1 / 16

Strategic Asset allocation

Strategic Asset allocation . MFIN5600 institutional wealth management. overview. Define objectives and constraints Form capital market expectations (CPPIB – Economic and Financial Market Forecasts group) U se as inputs to strategic asset allocation

tarmon
Download Presentation

Strategic Asset allocation

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Strategic Asset allocation MFIN5600 institutional wealth management

  2. overview • Define objectives and constraints • Form capital market expectations (CPPIB – Economic and Financial Market Forecasts group) • Use as inputs to strategic asset allocation • Outcome: a set of portfolio weights assigned to different asset classes, i.e. the “Reference” or “Policy” Portfolio

  3. Reference/policy portfolio Harvard Management company • “The Policy Portfolio is a theoretical portfolio allocated among asset classes in a mix that is judged to be most appropriate for Harvard University, from both the perspective of potential return and risk over the long term” • “(it will be) reviewed … for continued fit with the University’s risk profile and our projection of long-term market returns, volatility, and correlations” • “The Policy Portfolio (is) a guide …. to the actual allocation in the investment portfolio and also serves as a measuring stick against which we judge the success of our active investment management activities”

  4. Revisions to strategic asset allocation • How often should client revisit the allocaton? • Harvard Endowment Fund • Appears to be 8-10 years • But it is actually more often – 2012 policy portfolio slightly different from 2013’s (more real assets and fixed income in 2013’s) • Internal studies may be more frequent than actual outcomes (observed changes) • More dramatic changes for funds that were slow to move away from the 60/40 model

  5. Strategic asset allocation: history • Markowitz: mean-variance analysis • Minimize variance/standard deviation given a level of expected return • Do clients care about upside volatility? • Markowitz (1959) realizes that it is downside risk that matters to investors: semi-variance (SV) below mean or below target return • SV is a special case of the lower partial moment (2nd moment)

  6. history • But due to a lack of computer power at the time, Markowitz proceeded with  for his analysis • If return distribution is symmetric (i.e., normal), then the optimal allocation outcomes are the same • What if returns are not normally distributed? • Group project 1 • Use alternative measures of risk in the optimization and compare* • Can also include discussion of non-financial risks that should be monitored * In Morningstar Direct: Home  Training  Live session/videos/User Guides  Determine optimal allocation strategies

  7. Asset allocation and portfolio performance • Suppose portfolio returns can be attributed to the following three elements: • Strategic asset allocation • Market timing (tactical asset allocation) • Security selection (e.g., stock picking) • How important is the strategic asset allocation decision, out of the three?

  8. Importance of strategic asset allocation Empirical findings • Time-series studies (same fund over time) • Asset allocation explains 90%+ of the variations in portfolio returns on average • Brinson, Hood and Beebower (1986), Brinson, Singer and Beebower (1991), and Blake, Lehmann, and Timmermann (1999) • Interpretation: funds with similar asset allocation have similar returns over time

  9. Importance of strategic asset allocation • Cross-sectional studies (different balanced mutual funds within the same period) • Strategic asset allocation explains ~ 40% of the variations in portfolio returns • Ibbotson and Kaplan (2000) • Financial Crisis of 2008: Canadian pension plans had returns ranging from -25% to +6% (average: -18%) • What made the difference was the use of alternative strategies (recall comparison of Harvard’s portfolio to a 60/40 portfolio) • Overall, asset allocation is the most important factor in determining portfolio returns; the other factors (tactical and security selection) are secondary.

  10. Risk objectives in asset allocation • General description can be qualitative: Below average or above average risk tolerance • But in conducting strategic asset allocation, need to quantify risk attitude • For individual investor: numerical risk aversion score, measured through interview, questionnaire (see TD Mutual Funds example) • Recall the utility function: • Translate/map risk aversion score from questionnaire to an A for client, and compare the utility derived from different investments, given their and

  11. Risk objectives in asset allocation • Example: if A = 4 • Another way to quantify risk tolerance: specify an acceptable level of volatility (e.g.,  = 10%, thereby eliminating portfolio P above) • Downside risk: If investor is averse to loss (use a different risk metric) • Or if there is a target, then can consider shortfall risk, i.e., risk that return will fall below a certain percentage

  12. Additional measures of risk in asset allocation • Roy’s safety-first criterion (1952) • A simple shortfall risk measure for ranking portfolios where is the portfolio return, is the threshold level of return, and is the s.d.of • Sortino Ratio • Similar to Roy’s, but uses downside risk instead in the denominator: where DDP is downside deviation (standard deviation calculated using only returns below the target, RL)

  13. Return objectives • Quantitative return objectives are easier to define: specify return needed to achieve goals • Long-term investors care about compounded growth rate • Use geometric mean returns, rather than arithmetic mean returns • Example: • 10% return in first year, 8% in second year • If arithmetic: mean = ? • If geometric: mean = • One approximation of the relationship if distribution is normal:

  14. Specification of asset classes • What constitutes an asset class? • Assets within a class should be relatively homogeneous • Have similar attributes/features • Asset classes should be mutually exclusive • Global equities and U.S. equities • Asset classes should be diversifying • Correlation? • Asset classes as a group should comprise the majority of world investable wealth

  15. Global equities • Global versus international • Examples of global indices: MSCI All-Country World, FTSE Global Equity • Examples of international (developed market) indices: MSCI EAFE, FTSE Developed, MSCI World • When investing in foreign assets, investors should consider the following special issues: • Currency risk affects both return and volatility, and investors must decide whether to hedge • Increased correlations across countries in times of stress • Emerging markets are less liquid, less transparent and more likely to exhibit non-normal return distributions (but if markets are efficient, investors will receive compensation for bearing these risks)

  16. Inflation-sensitive assets • Assets that provide a good hedge against inflation • Gold, on average, maintains its value over time. If bought a dollar's worth of gold 200 years ago, after adjusting for inflation, it would be worth $1.07 in the fall of 2010 • CPPIB: In addition to real return bonds, also Infrastructure, real estate • OTPP: Also includes commodities • “We invest in commodities, which typically mirror short-term changes in inflation, as a hedge against the cost of paying inflation-protected pensions.”

More Related