1 / 40

Specification Writing

Specification Writing. Confidential to Beca: Please do not distribute externally without author approval Martin Wemyss 3 May 2018 Senior Technical Director - Beca Building Services 13 July 2017 . Tender / Contract Document make-up. Conditions of Tender (A)

rusty
Download Presentation

Specification Writing

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Specification Writing Confidential to Beca: Please do not distribute externally without author approval Martin Wemyss 3 May 2018 Senior Technical Director - Beca Building Services 13 July 2017

  2. Tender / Contract Document make-up • Conditions of Tender (A) • Conditions of Contract (B) • General Conditions; e.g. NZS 3910 • Special Conditions: Project specific clarifications/variations to General Conditions • Specifications (C) • C01: Preliminaries & General: Site safety management, traffic management, security, temporary facilities, … • C02, C03, … : Technical Specifications • Drawings & Schedules

  3. Beca (NZ) Specification Sections

  4. Building Services Spec Hierarchy Spec Workflow - Pg 2 • CXX Trade (Discipline): • General (CXX00) • Technical (CXXYY) • C45 & 46 • Building Services General & Seismic • Appendices (separate) • Common to all • Produced once (consistent) • By BS JM or WPM

  5. Specification Content • C45 & C46 – Building Services - General & Seismic • Rules for deviations from tender/contract documents • Construction phase set-out, coordination, quality control • General pre-manufacture submission, materials & workmanship requirements • Supports & fixings, seismic, fire stopping, painting, identification ….. • Testing, commissioning, handover, record drawings, O&M manuals, training of Principal • Digital information, BIM execution • Greenstar, LEED • Producer statements, 3rd party certification, defect liability, subcontract guarantees

  6. Specification Content • Trade Specific - General (CXX00) • Extent of work, contractor qualifications, rules for ambiguities / incompleteness, contractor design, trade interfaces …. • Pre-manufacture submissions; shop drawings, supplier certificates of compliance …. • Testing & commissioning processes & acceptance criteria • Trade Specific – Technical (CXXYY): For each system / proprietary equipment item: • Material specs, construction quality, performance rating methods, installation practice …. • Cited Standards / Codes of Practice • Functional descriptions (controls)

  7. Specification Value? • At least as important as Drawings and Schedules • Building Services: Say 30 – 40% of total contract information • Often higher value when things don’t go to plan ….. (next slide) • Construction monitoring routinely requires reference to specs • Failure to complete all construction design, set-out, coordination, submissions, T&C …. • Pre-manufacture submissions: Assessing system &/or proprietary equipment compliance • E.g. NZICC: • Cooling tower pipework arrangement (C1910) • Balancing valves (C1911), dampers and fire dampers (C1940) • Open drive chillers and plantroom ventilation (C1923) • Temporary filters (C1953) • Trade interfaces (when done well at the start!) • Client-requested brands; alternatives not permitted • Site inspections: Assessing installation practice compliance

  8. Specification Value • When things go wrong: • Devil often in the detail (like mortgage, loan, insurance contracts) • Spec content often crucial to determining responsibility / liability • Order of diminishing contractual significance: Specifics, General • Contract administrator / arbitrator / judge reads the fine print • DHW tempering valves in hospital ….. Had to be “fit for purpose”

  9. NZ / AU / SG Specs • One Beca • Global Beca Building Services spec proformas unlikely: • Differences in building codes, Standards, practices, brands, etc. • Resource intensive to coordinate & maintain global spec proforma • Resource intensive project specific editing • Regional specs: • NZ: CXX • AU: C(XX+50) • SG: Sections 1, 2, 3, …

  10. Specification Production

  11. Specification Production • How? • Spec writer completes Building Services Spec Setup Form • Admin creates 1st draft • Accept all tracked changes; leave set to continue tracking • Spec writer edits • Where from? • Under Dev – Usable (with care) • 00:\Specs • Under Dev – Not usable (w/o approval) of Spec Section Owner

  12. Building Services Spec Setup Form (NZ) • Brief to Spec creator • Records individual section source • Completed digital copy on file • Input to spec verification

  13. Hidden Text If you cant see on your screen, ask Editing instructions • Proven effective spec writing tool Technical Commentary Spec Content + Hidden Text • Often contain / reflect Beca design practice • Include in your: • Design toolset • Construction monitoring toolset; submission review, site inspections • Check latest proforma version(as opposed to project spec)

  14. Specification Writing - General Principles Avoid Repetition!! • Repetition increases: • Likelihood of contradiction / ambiguity • Potential for variation claims (“contra proferentem” common law) • Potential for Beca liability if contradiction / ambiguity not identified in time • CXX00.2 (EXTENT OF WORK): “Contractor is responsible for identifying ambiguity / incompleteness in Contract Documents, & obtaining clarification instructions prior to proceeding with affected work.” • DOES NOT relieve Beca of liability for ambiguity / incompleteness in our documents • In order to avoid, be familiar with: • C4500 BUILDING SERVICES - GENERAL • Avoids repetition in each TRADE Specific - GENERAL • TRADE Specific - GENERAL • Don’t repeat in TRADE specific Technical Sections

  15. Specification Writing - General Principles • Locate content where person needing information would expect to find it; e.g.: • Specialist equipment testing & commissioning by equipment supplier/agent: • In equipment technical section • BUT with cross-reference from [TRADE] - GENERAL - TESTING & COMMISSIONING • Identification (by trade subcontractors as opposed to equipment suppliers) • In C4521 – IDENTIFICATION • Specialist technical sections, e.g. Gas Piping: C1713 with X-ref to/from C4521 – IDENTIFICATION • Use “Provide” rather than “supply and install” • “Supply of all labour, materials and equipment for the specified design, selection/design of materials and equipment, setting out and co-ordination, submission of information, supply, fabrication, manufacture, installation, quality control, testing and commissioning and defects liability.” • Limit use of “supply” or “install” to where one party is supplying for another party to install.

  16. Specification Writing - General Principles • Typically separate: • “Materials” content – relevant to suppliers • “Installation” content – relevant to installers • Cross-referencing: • C45 & C46 • Auto-cross referencing to section title; may also include number • “Error reference source not found” • C17, C19, C20, C21 …. • X-ref to spec section title only (not numbers)

  17. Specification Writing Style Past writing style: • Long “essay” type sentences / paras • Often covering multiple topics • Difficult to scan & digest relevant content

  18. Specification Writing Style Preferred writing style: • Numbered headings, bullets • Use standard Beca Spec Styles; • Heading 2, 3, 4, 5, • Heading 4, 5 bullet • Body text, table text …. • Short succinct descriptions • Active rather than passive voice; • “Construct diverging tees such that ...” • Avoid “The Contractor shall…” (unless differentiating, e.g. between contractor & supplier)

  19. Citing Standards Each Spec Section • Global market  multiple standards • Standard Noonly; not title or date • Standards Index at end

  20. Citing Standards • C4505 - Reference Documents determines applicable version

  21. CXX00.2.2 - Extent of Work - Description • General • Minimises potential for conflict / ambiguity with Drawings & Specs • Alternative • Regional / market / trade specific drivers • Highly detailed descriptions should be avoided or very carefully written • Risk of effective exclusion by lack of specific inclusion (contra proferentem) Heating, ventilation and air-conditioning of lower ground to level 5 associated with refurbishment of existing office building at 132 Vincent Street. • New and modifications to existing HVAC systems at the refurbished and extended Northlands Shopping Centre, generally including but not necessarily limited to: • Packaged unit air conditioning and spill air systems in the new retail/mall extension area. • Split system air conditioning of the existing mall/arcade area excluding Foodcourt. (Mixed mode system with natural ventilation and supplementary spot mechanical cooling). • Split system air conditioning of those retail outlets in the existing retail/mall area that are not currently air conditioned. • Replacement of existing outdoor air supply system in existing retail/mall area with new system (including electric heating). • Removal of the existing non-operational Foodcourt packaged unit (1 of 4), and installation of the new (currently crated) replacement unit purchased by the Principal.

  22. CXX00.2.3 - Extent of Work – Specific Inclusions • Unusual / specific inclusions • Existing Systems - General • Alterations to operational systems • On-site checks • Demolition & removal • Liaison with Principal to minimise impact • ….. • Existing Systems – Specific • Scope clarification for • Alterations to Existing • Tenant Fitout • Reduces risk of effective exclusion by lack of specific inclusion

  23. CXX00.2.4 – Extent of Work, Contractor Design • Design continuum – Normally: • Construction Phase Design: • Selection of proprietary materials & equipment • Construction level set-out & coordination: • Pipework, ductwork, cable route details • Shop drawings • Proprietary system design: e.g. • BMS • Lighting control

  24. CXX00.2.4 – Extent of Work, Contractor Design Detail Design by contractor (alternative) • Can be appropriate in specific commercial circumstances • Partial: E.g. acoustics, E for M • All: E.g. SkyCIty Casino, NZICC? • Proformawords reasonably robust

  25. CXX00.2.3 – Extent of Work, Contractor Design “Design & Build” (alternative) • Refer “Guide – Building Services – Design Build Engagement & Documentation”: • No “standard” distribution of design responsibilities. • Could be handed over at various stages; varying degrees of risk • Beca JD/JM to discuss with client; overall objectives, documentation options • Documents include: • Client and stakeholder specific design requirements, e.g.; design guides, CAD standards. • Design / configuration / performance criteria, e.g.: • System capacity/performance/redundancy criteria • Distribution/control zones; air conditioning, lighting, fire alarm & evacuation • Energy/utility consumption characteristics & metering strategies • Materials and workmanship quality: Beca spec selections, e.g. pipe / duct / equipment pressure ratings? • Guidance on contract interface points; tenant connections, scope of other procurement contracts, utility metering, etc. • Schedule of exposed/visible items; reference photos to define the general appearance and finish quality.

  26. C4502 - Deviations from Tender/Contract Documents • Compliant tenders preferred • Tenders with alternatives (materials, equipment, workmanship, system designs or other matters of performance, construction, quality or space requirements) considered at Principal’s discretion • Tenders deemed to comply other than specifically listed deviations • Post-tender deviations (not identified in tender): • Deviations that “substantially differ” from Contract Documents • Principal reserves the right to reject & require Contractor to comply • May not be enforceable if Contractor can demonstrate compliance not practicable • “Substantially differ” is subjective; experienced judgement required • Not reasonable to reject out of hand all minor non-compliances: Some manufacturers may not be able to comply 100%, but may not be appropriate to exclude those manufacturers w/o consideration of significance of non-compliance

  27. C4502 - Deviations from Tender/Contract Documents • Post-tender deviations (Cont.): • If Contractor considers provides significant cost/technical advantages: • Contractor may submit: • Cost/technical advantages; supporting details & evidence • Latest acceptance / rejection date (to avoid Contract delay) • Beca to assess additional fees & time to evaluate • Principal may instruct Beca to evaluate, & accept or reject deviation at their discretion • Apply with care: • If contractor offers technical but no cost advantage, client may think we should evaluate at no additional cost. Unscrupulous contractors may try on with objective of pocketing cost advantage • Other consultant team members (also incurring cost) may resent our approach • Only activate for significant deviation for which we can readily convince client & others that additional Beca fees would be appropriate

  28. C4508 - Site Environment (Corrosion Classification) • Defines Exterior & Interior corrosion classifications • Consistent application across all trades • Referenced in Materials, Supports & Fixings, Painting, Trade technical specs • Exterior - General • Very High Marine • Very High Industrial • HighUp to 1km inland , Industrial within say 1 km • Medium 5-15 km inland • Low Inland • Exterior - Local micro-environments: • Sheltered exterior surfaces • Cooling tower compound • Within 10m of boiler flue discharge

  29. C4508 - Site Environment (Corrosion Classification) • Interior - General • Very Low: Commercial buildings; heated or air-conditioned & filtered • Low: Warehouses, sports halls, gymnasiums • Medium:Food processing plants, laundries, breweries, printing works, dairies • High:Dye works, paper manufacture, foundries, smelters, chemical processing, swimming pools • Interior - Local micro-environments • Builders work OA intake plenums / plantrooms • Ventilated plantrooms • Goods loading dock • Naturally ventilated atrium • Enclosed mechanically ventilated carparks • Naturally ventilated carparks

  30. Trade Names • C4509 – Materials: • Beca typically specify equipment performance (schedules) & quality (spec)Not brand or model type • Trade catalogue data is not binding • May list “preferred” or “acceptable” brands (but challenging to keep up) • May specifically limit to acceptable brands • Beca-wide; e.g. P&Dpipes • Project-specific; e.g. major equipment standardisation for institutional clients

  31. Pre-manufacture Certificates of Compliance • C4512.1 – Supplier’s Certificate of Compliance • Proprietary equipment / system supplier to: • Identify performance & quality compliance, exception or exceedance • Certify fit for purpose (Not all will) • Beca focus on assessing identified non-compliances (not trolling bulk product literature) • Helps contractor / subcontractors to retain supplier liability for contract non-compliances • C4512.2 – Spatial Certificates of Compliance • Contractor to certify equipment selected to comply with Contract requirements fits into spaces shown on Drawings with access and clearances as C4509 - MATERIALS • Objective: Identify spatial non-compliances in time to enable most appropriate solution (e.g. reselect material, revise spatial design) to be actioned with no or minimal abortive construction

  32. C4517 - Access & Protection Structures • Examples: • Access to high level AHUs in plantrooms. • Access/protection bridges/covers over pipe or cable systems • Protection barriers around exposed services in areas prone to physical damage • Where required but not shown on drawings, Contractor responsible for design • Clause applicable where: • need for or form of access / protection structures entirely dependent on Contractor’s construction phase services set-out • so cannot practicably be detailed on Architectural & Structural drawings • Don’t put too much reliance on this clause. (PI notification) • Consider SiD: Additional project specific spec words? (Trade specs)

  33. C4518 – Building Services Penetration Fire Stopping • Poor levels of compliance • Continual spec improvements • Construction monitoring engineers should become familiar with proper practice • Procurement options • Individual building services trades responsible for engaging fire stop specialist • Single fire stopping specialist for all building services trades: • Improved quality/compliance • But additional pricing risk • Refer C4518 & C47 commentary before applying • Excludes fire dampers • Excludes non-building services related fire stopping: • Floor, wall, cladding, partition construction joints

  34. C4529 - Defect Liability Period • Defect liability retentions available if contractor fails to reasonably rectify • Contractor & subcontractor joint liability • Contract Works excludes O&M during DLP • Otherwise, value must be retained beyond PC, retentions in trust, administered by Principal’s consultant team • Construction contractors often not qualified/experienced in maintenance work • C4532 requests separate maintenance contract proposal • Principle may or may not accept • Beca Design & CM fees don’t typically allow for maintenance contract setup or admin • Separable Portions • Potential for additional performance/compliance risk • Where SP boundaries cross building services distribution systems (heat, cooling, water supply, power, etc.), consider inter-dependence of system elements in different Separable Portions, e.g.: • AHU vs. distribution ductwork. • CHW plant vs AHUs coils, control valves, distribution piping, etc. • Refer C4529 Commentary • Option to extend DLP for 1st SPs to expire at end of DLP of last SP

  35. Subcontract Guarantees, Manufacturer’s Warranties • Subcontract Guarantees (C4531) • Longer than DLP • Beca NZS 3910 Contract: • Defines form of subcontract guarantees; e.g. joint and several. (Other Conditions of Contract may not.) • Suggests 2 year term for building services trades. • Likely to incur cost (relative to standard 1yr warranty) • No retentions, hence less risk protection than DLP • Discuss with client option of extending DLP • Manufacturer’s Warranties • Beca do not typically specify (exception is proprietary pipe systems; PPR, press-fit jointing) • Manufacturer’s warranties provide very limited protection • Beca typically advise Clients to NOT place significant reliance on manufacturer’s warranties

  36. Job Specific Editing Spec Workflow – Pg. 3 Delete non-applicable content • Contractors under time pressure during tendering • Incorrect / ambiguous / non-applicable content increases likelihood of; • Unpriced scope • Contractor indifference to entire specification

  37. Job Specific Editing • Non-applicable content examples: • Site Environment (C4508): “Sea Spray, Coastal, Inland, Industrial & Geothermal” • Both Short & Long form acceptance criteria • Low rise building: Expansion/Contraction allowances “specific to very tall structures (e.g. Sky Tower)” • Small project w/o seismic separations: Spec’d seismic flexibles & blank seismic movement table • Small project w/o builders work or kitchen extract ductwork; Spec’d builders work & kitchen extract duct pressure ratings and sealing • Non-applicable cable types, protection device types, light fitting types, etc. • Non-applicable design details and/or samples. • Required equipment sample where the contract required only one unit • Non-applicable Standard references • Specific cases may warrant some non-applicable content in anticipation of known or reasonably foreseeable work being included by future instruction

  38. Job Specific Editing & Verification • Spec Writers: • Expected to follow all hidden textinstructions • Self-check • Hidden text header: To aid VERIFICATION ….print Verification copies with HIDDEN text on & DELETED text in strikethrough • Spec verifiers: Check for • Deletion of non-applicable content • Remaining incompleteness / ambiguity

  39. Discipline specific training • Mechanical: On-the-job using hidden text • Electrical: G Williams + On-the-job (hidden text being expanded) • P&D, Gas: On-the-job using hidden text • Fire Protection: On-the-job using hidden text (needs expanding)

  40. END

More Related