1 / 24

Piety & Practice

Piety & Practice. Religion and Religious Change in England, c.1470-1558. Inevitability: a Problem. Traditional accounts of the Reformation A.G. Dickens Caricature of late-medieval Church : Corrupt, only concerned with enrichment Poor levels of piety, inept priesthood.

zazu
Download Presentation

Piety & Practice

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Piety & Practice Religion and Religious Change in England, c.1470-1558

  2. Inevitability: a Problem • Traditional accounts of the Reformation • A.G. Dickens • Caricature of late-medieval Church : • Corrupt, only concerned with enrichment • Poor levels of piety, inept priesthood. • England’s anti-Catholic heritage. • Whig History legacy – England meant two things: • ‘Protestantism’ &‘Parliamentary sovereignity’ • Reformation beginning of both, HAD to happen! • Teleology • Beginning with the end and projecting backwards • Examining late-medieval Catholicism solely for evidence of ‘what came next’ skewers its reality • Edward Muir: historians’ obligation to ‘respect the dead, to honour how different they were from us rather than to celebrate their ability to anticipate us or our ability to surpass them’. • History for whom, and to what end?

  3. Revisionist historiography • Late medieval Church characterised by a religious culture which was: • Vibrant • vital • Evidence for this: • No evidence of a swelling tide of discontent • Laity investing in the Church – time, money, energy – more than ever before at the Reformation. • See the work of: • Christopher Haigh, Jack Scarisbrick, R.B. Manning, Ralph Houlbrooke, Robert Whiting, • Eamon Duffy • Essentially 2 thesis: • 1) How attached people were to the liturgy • 2) That liturgy was flexible enough to allow them to adapt the Church’s practices to a variety of activities, needs and spiritual requirements. • That Church was not ‘top down’, ‘institutionalised’ and ‘rigid’ • actually a marriage between clergy and laity – moulded to local/individual needs.

  4. Revisionists: a caveat • Focus on liturgy, practice and piety • What the laity do, how they do it, and to what extent. • What is missing? • Clergy? • Where are they in Duffy? • Surely pivotal to assess the role of them in this society? • And people’s views towards them? • Structure of the Church • An institution. • Did it conflict with other areas of this society? • Crown • Nobles • Social organisations?

  5. Religion: Now & Then NOW THEN Mandatory Public Shared Peter Marshall: ‘where faith met community’ Corporate souls, members of the body of Christ which had visible expression in local structures. • Voluntary • Private • Individual

  6. The ‘work’ of traditional religion • Biggest landowner in Europe • Major provider of charity incl. schools, hospitals • Monopolisers of orthodox access to the sacred – via the (seven) sacraments – in partic. Baptism, Eucharist and Extreme Unction (but also penance, the Orders, matrimony & confirmation) • Providers of afterlife ‘fire insurance’ (also for your kin) • Promoter of social cohesion/peace via ‘mechanisms’ of confession & communion • Providers of entertainment (e.g. Church Ales & election of Boy Bishops; May Queens)

  7. How do we know about the pre-modern world? CHURCH RECORDS Visual & material culture Art Sculpture Prints & book illustrations Investment/wealth The Church building itself Buildings Bodies Household goods • ‘Official’ records • Courts • Domestic disputes • Crimes against the Church/society • Wills • Tax records • Bede rolls • Churchwarden’s accounts • Registers of: • Birth • Marriage • Death

  8. What do Churchwarden’s accounts tell us? • Scale of investment in the Church • 2/3 of Church buildings in England re-furbished C15th/ early C16th • Pride • Lavish church with the material culture of religion • Cloths • Vestments • Chalices • Candles • Imagery • Carvings • How is this paid for? • Tithe • And from additional sources of revenue. • May include: • Sheep – sell wool pay for candles to saints • Church ales • Plays • Hock-tide • Key: • a communal religion, not separate from the world (like monastery) but shaped by it.

  9. Time: The ritual year • Cyclical time: • Liturgical calendar’s re-enactment of life of Christ: • Advent • Christmas • Epiphany • Easter • Ascension • Pentecost. • Agricultural rhythms of the year: • Carnival preceding Lent: • licensed sin and disorder. • Holy Week/Easter: • imaginative engagement with sufferings of Christ. • performative • Easter communion: individual and collective rite. • Community as ‘the body of Christ’. • Year end – Easter (not Christmas)

  10. Marking the seasons • February/March – Carnival vs Lent • March/April – Easter – time of annual confession followed by communion/eucharist • May: Ascension/Pentecost/Whitsun – rogation processions (Feast of Corpus Christi) • June:Feast of St John the Baptist – midsummer’s eve 24/6 • November – All Hallows/All Saints’ day 1/11 • November – Martinmas/St Martin’s day – 11/11 • November – Advent (30/11) – beginning of liturgical year (feast of St Andrew)

  11. saints • Different conception of sanctity: • Not just exemplar of holy living • Portal to the supernatural • Major part of the practice of religion • Veneration of images/ prayers/ candles • Localism: • Each parish a patron saint • Acted as a guardian • Saint’s Day & communal celebration/ definition • Beyond the parish: • Shrines & aspects of the landscape • Travel to see/touch relics • Pilgrimages • Receive and indulgence • Specialities • ‘Problem solving’? • Plague/ disease • Infant mortality • Death in childbirth • Capricious and precarious existence • Weather • Harvest • Mary – a special case? • Most intense cult • Why? • Vengeful God – role of caring, sympathetic protector open. • Example of meek submission to divine will • In the works of some theologians – notably Gabriel Biel – she is almost the co-redeemer of mankind.

  12. Pickering, Yorkshire St. Peter & Paul St. Sebastian

  13. Lay involvement • Fraternities • Voluntary associations of laymen • Usually a devotion to the host, the Trinity or the Virgin Mary. • 30,000 in LC15th. • Very high – almost improbable • Own patron saint and therefore own rounds of religious practices • Maintain own light/candles/chapel for patron • Own altars in church – richest support own priest to tend to their needs • Burial of members • Other forms of support – religious and non-religious. • Tensions • Complement or supplement ‘official’ religion • In competition with the Church? • Did it withdraw from the body? • Within and without the parish: • Needs and demands which may not have been for the village or parish as a whole • Members may come from other parishes. • Yearning? • Counter Reformation respond to Protestantism in Europe by extending confraternities.

  14. Sacramental Religion • Mediation • Clergy’s pivotal role in society: to assist people en route to salvation. • Not necessarily about belief in the modern sense • Remember verb vsnoun: Sacramental religion: • God’s grace channelled through particular ritual actions, material objects and sacred places. • Salvation: a problem. • Adam & Eve and Original Sin • God, in his mercy, offered the opportunity to be saved – salvation. • Saving work of Jesus Christ on the Cross – crucified for the sins of humanity – was mediated through the sacrificial and sacramental ministry by the priests of the Catholic Church. • The rituals and sacraments of Catholic Church was the route through which that opportunity could be realised. • No salvation outside of it. • Overly material? • Scholasticism • Role of God and humanity in the process • Catholics – rites of the Church afforded some leverage • Protestants – God alone decided • Sacraments a visible role in life of the average Christian • Punctuated their journey from cradle to grave: • Baptism • Confirmation • Confession • Marriage • The Mass • Extreme Unction

  15. The mass • Temporal centre of the world: • Collapse time • Sacrifice • Ritual re-enactment of the Last Supper • Transubstantiation: • Piety & pity • Efficacious: • See God • Not a singular practice: • Powerful – variety of uses: • Masses for the dead • Corpus Christi procession • Mysticism • Unofficial – curses • Bossy – ‘social institution’ • Marshall – ‘where faith met community’.

  16. St Gregory’s Mass

  17. Matthias Grunewald

  18. Corpus Christi Procession

  19. Does ‘communal’ = ‘uniform’ • Uniformity: • No space for individual to approach God? • Christian? • Keith Thomas, Religion & the Decline of Magic • Division of ‘elite’ and ‘popular’ religion. • Most ‘Christianity’ before the Reformation not ‘Christian’ in any meaningful sense. • Overstatement to see as semi-magical or solely ritual based • Religious books: • Handbooks for priests • Catechisms • Work through the basics before confession: • 10 Commandments • Seven deadly sins • Works of mercy • Five bodily senses • Asked parishioner how their behaviour accorded with • A move to education/ instrospection/ piety? • Eamon Duffy • ‘Popular’ & ‘Elite’? Or ‘traditional’?

  20. Books of hours • Primer of religious instruction/ text-book of essentials o faith • Poor Caitiff – didactic and devotional works • Dives and Pauper – systematic exposition of the Commandments • Prayers to meditate on – especially the Passion. • Thousands printed in the later-fifteenth century • Extensive readership by the standards of the time (if not our own). • Division of ‘popular’ and ‘elite’? • Peter Burke • 1500-1800: move to a divide between solemn ‘high’ and a vibrant ‘low’ culture • Social stratification determines cultural stratification • Access to culture • Ability to read • Duffy – ‘traditional’ • Shared/common culture • Oral and written not as demarcated as we would see it.

  21. Books of HOurs

  22. Books of Hours

  23. Divisions? • Were the gentry withdrawing? • Develop own chapels • Moves to build own pews in Church • Reading = withdrawl? • Group reading, not private. • Criticisms of the ‘material’ aspect of late medieval Christianity: • shrines/ pilgrimages criticised • Yearning, or debate? • Individual examples, rather than the system?

  24. Concluding thoughts • Vibrant and vital • Fulfil needs in many different facets of life • Clearly not waiting for Reformation • But were there fissures in the bedrock of this Church? • Was that vibrancy actually a weakness as much of a strength? • Ability to be pulled in lots of different ways – as communal as historians suggest? • Later lecture – see that early Protestantism had much to do with Reform movement within the Church • Perhaps ‘Ref’ not a juncture, but a continuation of what was already present.

More Related