1 / 78

CIPD Employment Law Seminar

CIPD Employment Law Seminar. 7 March 2013. Employment Update Legal Update Recent Cases Emilie Darwin & Kristine Scott. Collective Consultation. 100+ redundancies - 90 day consultation 6 April 2013 Reduce to 45 days consultation Acas non statutory code of practice. Tribunal Update.

ranit
Download Presentation

CIPD Employment Law Seminar

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. CIPDEmployment LawSeminar 7 March 2013

  2. Employment Update • Legal Update • Recent Cases Emilie Darwin & Kristine Scott

  3. Collective Consultation • 100+ redundancies - 90 day consultation • 6 April 2013 • Reduce to 45 days consultation • Acas non statutory code of practice

  4. Tribunal Update • Compensation cap now £74,200 • Week’s pay £450 • Proposed overall 12 month cap to unfair dismissal compensation • Issue fees in tribunal – July 2013

  5. End of Employment • Settlement Agreements • Guideline “tariffs” • Statutory code of practice

  6. Other legislative changes • Parental leave increases from 13 to 18 weeks • Draft subject access code of practice • Protection of Freedoms Act • DBS • Biometric

  7. On the Horizon • Proposed new system of shared leave • Fully flexible maternity/paternity leave • Time off for fathers at antenatal appointments • Proposed extension of flexible working

  8. Case Law Update Tayeh –v- Barchester Healthcare Ltd [2013] • Court of Appeal • Tribunal was not entitled to substitute own view of the seriousness of an employee’s misconduct

  9. Case Law Update Bray & Others –v- Monarch Personnel Refuelling [2012] • ET decision • Agency Workers Regulations 2010 • Pay between assignments complied with Swedish derogation provisions

  10. Case Law Update Davies –v- Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council [2013] • Court of Appeal • Legitimate to rely on final written warning where issued in good faith

  11. Case Law Update Eweida & Others –v- UK [2013] • European Court of Human Rights • 4 cases brought for UK breach of Article 9 of ECHR (right to manifest religious belief) • Upheld Ms Eweida’s claim that UK failed to protect her Article 9 right • Legitimacy and proportionality of uniform policy were key

  12. Case Law Update Eweida & Others –v- UK [2013] • Other 3 claims were unsuccessful • Mrs Chaplin was not allowed to wear her necklace on health and safety grounds • Mr McFarlane refusal to counsel homosexual couples • Ms Ladele refusal to officiate

  13. Case Law Update X –v- Mid Sussex CAB [2012] • Volunteer is not an employee for purposes of discrimination law • Is there a contract?

  14. Case Law Update Lloyd –v- BCQ [2012] • Dismissal of employee receiving PHI benefits • Wording of contract

  15. Holiday and Sick Pay NHS Leeds –v- Larner [2012] • Court of Appeal • Prevented from taking holiday during sickness absence

  16. Case Law Update Aderemi –v- London and South Eastern Railway [2012] • Definition of disability • Standing for long periods can be day to day activity • Focus on what employee cannot do

  17. Managing TUPE Tim Crane, Rachel Roberts and Oliver Daniels 7 March 2013

  18. Programme • General introduction to TUPE including: • What is TUPE? • What and who transfers? • When does TUPE apply? • TUPE process – information, consultation and ELI • Practical application of TUPE

  19. What is TUPE? • The Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006 • Acquired Rights Directive • TUPE protects employees in the event of a “relevant transfer”

  20. Aim of TUPE • To protect employees when the work they perform on behalf of one employer is transferred to another employer • Employees’ rights and liabilities transfer from one employer to another

  21. Effect of TUPE • Automatic transfer of employment • Continuity of employment preserved • Automatic unfair dismissal • Obligations to inform and consult

  22. Dismissals and TUPE • A dismissal will be automatically unfair if the sole or principal reason for the dismissal is: • the transfer itself; or • A reason connected with the transfer which is not an ‘ETO reason’ • ‘ETO reason’ means “an economic, technical or organisational reason entailing changes in the workforce”

  23. Fair or unfair dismissal? • Dismissals in a TUPE context generally fall into one of three categories: • Automatically unfair – dismissal due to transfer or for a reason connected with it and no ETO reason; • Potentially fair - dismissal for a reason connected with the transfer but with an ETO reason; • Potentially fair – dismissal is for a reason not related to the transfer at all • Affected employees still require the qualifying period of service of one year (or 2 years from 6 April 2012)

  24. Constructive Dismissal? • Regulation 4(9) – where a relevant transfer involves or will involve: • a substantial change in working conditions • to the material detriment of a transferring employee • that employee may treat the contract as having been terminated • and shall be treated as having been dismissed.

  25. Definition of a TUPE transfer • TUPE defines two types of transfer: • Classic Business Transfer: the transfer of a business or part of a business from one owner to another; and • a Service Provision Change (“SPC”)

  26. Classic Business Transfer • Classic Business Transfer: the transfer of an undertaking or part of an undertaking where there is a transfer of an economic entity which retains its identity; • Economic entity: “An organised grouping of resources which has the objective of pursuing an economic activity, whether or not that activity is central or ancillary”

  27. What is an economic entity? • Business sales/ purchases: assets, goodwill, employees, premises etc • Sales of the freehold of a property • Transfer of a lease • Change in a franchise • But NOT sale of shares in a company

  28. Retention of Identity • Relevant factors include: • Type of undertaking; • Whether tangible assets transfer; • Value of intangible assets; • Whether majority of employees are taken on; • Whether customers are transferred; • Degree of similarity between activities; • Period, if any, for which activities suspended

  29. Service Provision Change • Activities cease to be carried out by a principal on its own behalf and are carried out instead by a contractor (outsourcing); or • Activities cease to be carried out by a contractor on the principal’s behalf and are carried out instead by a subsequent contractor (second-generation transfer); or • Activities cease to be carried out by a contractor or a subsequent contractor on a principal’s behalf and are carried out instead by the principal (in-sourcing)

  30. SPC conditions • Immediately before the SPC there must be “an organised grouping of employees … which has as its principal purpose the carrying out of the activities concerned on behalf of the client”; • The relevant activities will be carried out after the transfer other than in connection with a single specific event or task of short-term duration; • The activities do not consist wholly or mainly of the supply of goods for the client’s use

  31. What transfers? • Virtually everything • Regulation 4(1): “…any such contract shall have effect after the transfer as if originally made between the person so employed and the transferee” • Transferee ‘steps into the shoes’ of transferor

  32. What transfers? • All existing rights, duties, liabilities and obligations • Includes benefits – holiday pay, sick pay, medical and permanent health insurance, company car, bonus, commission, notice, garden leave etc • Includes terms incorporated under collective agreements • Accrued liabilities and outstanding claims – e.g. equal pay, discrimination, constructive dismissal claims etc

  33. What doesn’t transfer? • Pensions exception; • rights under occupational schemes excepted • employee contributions matched to 6% of basic pay • Insolvency exception (regulation 8) • Criminal liability for transferor’s actions (e.g. for breach of health and safety legislation); • Terms that cannot be replicated • e.g. profit share, share option schemes, staff discount; • “scheme of substantial equivalence”

  34. The process • What must employers tell staff? • When you are required to tell staff? • Who is entitled to information and when? • Election of representatives • Penalties for non-compliance AND • Employee liability information (ELI)

  35. What must employers tell staff? • The fact of proposed transfer and the reason for it • When the transfer will occur • Any legal, economic and social implications • Any action that the employer envisages it will take (or if no measures are envisaged that fact) • Outgoing employer must also inform of measures the new employer envisages

  36. When will consultation be required? • Consultation required if “measures” are envisaged • With a view to seeking agreement to the measures • Responsibility of the employer of the affected employees • “envisages” means definite plans or proposals which would not have happened but for the transfer; not mere hopes or possibilities • No need actually to reach agreement

  37. What are “measures”? • “Any action, step or arrangement” affecting employees: • changes to T&Cs and within T&Cs • redundancies • reporting line changes • reorganisations • relocations • pension changes • salary payment dates

  38. Who is entitled to information and when? • Information in written form to “the appropriate representatives of any affected employees” • “affected employees” means: • any transferring employee • any other employee of the transferor or the transferee who may be affected by the transfer or by measures taken in connection with it • When? Long enough before the transfer to enable old employer to inform and consult in good time

  39. Who are the appropriate representatives? • Representatives of a recognised trade union; or • Where there is no trade union recognition “Employee representatives” who are either; • Existing employee representatives who; • were appointed or elected previously for other purposes AND • have appropriate authority to be informed/consulted in the context of TUPE • To inform/consult employee representatives elected specifically for the purposes of TUPE 2.

  40. Election of employee representatives The employer must; • Take reasonably practical steps to ensure election is fair; • Determine the number of elected representatives sufficient to represent the interests of all the affected employees; • Determine whether the representatives should represent all affected employees or particular classes of those employees;

  41. Election of employee representatives • Ensure candidates are themselves affected employees on the date of the election; • Ensure no affected employee is unreasonably excluded from standing for election; • Ensure votes are secret and accurately counted; • Ensure all affected employees are entitled to vote

  42. Roles of representatives • Similar to collective redundancies • Conduit for information and views • Need (and have a right to) access to affected employees • Facilities and accommodation to do their role. • Legal protection (time off and no detriment)

  43. No election? Where the employer invites affected employees to elect representatives BUT employees fail to do so within a reasonable time: • The employer must give to EACH and EVERY affected employee the relevant information concerning the transfer; • There is no duty to consult (but will in practice)

  44. “Special Circumstances” defence • Allows the employer to circumvent its obligations to inform and consult where it is not reasonably practicable for the employer to comply. • Very limited application.

  45. Penalties for non-compliance • Complaint to Employment Tribunal • Time limit: 3 months from transfer date • “Appropriate compensation” – punitive rather than compensatory • Protective award: up to 13 weeks’ pay for each affected employee • New employer is jointly and severally liable with former employer

  46. Employee Liability Information (1) • Regulation 11 – statutory due diligence • identity and age of all transferring employees • information contained within section 1 statement (pay, hours, holiday, sickness, notice, job title etc) • disciplinary and grievance proceedings • legal action • collective agreements

  47. Employee Liability Information (2) • In writing / readily accessible form • Not less than 14 days before the transfer date • Ongoing duty on former employer to notify new employer of any interim changes • Compensation for failure to comply • Minimum award ordinarily of £500 per employee

  48. TUPE in practice

  49. Ratatouille • Jean-François is the owner of Ratatouille and Cassoulet, a pair of high class French restaurants. • He is approached by Claude, who agrees to purchase the lease, assets and goodwill of Ratatouille. • Will this sale amount to a TUPE transfer? • What sort of transfer?

  50. Spic ‘n’ Span • Sushi and Sushi, a top London advertising agency, is dissatisfied with its office cleaners, Spic ‘n’ Span. • They are dissatisfied at the standard of cleaning and there has been a recent spate of items going missing from the office. • Sushi and Sushi decides to terminate the cleaning contract and engage an alternative contractor. • Will this trigger a TUPE transfer?

More Related