help youth who have had sexual intercourse re-establish abstinence, and (c) present information on disease prevention methods for those unable or unwilling to refrain from sexual intercourse.” Montana Accreditation Standards for Health Enhancement, OPI: http://www.opi.mt.gov/pdf/HIVEd/HEStandardsSexEd.pdf

  22. Things to Consider • Montana Standards for Sex Education, cont. • “The content should explain the health reasons for refraining from sexual activity as well as the health consequences for engaging in sexual intercourse.”* • There is no mention of the psychological effects of teen sexual activity – depression, higher-drop out rates, etc. • “The content should reflect the values of the community”* • On the committee there was only one member listed as a non-district employee parent – we need more community parents involved in the committee process *Montana Accreditation Standards for Health Enhancement, OPI: http://www.opi.mt.gov/pdf/HIVEd/HEStandardsSexEd.pdf

  23. Things to Consider • Primary disease prevention focuses on avoiding exposure first: • We don’t teach children how to use drugs responsibly – we teach them to “just say ‘no’” – with STI rates so high, why should teen sex be considered differently? • This program discusses STIs transmitted by fluid to fluid contact, but does not explicitly mention skin to skin contact

  24. Things to Consider • In Montana (Dept. of HHS 2008): • 53% of all Chlamydia cases occurred in ages 15-24* • 63% of all Gonorrhea cases occurred in ages 15-24* • Lewis & Clark County has the 5th highest instances of Chlamydia in Montana* • With stats like these we need to have a serious and open discussion with parents about what approach is best for our kids and community. *Montana Department of Public Health and Human Services, Communicable Disease Stats and Facts, 2008: http://www.dphhs.mt.gov/PHSD/epidemiology/documents/AnnualReport2008FINAL_03_31_2010.pdf

  25. Things to Consider • Is this really the most up to date science? • February 2010: NY Times and CNN featured a study comparing “comprehensive” sex education to “abstinence” education • In a high risk population, abstinence education was proven to be more effective at delaying initiation of sexual intercourse (Efficacy of a Theory-Based Abstinence-Only Intervention Over 24 Months: http://www.asc.upenn.edu/assets/other/pressReleases/Jemmott%20abstience%20study%202010.pdf)

  26. Things to Consider • This curriculum seems to fully lack a conversation of the psychological effects of early sexual activity, especially for girls: • Early sexual activity has been shown to lead to depression in young girls (Which Comes first in Adolescence – Sex and Drugs of Depression?: http://download.journals.elsevierhealth.com/pdfs/journals/0749-3797/PIIS0749379705002138.pdf) • Less likely to go to college* • Less likely to be happy* • More likely to divorce* *The Harmful Effects of Early Sexual Activity and Multiple Sexual Partners Among Women: A Book of Charts. The Heritage Foundation. 2003

  27. Things to Consider • This still requires “professional development” • Do we really want approve something without knowing what it fully contains? Or who will be involved in this “development”? • “Universal values” are referred to, but never enumerated. Values are also said to “differ” amongst families, churches and communities. • Is this appropriate for the school to be teaching to young children? • Whose/what value system is being promoted as “universal”?

  28. Things to Consider • Is this age-appropriate material? • Does a Kindergartener really need to know the reproductive body parts? • Early introduction of sexual material contributes to the sexualization of young children. • Child focused prevention programs (K -3) have failed reduce instances of sexual abuse and have been shown to increase anxiety. (Berrick and Gilbert. With the Best Intentions: The Child Sexual Abuse Prevention Movement. New York: Guilford Press, 1991)

  29. What can I do to help? • Write the Superintendent and Board Members • Be RESPECTFUL! – you catch more bees with honey than vinegar • Be concise and to the point • Have supporting resources and facts • Share personal story if appropriate • Write the newspaper • Call into your local radio station and make comments

  30. What can I do to help? • Inform your PTA and teachers of what is in the draft • Encourage them to write the Superintendent and Board Members • Inform your friends • Encourage them to write the Superintendent and Board Members • Sign our online petition and encourage others to do so • Sign our hand-written petition • Help us gather signatures by going door to door

  31. Thank you!

More Related