1 / 73

Organizational Communication

Organizational Communication. Dr. John Morrison. Chapter 1. The Challenge of Organization Communication. Defined. Organization: Social collective (group) Coordinated activities Structure Organizational environment Communication Continuous process Transactional Symbolic. Communication.

step
Download Presentation

Organizational Communication

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Organizational Communication Dr. John Morrison

  2. Chapter 1 The Challenge of Organization Communication

  3. Defined • Organization: • Social collective (group) • Coordinated activities • Structure • Organizational environment • Communication • Continuous process • Transactional • Symbolic

  4. Communication • “Continuous, transactional process involving participants who occupy different but overlapping environments and create relationships through the exchange of messages, which are affected by external, psychological and physiological noise”

  5. We Examine: • Foundational approaches: • Classical, human relations, human resources • These are prescriptive • How organizations should run • Not descriptive: how they do run • Not explanatory: what makes them work (or not) • Based in other disciplines (sociology, psychology, management, economics, etc.) • Didn’t originally consider communication

  6. We Also Examine: • Contemporary approaches: • Systems, cultural, critical approaches • These include description, prescription, explanation, and critique • We examine organizational processes • Assimilation, decision-making, conflict management, change and leadership, emotion, diversity, technology and more

  7. Organizational Communication • How does the organization affect the communication process? • How does the communication process affect the organization? • How does your organization react (poor) or anticipate (better) to important national and international issues? • Globalization and outsourcing • Terrorism • Climate change issues • Changing demographics and social initiatives

  8. Chapter 2 Classical Approaches

  9. Classical Approaches • Machine metaphor • Specialization • Standardization • Replaceability • Predictability • Like a machine, if an organization is not functioning properly… • Some rule or standard has been misapplied

  10. Henry Fayol (1841-1925)Classical Organization • Father of Modern Operational-Management Theory • Elements of Management: • Planning: best way to achieve goals • Organizing: arrangement/evaluation of human resources • Command: task assignment • Coordination: the blending of the various organizational parts into a cohesive whole • Control: comparing goals to activities and adjusting

  11. Henry Fayol • Principles of Management • Organizational structure: • Scalar chain: vertical hierarchy of communication and command • Unity of command: individual employee should receive orders from a single supervisor • Unity of direction: activities with similar goals require same supervisor • Division of labor: limited, specialized tasks • Order: specific place for each task and employee • Span of control: each supervisor should have a limited number of employees

  12. Henry Fayol • Principles of Organizational Power • Centralization of management and decision-making • Authority and responsibility: power from the position and personal characteristics • Discipline: all members should be obedient

  13. Henry Fayol • Principles of Organizational Reward • Remuneration of Personnel • Appropriate salary and benefits (primary motivation) • Equity: treat all justly • Tenure stability: employees require guaranteed job time to achieve maximum productivity and maintain loyalty (although too much is counterproductive)

  14. Henry Fayol • Principles of Organizational Attitude • Subordination of individual interests to general interests • Organizational goals must come first • Initiative: supervisors should value and direct employee efforts in support of the organization • Esprit de corps: no dissension in the ranks

  15. Henry Fayol (summary) • Elements of Fayol’s classical organization: • Highly structured • Hierarchical • Functional divisions • Vertical communication only • Except for limited horizontal (Fayol’s Bridge) for those at the same level • Prescriptive

  16. Max Weber’s (1864-1920) Theory of Bureaucracy • Six features of the “ideal” organization • Three features similar to Fayol: • Clearly defined hierarchy • Division of labor • Centralization of decision-making • Three features unique to Weber • Bureaucracies should be closed systems • Ignore outside influences (like a machine) • Importance of codified rules • Rule for every possible contingency • Functioning of authority • Three types

  17. Weber • Three types of authority: • Traditional (legitimate) • Based on the title/position • Charismatic • Based on personality, communication • Unstable • Rational-legal (must dominate) • Expertise/rationality/norms/rules • Basis of bureaucratic functioning • Impersonal

  18. Weber • In sum: • Similar to Fayol, but he describes an “ideal” organization as a closed system with focus on rationality as the driving force • Individuality is discouraged • Highly impersonal • Dominate through knowledge

  19. Groupthink Groupthink When group cohesiveness rises to the point where consensus becomes/replaces the group’s goal(s)

  20. Frederick Taylor (1856-1915) • Like Fayol (prescriptive), but concerned with the micro-level of organizational functioning • Emphasis on relationship between manager and employee and control of the individual worker, not organizational structure • Developed the Theory of Scientific Management

  21. Taylor’s Theory of Scientific Management • Taylor rejected: • Apprenticeship as the primary training method • Unreliable • Led to uneven work • Piecework as the typical reward system • Salary based on quantity of work • Led to “rate busters,” which reduced pay per piece • Motivation was to keep productivity low, so rates would stay high (systematic soldiering)

  22. Taylor’s Tenets • One best way to do every job • Time and motion studies • E.g. 21 ½ lb. shovel • Piece work could be adapted to results • Proper selection of employee to task • No suitable task: fire the worker • Reduces systematic soldiering (breaks the groups) • Training determined by “best way” studies • Inherent differences between management and workers • Strict division of labor

  23. Communication in “the Machine” • Content: mostly task • Innovation? • Direction: mostly vertical and downward • Advantages/disadvantages? • Is horizontal needed? When? • Mode: mostly written • Advantages/disadvantages? • Style: mostly formal • Titles, standardized terms, attire, environment

  24. Classical Management • Fast food example • Other examples? • When might classical management be the most appropriate choice? • Least appropriate?

  25. Chapter 3a Human Relations Theories

  26. David McClelland : Achievement Motivation • Achievement is a distinct human motive/need • Some have a high need, some a low need • Set high, but attainable goals • “Peg throwing” example • Like the “overload principle” • Avoid very low risk and very high risk • Achievement trumps rewards • Greater concern for performance feedback than for affective feedback • “How am I doing?” versus “do you like me?”

  27. Human Relations Approach • Hawthorne Effect • From the Hawthorne Studies (1924-32) • Effects of lighting, temperature, breaks, hours, incentives, and other changes on productivity • Mayo’s work at Western Electric’s Hawthorne plant • Did it work? • What are the conclusions? • Social and emotional needs are more important • Are the findings valid?

  28. Hawthorne Studies • So, why are the Hawthorne studies important? • They began the study of social variables on organizational functioning • Role of informal and group communication became something to consider

  29. Human Relations Theories • Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs (1943) • Self-transcendence: introduced late in his life • Level 5: Self Actualization: self expression and personal growth, need to fulfill one’s potential • Level 4: Esteem: rewarding work (internal) and bonus compensation and public recognition (external) • Level 3: Affiliation: social relationships and needs • Level 2: Safety: , shelter, safe working conditions, etc. • Level 1: Physiological: wages (food, clothes, etc.

  30. Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs • General theory of motivation • Hierarchy of prepotency • Limited empirical support (but some) • Examples in the college environment?

  31. Herzberg’s Motivation Hygiene Theory • AKA the “Two-Factor Theory” • The causes of organizational satisfaction and dissatisfaction are separate • i.e. dissatisfaction is not the opposite of satisfaction • Motivation factors: • Variables related to satisfaction • Hygiene factors: • Variables related to dissatisfaction

  32. Motivation Factors • Motivators: • Challenging work, recognition, achievement, responsibility, opportunities for personal growth, etc. • Presence or absence does not affect dissatisfaction, but satisfaction level is dependent on them • Inherent parameters of the specific job • Like Maslow’s high levels

  33. Hygiene factors • Hygiene factors • Status, job security, salary, supervisory methods and policies, benefits and wages, etc. • Presence or absence does not affect satisfaction, but dissatisfaction results from their absence • External to the specific job • Like Maslow’s lower levels • Empirical support for theory is minimal • Except that recognition and achievement are motivating

  34. Dealing with Deviant Members • Not all deviant behaviors have negative effects. When unmanageable: • Accept: live with it. (not the same as approval) • When member’s positives outweigh the negatives • When deviation isn’t critical to success • Confront: • Attention to behavior may alleviate the situation • Exclude: last resort only • Ignore, exclude, reject, remove • Consider assigning solo or unimportant tasks

  35. McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y • Theory (1960) of two distinct attitudes toward organizational motivation and functioning • Theory X: the average worker is lazy, lacks ambition, dislikes responsibility, is selfish, gullible, and not intelligent • McGregor asserts these preconceptions are incorrect. He suggests a different set of managerial assumptions called Theory Y

  36. McGregor’s Theory X and Theory • Theory Y • Work is a natural desire • Workers are generally self-disciplined, so harsh control is not needed • Workers seek opportunities to enhance self-actualization, which is in harmony with fulfillment of organizational goals • Workers enjoy responsibility • Workers employ imagination and creativity in solving organizational challenges

  37. Schutz’s Theory of Interpersonal Behavior • FIRO: Fundamental Interpersonal Relationship Orientation • We join groups to fulfill needs: • Inclusion: need to belong • Control: need to feel influential • Affection: need to feel that others like us

  38. Communication in “the Machine” • Content: task and maintenance communication • Communication that maintains relationships • Direction: vertical and horizontal • Advantages/disadvantages? • Mode: focus on face-to-face • Channels with high social presence, less reliance on written • Advantages/disadvantages? • Style: relatively informal • Less reliance on titles, more conversational language, less formal attire, less sterile environment

  39. Expectancy Violations Theory JudeeBurgoon

  40. Expectancy Violations Theory • Personal space is governed by our cultural norms and individual preferences. • “Proxemics” • Sometimes, it’s effective to break the rules regarding space and other nonverbal behavior • Facial expressions, eye contact, touch, posture etc.

  41. Expectancy Violations Theory • Practical: • If we are likely to be viewed as “rewarding,” consider minor deviations from nonverbal expectations • If we are likely to be viewed as nonrewarding, do not deviate from nonverbal expectations • However, accurate diagnosis is difficult

  42. Chapter 3b Human Resources

  43. Human Resources • Continuation of classical and human relations approaches • In addition, it recognizes the potential value of the ideas and unique contributions of organizational members • More than just physical labor (classical) • More than just physical labor and feelings (human relations)

  44. Human Resources • No single significant event triggered the movement • General dissatisfaction with existing models • Distrust of human relations applications • Lack of empirical support for human relations

  45. Human Resources • Human Relations movement suggests: • Work factors ---- satisfaction of higher order needs ---- job satisfaction ----- productivity • However, no empirical support for the connection between satisfaction and productivity • Does “being satisfied” at work result in increased productivity?

  46. Gestalt • More meaning exists than the parts alone can account for • Example • Groups can (but not necessarily do) have unique qualities not present or knowable via analysis of the members

  47. Human Resources • Human Relations approach examples: • Give people a voice to satisfy needs • Assign titles to individuals to satisfy needs • Reward individuals to satisfy needs • Human Resources approach examples: • Give them a voice because they often have valuable information and ideas • Assign increasing responsibility based on performance and initiative • Reward those that excel

  48. Human Resources • Blake and Mouton’s Managerial Grid (Leadership Grid) • Tool for training leadership styles to enhance efficiency , employee satisfaction, creativity • Balancing two dimensions: concern for people, concern for production

  49. Source: http://www.stewart-associates.co.uk

  50. Human Resources • Ouchi’s Theory Z • Based on Japanese management principles and assumptions • Long-term employment • Slow evaluation and promotion • Nonspecialized career paths • Implicit control • Collective decision-making and responsibility • Holistic concern • While impractical to fully implement, he suggests partial integration of these characteristics

More Related