1 / 22

Market Failure (?): Public Goods, Common Property & Externalities

Market Failure (?): Public Goods, Common Property & Externalities. Dr. D. Foster Microeconomics. When do markets fail?. When will even perfectly competitive markets fail to produce the allocatively efficient level of output?. Public goods Common property Positive externalities

Download Presentation

Market Failure (?): Public Goods, Common Property & Externalities

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Market Failure (?):Public Goods, Common Property & Externalities Dr. D. Foster Microeconomics

  2. When do markets fail? When will even perfectly competitive markets fail to produce the allocatively efficient level of output? • Public goods • Common property • Positive externalities • Negative externalities

  3. Public Goods Non-rival in consumption One person doesn’t use it up. Non-excludable Non-payers can’t be (easily) excluded. • For example: • National defense • Legal system • Lighthouses • TV and radio • Roads

  4. Public Goods Not all “publicly-provided” goods meet the test of being public goods. • For example: • Education • Trash collection • Social security • National parks . . . • Roads & lighthouses ! • The legal system ?!

  5. Public Goods Non-excludability problem leads to free riders. How do markets deal with this problem? • “Charge” differently - TV & radio ads • Find way to exclude - TV & cable/satellite • Tie-in sales - lighthouses - shopping malls - gated communities

  6. Graphical Analysis Price Price Price For private goods, the market demand is the horizontal summation of individual demands. Everyone pays the same price, consumes differing amounts $10 $10 $5 $5 MC $3 Quantity Quantity Quantity 15 25 40 Sally Tom The Market

  7. $ Graphical Analysis $15 $11 MC Everyone consumes the same amount, pays differing prices. Q 20 $ The Market $10 For public goods, the market demand is the vertical summation of individual demands. $8 Q 20 Sally $ $5 $3 Q 20 Tom

  8. Caveats Government provision may not be desirable: --The free rider problem is replaced with the forced rider. --Government may be inefficient, imposing higher costs such that we would be better off without this good/service!

  9. Common Property • Weak incentive to preserve/protect. • Weak incentive to maximize value. • Who owns common property? • Fish in the ocean This is another free rider problem.

  10. Supply P D1 D2 P1 Q - Fish Q1 Q2 Qmx Q* Common Property

  11. Common Property • What to do?-- Assign private property rights.-- Regulate use . . . -standards, -limits, -prohibit.

  12. Some observations • Elephants in Africa1970s - 1.2 million1980s - 600,000 2007 150,000

  13. S’ P S” S D Q Can markets really work?What about non-renewable resources? • Hotelling Principle:People treat exhaustible resources like any asset and want to max. value over time. The Simple Version - We can’t run out of . . .

  14. Positive Externalities • Some “consumers” benefit w/out paying.-- concert-- flower garden-- flu shot • What to do?-- Nothing.-- Subsidize producer/consumer - there is a cost to this!

  15. MSB Q2 Positive Externalities P S To promote allocatively efficient level of output, subsidize by the vertical distance. P1 D = MPB Q Q1

  16. Negative Externalities • Third parties bear part of the cost without receiving any of the benefit.-- In the case of pollution:the firm is facing zero-priced waste disposal. • How do we deal with this problem?-- Tax the producer/consumer. -- Set standards/quotas for pollution.-- Allow parties to negotiate.-- Sell pollution rights.

  17. Pollution - Tax & Standard MSC P Tax raises costs;  production. Quota on production would (might?) serve the same purpose. Standards for pollution would also raise costs and production. S = MPC P1 D = MPB Q Q2 Q1

  18. Pollution & The Coase Theorem • Assign property rights to the resource (!) • It doesn’t matter who gets the right . . .

  19. NO !!! Q* Is zero the “right” level of pollution? $ MC MB Quantity of pollution • Problems: Holdouts and Free Riders

  20. $1000 $ MC MB $400 Quantity of pollution 0 Qm Q* The Free Rider Problem • The firm owns the rights . . .

  21. $ MC $20,000 MB Quantity of pollution $2000 0 Qm Q* The Holdout Problem • The downstream users own the rights . . .

  22. Market Failure (?):Public Goods, Common Property & Externalities Dr. D. Foster Microeconomics

More Related